Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Articles | Original Articles on Fanpop

4

posted by woofbark

Okay. I'm going TRY to be thorough, and express my reasons in a clear way. If there's something you think is wrong or incorrect, feel free to debate that point.

PART I:PLOT

The plot of the book is like the structure of a building-without it, the book is moot. Both HP and T have simple plots (Girl falls in love with a vampire, boy discovers he's a wizard).

However, HP (In my opinion) is unpredictable, whereas Twilight is very predictable.
In fact, (I swear this is true) I had a person who'd never read the Twilight books before, watched the movies, and had barely known the series existed, read book...

6

Why?

posted by PiperLunaPotter

Why do you like Harry Potter/Twilight?
I'm sorry, but I want to read something positive. Please, no fighting and number these. So, I'll go first.
-----
I like Harry Potter.

1. Hermione shows that girls can be smart and it's great if they are. None of the girls need a boy to survive. They can defend themselves. Harry and Ron do depend on Hermione for schoolwork. Ginny is accomplished at the Bat-Bogey Hex.
2. Harry is willing to sacrifice himself if it means his friends will survive.
3. Harry's is brave, but he still has emotion. When he goes into the forest in Ch. 34 (DH), he's scared, but he...

1

Team Harry

posted by one_a_kind4ever

In my last article I got some comments that stated that I didn't support my opinion so I will try again.

Harry Potter is definitely going to be a story that people are going to be telling 50 years from now. Harry Potter is a fun filled story taking place in a wizarding world as many of you know. Over the past couple of years it has been argued that Twilight is better. Us Harry Potter fans disagree because a 17 year old wizard who defeats a dark lord is WAY better than a sparkling 107 year old vampire virgin. I respect the fact that Twilight has fans as well that like Twilight for reasons we...

4

Things Twilight and HP both have...

posted by ariba_c

Not sure what to title this exactly:P

Anyways this was a comment on some forum here I cant remember and I liked it so decided to post it as an article. It was by Lumos_Maxima I believe.

You have Robert Pattison play Edward - we had him play Cedric. He even admitted to enjoying play Cedric more than Edward ;)

You have Jacob and Edward - we have Draco Malfoy and Blaise Zabini.

You have Bella Swan - we have Bellatrix Lestrange who could Avada Kedavra your Bella any day.

You have Jacob Black - we have Remus Lupin who is the real werewolf here. Jacob isn't even a werewolf, he's a shape shifter.

You have...

hermiones

posted by june13

we all knowed hermiones was one of harrys friends anyone who did not know her know her for a know it all over the years at hogwards she larned not to worry want everyone says about you and want you are in book five six and 7 we was showed want she could do that was not spells and every thing esl love she fell hard for one boy that was her freind ron and some us thougth that i =t was going to be harry or nelive over the ages she had kids and they turn out to be smart and good at hogwards to and we all thought that she would end up somewhere esl on the road

10

Harry Potter Errors

posted by Sophia21

Ah well, in the name of justice now I will take it a little bit against Harry Potter. For starters I will only mention consistency errors or plot mistakes. Scientific and lore mistakes will be included later. HEY! They are 7 very long books, and unlike Twilight were mistakes were easy to spot amongst the constant lovey-dovey of Bella and Edward, Harry Potter has a lot of information going around. Now then.

1)Where did Voldemort stick his wand?
Explanation: Yeah the title doesn't give a very nice image. But seriously. Voldemort went on a solo mission to kill the Potters and their baby. Due to...

1

What's better?

posted by pokerface22

Basically, I'm making this article to see which is better: Harry Potter or Twilight?

I want Twilight and Harry Potter fans to come up with reasons why the book they prefer is better. I will be making a list for each book's reasons. I will only post the valid reasons.

I will make sure they are valid and read each reason. I hope fans from both sides will make reasons here!

I'll start off both lists:

Harry Potter:
1. The plot is mentioned in the first chapter. Twilight's is mentioned at around 16 chapters in.

Twilight:
1. Twilight has sparked up arguments between twilighters and anti-twilighters. Some...

Honestly...

posted by RavenclawRocks

OK, I just got this message from somebody on this spot. They're a Twilight fan and I couldn'y help laughing. It's very pathetic.

Not naming any names, but this is a message somebody sent me:

It made me LOL when I saw somebody had to add Jessie J to their profile.

It made me LOL when I saw somebody had to add an "Edward is Cedric" reference in their motto.

It made me LOL when I saw somebody had to add Harry Potter to their profile.

It made me LOL when I saw somebody had to have an unoriginal Hermione and Ron icon.

My thoughts:
1)Yup, I like Jessie J. She's a great singer and I love her songs....

1

The famous Trio take a feild trip to Forks:)

posted by ImBooOK

One fine evening, as the famous trio Harry, Hermione and Ron, were in class they thought of an idea. "Professor Snape?" Harry raised his hand. The tall dark man turned, with that scorn as always on his face, sighing "What Potter?" Harry looked to his two friends and nodded. "May we take a feild trip?" Harry asked biting his lip. "A field trip? what in the name of slitheren is that?" Snape said with hardly no emotion. "It is where one or more classes take a day off of class to go and visit some other place to learn about different things, such as the places history or if they have museums we...

5

Letter to JK!!!!

posted by FredWRules

Hey guys, I was thinking of writing a letter to JKR, coz I have a question for her... Can you please give me your honest opinion on what you think of it, but no actual abuse? Thank you!

Dear Ms Rowling,
First may I say how much I love your books, it really felt like the characters were alive, like I was at Hogwarts.

Secondly, the other day I was thinking, and I was wondering, (sorry if this doesn't make much sense, but I'll try using Draco, Harry and Ron as an example) what would happen if Harry disguised himself as Draco using Polyjuice Potion, and Ron also wanted to disguise himself as Draco, and plucked hair out of Harry's head, thinking he was Draco, and then took the potion. What would happen, do you think?

On the envelope, I have written my address, and I am hoping you will reply, but fully understand if you don't.

Yours sincerely,

Andie Dircks.

35

So You Want to Be a Death Eater?

posted by BellaCullen96

Greetings, new follower:

If you are reading this letter then you have doubtless been accepted into the select band of professional wizards known as the Death Eaters. If by some unprecedented chance you are reading this and you have not been accepted into the Death Eaters then I suggest you put down this letter and leave now, or the consequences for you will be as terrible as my lifelong study into the Dark Arts can make them.

Please find enclosed a short introductory guide to Death Eating, which you must memorize and then eat, to prevent security leaks. (Due to an unfortunate fatality last week,...

1

JKR - as great as everyone thinks she is?

posted by emilykuru

Hey guys! I found this article written by someone on a website and I thought I would let you read it through. So im posting it.

first of all im a harry potter fan and i love jkr. and i think that this article is not sensible. but you all can read it to tell your views, so im posting it for you all to give your opinions.

This article shows out what position jkr holds in the heart of the author.
Sincere fans of jkr may get a bit annoyed by reading this, but for those who always thought she was a bit of …..well read it! Interesting view points have been brought out here!
So before you go on,...

1

Youknowit101's Justification.

posted by cassie-1-2-3

Hello.

*All credit goes to youknowit101. He's not familiar with html tags, so he asked me to perform all the fancy link tricks. All information was provided from him. Though, I did assist in editing; revising; and providing alternate wording, from this point on, you are hearing strictly from youknowit101.

Some of you do not approve of the recent images I have added to this spot. I claimed they were intended to provide a sense of balance to the obvious, unnecessary, counterproductive prejudice against Twilight. Here is a list of images I've added, accompanied by an opposing image against Twilight....

2

O Tempora o mores

posted by Aquilia

O Tempora o Mores
Oh the times, oh the customs

This article is an appeal to all Twilight fans out there, I invite you all to think over your good and bad actions here on fanpop and contemplate them.

I have seen and compared examples of the appearances of the fandoms Harry Potter and respectively Twilight when criticism appear in each other’s sites on fanpop and I am astounded by the comparatively aggressive tone the Twilight fans carried when they respond to the said criticism.

Compare the responses of: link

And: link ;

Notes are to be made that both internet addresses were found by searching...

4

Lost the Spark

posted by HecateA

This is my HP fanfiction, I hope I'm allowed to post it here. If it belongs on the HP spot I'll move it. This is my first HP fanfiction so have mercy on me and I hope you enjoy it!

Disclaimer: I own no characters but Erica, Nathaly, Van, Veola and Harbeck

To: All the muggleborns who are still waiting for that letter

I looked at the picture of the 3 laughing kids. These 3 kids were killing themselves, and they were moving. I could name them. My sister’s friends. Veola Madgey, a girl with blond flowing hair and flowers placed here and there, her cheeks full and face cheerful; Van Teeje a tough...

9

What happened Next

posted by FredWRules

Harry Potter married Ginny Weasley. They had three children, James Sirius, Albus Severus, and Lily Luna. He became head of the Auror’s Department under Kingsley Shacklebolt.

Ginny Weasley played quidditch for the Holyhead Harpies. After deciding to raise a family, she retired and became Senior Quidditch correspondent at the Daily Prophet.

Hermione Granger married to Ron Weasely and had two children, Rose and Hugo. Hermione went back to Hogwarts and sat her NEWTS before working for Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures and helping house elves. She then moved to the...

7

An appology (from KatyLautner)

posted by KatyLautner

Hey, it's me KatyLautner. I just wanted to say, I'm sorry to all Harry Potter fans and anyone I may have offended. I didn't mean to make any enemies, and I never ment for it to go this far.

We all have our opinions, people like what they like. And I should accept that a lot of you are Harry Potter fans, and that's cool with me now. I hope all you accept that me and a lot of other people are Twilight fans.

Sorry if I called you or any of your friends a nerd, a bitch, or anything else I may have said that offended you in any way.

I'm not saying I wasn't offended, because I was. But most of the people who offended me appologized, so I'm good with them now.

I think a lot of us have lost sight about what this spot is for. Debating, talking about which book is better. Our opinions.

So, I'd like to start over. I'll try to give more detailed and valid reasons why I think the way I do. I hope you forgive me, and want to start over as well.

xoxo,
Jade

1

Google: Twilight or Harry Potter?

posted by harrypotterbest

So today I was searching stuff (mostly HP related) on google, right? And I get this idea, 'I wonder what google like's more - HP or Twilight.'
Test one
So I put in 'is Twilight' and one of the options was 'a good book.' So then I put in 'is Harry Potter' and the first option was real. And the 3 was 'and the deathly hallows in 3d.'
Test two (first two options)
'Harry Potter is'
better than Twilight
my life
'Twilight is'
like soccer
my life
But... the last option was 'terrible.'
Test 3 (last 3 options)
'Edward Cullen is'
an abusive boyfriend
abusive
real
'Ron Wealey is'
our king
hot
an idiot
Test 4 (first 4)
'Bella Swan is'
a mary-sue
a bad role model
Stephenie Meyer
annoying
'Hermione Granger is'
hot
played by
adopted
Test 5 (last option)
'Voldemort is'
awesome
'Volturi are'
Which Volturi are you
...
So now tell me. Which one do you think Google likes better? Twilight or HP?

A Little Rant By Me

posted by VampiresRevenge

Okay, I should start this off by saying that I am a fan of both Harry Potter and Twilight, but I am a bigger fan of Harry Potter. Why am I telling you this, you ask? Because this article is going to sound a lot like I am defending Twilight, which I am, and trashing on the Harry Potter, which I am not. Now that that's out of the way...

Okay. Earlier, I was in the Harry Potter spot, and I saw a rather shocking comment in one of the picks: "I cant think of an overrated harry potter character- overrated is over on the Twilight spot- he he." This sparked my interest. Is there anything else in the...

16

Article for Twilight Fans.

posted by andierox13

Okay, So I am just going to re-do this. I re-read the previous one and I realize I lacked in giving reasons why the Twilight Saga kicks ass compared to the Harry Potter Series.

Let's just break this down now. Take a look at Edward, some people thinks he stalks Bella? I am here to tell you that is false. He does not stalk her at all, he feels it is his duty to protect her because a life without her would be no life at all. I read some of your comments on the previous article and I would like to say that he DOES NOT fall in love with her because she 'smells yummy' that is why he is attracted...