answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

Harry Potter-ers: What do you like least about Hp?Twilight-ers: What do you like least about Twilight?

Yeah, I know it's hard, but I always thought a true fan could admit flaws in their chosen fandom.
It can be something as simple as "I don't like the way JK uses the word 'said' a lot"
Good luck!
 LoopyLuna96 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

TeamSiriusBlack said:
HP: That they didn't say what happened to Lune :(
Twilight: That they ended the series with Bella and Edward making out, and that there are plot holes. (Personally I don't like the series)
select as best answer
HP: That they didn't say what happened to Lune :(
Twilight: That they ended the series with Bella and Edward making out, and that there are plot holes. (Personally I don't like the series)
posted over a year ago 
*
Nice icon. That would be Snape. He looks closer to a vampire than the Twi-folk do.
Persephone713 posted over a year ago
*
Lol so true
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
She marries Newt Salamander's grandson
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
CullenProperty said:
In the Twilight Series, I didn't like how there was barely anything said about Emmett, Carlisle, Esem or Jasper. How it was kinda all centered around Edward, Bella, Alice & Jacob. Although I love them, it would have been nice to see parts of the other's lives too. Especially Emmett, Stephenie Meyeres didn't write about Emmett's past at all. :( Made me sad.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
True! but it did say that Rosalie saved Emmett from a grizzley bear :)
NCISLuverjk93 posted over a year ago
*
Yeah, but... it didn't say anything of his past or anything... before he was human. :(
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
Er... yeah, your right NCSILuver. :) Well of course they're his fave, I mean if something is gonna attack you in a former life, why not go back at them in your next one? :)
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
NCISLuverjk93 said:
For the record I love both series' but there are a few things I didnt like...

Twilight: I just disliked how it ended, it was just Too happy... also Bella kissing Jacob pissed me off, but thats mere opinion.

Harry Potter: I didnt like Harry& Ginny getting together, Sorry! I just didnt like it, and also some parts of the books I had to skip when reading the book again because the part bored me.

But all in all I love all the books from both Series'! <3
select as best answer
For the record I love both series' but there are a few things I didnt like... 

Twilight: I just disliked how it ended, it was just Too happy... also Bella kissing Jacob pissed me off, but thats mere opinion.

Harry Potter: I didnt like Harry& Ginny getting together, Sorry! I just didnt like it, and also some parts of the books I had to skip when reading the book again because the part bored me. 

But all in all I love all the books from both Series'! <3
posted over a year ago 
*
The ending of Twilight was too happy, I wasn't satisfied with that either.
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
so didnt like the harry and ginny pairing either
Ash24 posted over a year ago
*
^^^ At least some people agree with me :P
NCISLuverjk93 posted over a year ago
BellaCullen96 said:
The only thing I didn't like about HP was the love sheild thing, because the books keep saying that Harry was the only one to survive the Killing Curse, because Lily had died to save him, but I doubt that Lily was the first person to do so.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Im confused at what you meant. Harry is the only survivor of the AV curse but yes you are probably right that Lily wasnt the first to sacrifice her life for a loved one. Is that what your saying?
Persephone713 posted over a year ago
*
yeah
BellaCullen96 posted over a year ago
*
the prophecy helped save harry, it wasnt just her love it was the fact she begged voldemort to kill her
jodarchy posted over a year ago
Persephone713 said:
BellatrixBlack is going to kill me, but okay. I wish somewhere Bellatrix let her shield down and said for herself like in a rage by accident or something " I hate Roldolphus, I only married him to stay in the family Cissy. My heart belongs to The Dark Lord." - best paraphrase I could do. She gives subtle hints but. It would have been nice for her to blab about it. Like she does, cant keep her trap shut. LOL.
select as best answer
BellatrixBlack is going to kill me, but okay. I wish somewhere Bellatrix let her shield down and said for herself like in a rage by accident or something " I hate Roldolphus, I only married him to stay in the family Cissy. My heart belongs to The Dark Lord." - best paraphrase I could do. She gives subtle hints but. It would have been nice for her to blab about it. Like she does, cant keep her trap shut. LOL.
posted over a year ago 
*
I love the picture.
DivyaHarry posted over a year ago
ThatDamnLlama said:
In the Goblet of Fire, I hate it how Ron is mad at Harry when his name got into the goblet. I mean, it's obvious he wouldn't be able to do it. They are friends. Ron should've stuck my Harry's side to whole time.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree with that, but it turned out good like how it showed Harry was basically lost without Ron, and how much he meant to him :)
NCISLuverjk93 posted over a year ago
*
yeah, but i think it never should've happened in the first place. if Ron was a real friend, he would've believed Harry and stuck with him through the hardship of being a Triwizard champion.
ThatDamnLlama posted over a year ago
*
i hated that too,
Ash24 posted over a year ago
lilith84 said:
I Harry Potter, I hated the fact that Ron and Hermione got together. But more than that, I hated the way Severus Snape died. If it was up to me, he would either stay alive or at least died in a more heroic way.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
DivyaHarry said:
Harry Potter: Only 7+3 books. No. JKR, I want more.

Twilight (not a fan): 4 books!. Smeyer, why didn't you just shoot Bella and get it over with in the first book?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
The encyclopedia is coming up! :D
Athiya posted over a year ago
*
Waiting for it. :)
DivyaHarry posted over a year ago
*
Can't wait for that! =)
silverandgreen7 posted over a year ago
italiangirl976 said:
In Twilight I hated that they had a baby, that Jacob imprinted with that baby(ewwww...Can you say pedophile?), and how the vampires sparkle.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
lmao a pedophile werewolf XD
hpfreak14 posted over a year ago
*
^ Pedowolf! Italiangirl1976, those are actually two of the things I hated the most too... But I'm an anti.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
hpfreak14 said:
Harry Potter - my favorite characters died. It kind of annoyed me how many people died. It did create a emotional connection with the book but all those people who died got kind of upsetting


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah Me too! :(
joose32 posted over a year ago
*
yes, i cried when Snape and Fred died! So sad):
gothgrl3249 posted over a year ago
*
i know man i hated that tonks died ( she was one of my favourites)
jodarchy posted over a year ago
XXCissyXX said:
In HP I really don't like the fact that Ron and Hermione ended up together. I like Ron, I like Hermione but they seem just like brother and sister to me... :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
silverandgreen7 said:
Harry Potter: The Epilogue *sucks*...Maybe it would have been better without it. More room for imagination or something...Or it could have been different! I don't know about everyone else, but the Epilogue was pretty horrible. =S
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Renesmee_XD said:
I don't like the way Twilight was written.
I mean that the Host is written much better.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
KatiiCullen94 said:
with Twilight
i hated how with Isle Esme, how she was too shy to write a sex scene.. like if a friend tells about a sex scene a book she is reading i read that part,.. i like to see how sabby its written LOL the "whole sailor wife with his long hair" that whole crap.
and how she says virtue, not virginity,, its like this is a teenage book,... talk in this era for one second
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
vskparaimer said:
Of HP, I hate the fact that so many people died (especially in the 7th part like Snape and Fred, and Sirius in OoP, and Dumbledore in HBP), but at the same time it didn't stop me luving HP.
I'm an anti if talking about Twilite so i won't talk about it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
XDRoseLuvsHP said:
I'd have to say Slytherin.

Why are all Slytherin's evil?

Except Snape, of course, but Dumbledore said he would have put him in Gryffindor anyway. Other than that, none of them do anything good.

Why? :(

(Just want to add, NOT ALL HUFFLEPUFFS ARE LAME! Tonks was a Hufflepuff after all, so don't tell me all Hufflepuffs are lame unless you have reasonings as to why Tonks is lame. Kaythankyou!)
select as best answer
I'd have to say Slytherin.

Why are all Slytherin's evil?

Except Snape, of course, but Dumbledore said he would have put him in Gryffindor anyway. Other than that, none of them do anything good.

Why? :(

(Just want to add, NOT ALL HUFFLEPUFFS ARE LAME! Tonks was a Hufflepuff after all, so don't tell me all Hufflepuffs are lame unless you have reasonings as to why Tonks is lame. Kaythankyou!)
posted over a year ago 
*
Whoo! Thanks for sticking up for us Hufflepuffs! :D!
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
*
Go Hufflepuff! We're cool.
LoopyLuna96 posted over a year ago
*
tonks was awesome
jodarchy posted over a year ago
next question »