Lord of the Rings Survival Game

swifferkramer posted on Jul 17, 2007 at 07:03PM
This game decides who out of the fellowship will survive and who will die.

1. All characters start with 15 points.
2. Anyone can cast a vote adding (++) or subtracting (--) from any character.
3. You vote for 3 characters at a time.
4. When any character's total reaches 0, he/she is eliminated.
5. When half of the field is eliminated, you can only put in a vote of one (+), but the two negatives remain the same (--). This is just so the game doesn't last forever.
6. You can't vote for only one person. For example, you can't just deduct 6 points from Stanley, you must add or subtract from 3 different people.
7. Also, no voting over and over and over again within a short time span (i.e. 10 minutes). Give some other people a chance to cast their votes, too.

Please post your vote along with the standings of the characters in rank order. This helps immensely with all the math and keeps everything in line.


Frodo: 15
Sam: 15
Pippin: 15
Merry: 15
Aragorn: 15
Legolas: 15
Gimli: 15
Boromir: 15
Gandalf: 15

Lord of the Rings 53 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 53

over a year ago R-S-Lee said…
Frodo -- (Kind of Boring)
Gimli ++ (Action star and Comic Relief)
Merry ++ (Power to the hobbits)

Merry: 17
Gimli: 17
Sam: 15
Pippin: 15
Aragorn: 15
Legolas: 15
Boromir: 15
Gandalf: 15
Frodo: 13
over a year ago swifferkramer said…
Frodo: - (Betrayed Sam and tried to keep the ring)
Aragorn: ++
Boromir: + (Fought Hard to save the hobbits in the first)

Merry: 17
Gimli: 17
Aragorn: 17
Boromir: 16
Sam: 15
Pippin: 15
Legolas: 15
Gandalf: 15
Frodo: 12
over a year ago R-S-Lee said…
Frodo: --
Gimli: ++
Merry: ++

Merry: 19
Gimli: 19
Aragorn: 17
Boromir: 17
Sam: 15
Pippin: 15
Legolas: 15
Gandalf: 15
Frodo: 9
over a year ago meeee said…
Gandalf++
Aragorn++
Merry++


Merry: 21
Gimli: 19
Aragorn: 19
Boromir: 17
Sam: 15
Pippin: 15
Legolas: 15
Gandalf: 17
Frodo: 9
over a year ago R-S-Lee said…
Merry ++
Gimli ++
Sam ++

Merry: 23
Gimli: 21
Aragorn: 19
Boromir: 17
Gandalf: 17
Sam: 17
Pippin: 15
Legolas: 15
Frodo: 9
over a year ago Sivan325 said…
Legolas ++
Gimli ++
Merry --

Gimli: 23
Merry: 21
Aragorn: 19
Legolas: 17
Boromir: 17
Gandalf: 17
Sam: 17
Pippin: 15
Frodo: 9
over a year ago Jillywinkles said…
Boromir ++ (omg I cried when he died)
Gandalf ++ (how can you not love Ian Mckellan)
Frodo -- (yeah let's kill him off)


Gimli: 23
Merry: 21
Aragorn: 19
Boromir: 19
Gandalf: 19
Legolas: 17
Sam: 17
Pippin: 15
Frodo: 7
over a year ago ILoveZane said…
Boromir ++ (omg I cried when he died)
Gandalf ++ (how can you not love Ian Mckellan)
Frodo -- (yeah let's kill him off)


Gimli: 24
Merry: 21
Aragorn: 19
Boromir: 19
Gandalf: 19
Legolas: 16
Sam: 17
Pippin: 15
Frodo: 5

Frod --
Gimli +
Aragon ++
Legolas -
over a year ago RainbowGeek819 said…
Legolas ++ (the gay dude XD)
Merry + (CHARLIE!!!)
Frodo-- (Drama Queen ¬¬)



Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Aragorn: 19
Boromir: 19
Gandalf: 19
Legolas: 18
Sam: 17
Pippin: 15
Frodo: 3
over a year ago Prodigy said…
frodo --(so dull)
sam --(dull's partner
gandlaf -- (magical and interesting)
over a year ago zuntiz said…
frodo -- (I guess that he is killed now)
boromir ++
merry ++

over a year ago king_wa said…
Pippin ++
Gandalf ++
Boromir --

Gimli: 24
Merry: 25
Aragorn: 29
Boromir: 19
Gandalf: 19
Legolas: 18
Sam: 15
Pippin: 17
Frodo: Eliminated
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
Aragorn ++ (crazy super special awesomeness)
Sam ++ (totally the coolest hobbit plus he's losing)
Merry -- (still awesome just my least favorite out of these)

Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Aragorn: 31
Boromir: 19
Gandalf: 19
Legolas: 18
Sam: 17
Pippin: 17
over a year ago i_luv_angst said…
Sam ++ (Sam can't die - he's the best character)
Pippin ++ (LOVE Pippin!!)
Boromir -- (angst on you, Boromir)

Aragorn: 31
Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Gandalf: 19
Sam: 19
Pippin: 19
Legolas: 18
Boromir: 17
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago alexapetrelli said…
Aragorn ++ [Phwoar]
Boromir --
Pippin ++

Aragorn: 33
Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Pippin: 21
Gandalf: 19
Sam: 19
Legolas: 18
Boromir: 15
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
Gandalf ++ (radically awesome wizard)
Legolas ++ (radically awesome elf)
Aragorn -- (he is my favorite but he has a ton of points he can afford to lose and i don't wanna take anything away from sam or boromir or anyone else with a low score!)

Aragorn: 31
Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Pippin: 21
Gandalf: 21
Sam: 19
Legolas: 20
Boromir: 15
over a year ago alexapetrelli said…
Boromir -- [he tried to take the ringn from Frodo, that's a no-no]
Aragorn ++ [made of awesomeness]
Pippin ++ [Scottish accent love <3]

Aragorn: 33
Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Pippin: 23
Gandalf: 21
Sam: 19
Legolas: 20
Boromir: 13
over a year ago makintosh said…
Legolas --
Gandalf ++
Pippin ++

Aragorn: 33
Gimli: 24
Merry: 23
Pippin: 25
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 19
Legolas: 18
Boromir: 13
over a year ago alexapetrelli said…
big smile
Aragorn ++
Boromir --
Merry ++

Aragorn: 35
Gimli: 24
Merry: 25
Pippin: 25
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 19
Legolas: 18
Boromir: 11
over a year ago i_luv_angst said…
wink
Legolas ++ (My fave character in the books)
Pippin ++ (Cuz he's such a fool of a Took)
Boromir -- (Someone has to die and Boromir is an angsty fellow....which is sometimes okay but not when it involves stealing from an innocent Hobbit)

Aragorn: 35
Pippin:27
Merry:25
Gandalf: 23
Legolas:20
Sam: 19
Boromir: 9
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
smile
Sam ++ (cuz he's simply awesome!)
Legolas ++ (also cuz he's simply awesome)
Merry -- (love him he's just my least favorite out of these)

Aragorn: 35
Pippin: 27
Merry: 23
Gandalf: 23
Legolas: 22
Sam: 21
Boromir: 9
over a year ago alexapetrelli said…
heart
Boromir --
Pippin ++
Sam ++

Aragorn: 35
Pippin: 29
Merry: 23
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 23
Legolas: 22
Boromir: 7
over a year ago i_luv_angst said…
Boromir -- (Die, Boromir!! You can't forget your place, silly! This is the fate Tolkien meant for you!)
Aragorn -- (Cuz you look so silly at your coronation)
Legolas ++ (Hey, you guys can't kill off my favorite character! That wouldn't be very nice at all!)

Wow I was more negative than positive today....I must be having a bad day...

Aragorn: 33
Pippin: 29
Legolas: 24
Merry: 23
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 23
Boromir: 5
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
smile
Merry -- (he makes me angsty when he says he'll work for theoden. "please. i have a sword." augh he's so small and serious! he looks like he's proposing to theoden!)
Sam ++ (he rox my sox!)
Pippin ++ (he also rox my sox

Aragorn: 33
Pippin: 31
Legolas: 24
Merry: 21
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 25
Boromir: 5
over a year ago emmoa said…
Legolas: ++ (cause he´s the elf)
Gimli: ++ (cause he´s the dwarf)
Boromir: ++ (he tries to help his little brother when it comes to their father)

Aragorn: 33
Pippin: 31
Legolas: 26
Gimli: 26
Merry: 21
Gandalf: 23
Sam: 25
Boromir: 7

(I belive someone forgot Gimli on the way)
over a year ago i_luv_angst said…
Legolas: ++
Boromir: -- (seriously, dude. It's time to go)
Aragorn: -- (cuz your speech isn't anywhere near as good as Theoden's!!)

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 31
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 26
Sam: 25
Gandalf: 23
Merry: 21
Boromir: 5
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
smile
Aragorn: -- (he can afford to lose points...)
Boromir: -- (i love you, but you've got to go sometime...)
Sam: ++ (go samwise!)

Aragorn: 29
Pippin: 31
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 26
Sam: 27
Gandalf: 23
Merry: 21
Boromir: 3
over a year ago green79 said…
meh
Sam: ++
Aragorn: ++
Boromir:--

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 31
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 26
Sam: 29
Gandalf: 23
Merry: 21
Boromir: 1

I can't believe that Frodo got eliminated first! What's wrong with Frodo??
over a year ago TmoVie_obsessed said…
Boromir: - (i love him but he was about to go anyway)
Pippin: ++
Sam: ++ (i was just rewatching LOTR the other day and I realized how awesome Sam was again)

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 26
Sam: 31
Gandalf: 23
Merry: 21
Boromir: ELIMINATED
over a year ago green79 said…
Merry: --
Gandalf: -- (I like Merry and Gandalf but they're probably my least fav. out of the people that are left)
Sam: ++

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 26
Sam: 33
Gandalf: 21
Merry: 19
over a year ago LBSinger said…
Legolas: ++ (my fav <3)
Sam: --
Gimli: --

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 30
Gimli: 24
Sam: 31
Gandalf: 21
Merry: 19
over a year ago TmoVie_obsessed said…
Merry: ++
Gandalf: --
Gimli: --

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 30
Gimli: 22
Sam: 31
Gandalf: 19
Merry: 21
over a year ago green79 said…
smile
Gandalf: --
Legolas: -- (He can afford to lose some points)
Sam: ++

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 22
Sam: 33
Gandalf: 17
Merry: 21
over a year ago TmoVie_obsessed said…
Gandalf: --
Gimli: --
Merry: ++

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 33
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 20
Sam: 33
Gandalf: 15
Merry: 23
over a year ago London said…
tongue
Legolas: ++ (my favorite character)
Sam: --(refused to call"Mr.Frodo" just Frodo)
Pippin: ++(ingenious plan to go South towards Isengard)

Aragorn: 31
Pippin: 35
Legolas: 30
Gimli: 20
Sam: 31
Gandalf: 15
Merry: 23
over a year ago ring-bearer said…
pippin ++ because he helps keep up the moral
Boromir -- because he tried to steal the ring
Aragorn ++ because i love him!

Aragorn 35
Pippin 33
Legolas 26
Gimli 26
Merry 21
Sam 25
Boromir 5

(AND JUST TO LET YOU KNOW,spikes_girl, MERRY IS A GOOD PERSON. HE WANTED TO HELP THEODEN!)
over a year ago green79 said…
Sam: ++
Gandalf: --
Legolas: --

Aragorn: 33
Pippin: 37
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 20
Sam: 33
Gandalf: 13
Merry: 23

ring-bearer I think you got a bit confused.
-Boromir has already been eliminated.
-You forgot about Gandalf.
-You mixed up all of the points of people. I fixed it on mine though. Maybe you didn't understand but you take all of the points that everyone was at in the last person's comment and then say you gave Sam ++ you would give him 2 more points and so on.
over a year ago JAlanaE said…
Gandalf: ++
Aragorn: ++
Merry: --

Aragorn: 35
Pippin: 37
Legolas: 28
Gimli: 20
Sam: 33
Gandalf: 15
Merry: 21
over a year ago razz4499 said…
Legolas: --
Gandalf: ++
Pippin: ++

Pippin: 39
Aragorn: 35
Sam: 33
Legolas: 26
Merry: 21
Gimli: 20
Gandalf: 17
over a year ago elmo01 said…
Aragorn ++
Gandalf ++
Gimli --

Pippin: 39
Aragorn: 37
Sam: 33
Legolas: 26
Merry: 21
Gandalf: 19
Gimli: 18
over a year ago Wow_Nightelf said…
Gimli ++ (awesome fighting skills)
Legolas ++ (Again, awesome fighting skills)
Gandalf -

Pippin:39
Aragorn:37
Sam:33
Legolas:28
Marry:21
Gimli:20
Gandalf:18
over a year ago terhenetar said…
Pippin --
Aragorn ++
Legolas ++

Pippin:37
Aragorn:39
Sam:33
Legolas:30
Marry:21
Gimli:20
Gandalf:18
over a year ago amy535 said…
Sam: ++
Gandalf: --
Giml: --

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 39
Sam: 35
Legolas: 30
Merry: 21
Giml: 18
Gandalf: 16
over a year ago DracoLuver said…
Gandalf: ++ (for coming back for the Hobbits and ensuring their safety.)
Aragorn: ++ (for being a fierce leader and not giving up when Merry and Pippin were taken)
Legolas: -- (I love him to death and I'm even "married" to him, but I think the others had more important roles. I still adore him though)

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 41
Sam: 35
Legolas: 28
Merry: 21
Gimli: 18
Gandalf: 20
over a year ago cheekimunkei said…
can't pick! can't pick!!!!!!
over a year ago JAlanaE said…
Gandalf: ++
Aragorn: ++
Merry: --

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 43
Sam: 35
Legolas: 28
Merry: 19
Gimli: 18
Gandalf: 22
over a year ago cheekimunkei said…
Merry: ++! my fave of the hobbits!
Aragorn: ++
legolas: ++

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 45
Sam: 35
Legolas: 30
Merry: 21
Gimli: 18
Gandalf: 22
over a year ago BelleAnastasia said…
Merry: --
Aragorn: ++
Legolas: ++

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 47
Sam: 35
Legolas: 32
Merry: 19
Gimli: 18
Gandalf: 22
over a year ago JAlanaE said…
Gandalf: ++
Aragorn: ++
Merry: --

Pippin: 37
Aragorn: 49
Sam: 35
Legolas: 32
Merry: 17
Gimli: 18
Gandalf: 24
over a year ago Midnightsun564 said…
smile
Pippin++(My favorite hobbit. You gotta love Pippin)
Aragorn++
Gimli++

Pippin: 39
Aragorn: 51
Sam: 35
Legolas: 32
Merry: 17
Gimli: 20
Gandalf: 24