Sort by:  Recently Created | Most Popular

Best King Herod Tied! Joshua Mostel 25% Rik Mayall 25%

Best Pontius Pilate The fans pick: Barry Dennen Barry Dennen 80% Rob Fowler 20%

Best Mary The fans pick: Yvonne Elliman Yvonne Elliman 80% Sara Bareilles 20%

Best Jesus The fans pick: Ted Neeley Ted Neeley 100% Ian Gillan 0%

Best Judas? The fans pick: Carl Anderson Carl Anderson 40% Tim Minchin 20%

Is it just me, or does this musical make Jesus more human instead of divine? The fans pick: Yes, totally agree! Yes, totally agree! 80% Nah, he&# 39; s still divine 20%

Who was a better Apostle? The fans pick: Peter Peter 63% Judas 38%