LETS SAY AFTER 10 YEARS IF THEY DECIDED TO REMAKE THE TWLIGHT MOVIES WHO WOULD MAKE A GREAT CARLISE JOSH HARNETT OR RYAN REYNOLDS

First of all ...why are you yelling? lol Second of all...to me it would depend how well Ryan Reynolds or Josh Hartnett look in 10 yrs...remember Carlisle is suppose to be in his mid 20s so they would have to look good AND young. And thinking about it...would Ryan Reynolds be able to be serious and compassionate that is required to play Carlisle? I totally think he's good looking...but he always seems to play the comedic smart ass...you know what I mean?

well look ryan reynolds and josh hartnett is nothing like carlisle character...they just don't fit!!!!

I think is Ryan Reynolds.