Ceaser?

Charcoal Bakes?

Charlie Coal?

I'm gonna stop geussing now.

You just filled an entire page... I don't think that's quite fair to the other players... It's one guess at the time, we don't start throwing in a bunch of pony names randomly. It's just an observation, no offense.

:T you just searched pony names and filled some pages...no fair...

um..Fancy Pants? Prince Blueblood? (scratch that..its not him) how about that pianist at the Grand Galloping Gala with Octavia and the rest? i think its Frederick

There's a stallion that's always with Fluttershy. I think his name is Mr. Greenhooves.

Okay. I made this one hard too ^ ^". All answers were wrong...

Uh, should I just tell everyone who it is? I don't want anymore trouble...

Sure.

It's Sir Colton Vines III. Colton / Goldengrape. He's my favorite and he appears with Daisy a lot.

Ok, since no one got it correct, you can go again.

Or since you're taking too long, I'll go. I am thinking of a blue pony.

Dashie?

No. Even though Rainbow Dash is my favorite pony of all time, I am thinking of someone else.

Understandable, she's one of my favorites too. All right, is it Trixie?

No, but she is a unicorn. You should be getting close.

Hmm... blue unicorn... Is it Colgate?

Vinyl Scratch? Her mane is blue. Sorta.

dang..Mirage got it first! xD i was gonna answer that too~

Twilight? (oh,right...alicorn now..) well then i guess im with Lyra ^^''

No it was Colgate. Good work Mirage

Yay! Okay, I'm thinking of an earth pony now.

Big McIntosh

Apple Bloom

Apple Bloom is the correct answer.

I just got back from guitar practice.

How was it? :)

Good.

Ok now we just gotta wait for Izfankirby.

Oh, ok I'm thinking of an earth pony

Bonbon

...no

Pinkie Pie?

No, we have seen this earth pony in one episode

Photo Finish.

no this particular episode was from season 1

Cheerilee?

Photo Finish is from season 1.

Diamond Tiara?

Could be Sapphire Shores too...

Hoity Toity?

Pinkie's dad?

Doctor Whooves/Time Turner? I knew it had to be a first appearance, and it had to be a background pony. I will be surprised if my guess is right, but the fact that the Giants of the NFL started 0-6 is even more surprising.

Also, I put both names for the pony I chose as my guess because both were created by the fandom. If I'm right, use the name you're familiar with.

My other guess would have been Apple Bloom, but I didn't think it was a mainstay character.

Doctor Whooves is has been in more then one episode though. I don't think your answer will be correct.

No, none of those.

Apple Jack? Golden Delicious? or Carrot Top?

My only other guess is Applejack's uncle. Oh, Celestia, what's his name... Uncle Orange! That's it.

Nope this particular earth pony is female

Mrs. Cake?

I'm thinking of a unicorn.

A light blue unicorn.

No, she's an earth pony. (Feel free to ask a question to get closer)