And killed by an effin snake bite, how the hell is that right? He was such a complex and amazing man, if he HAD to die, it should've been honorably, like in battle.
posted over a year ago
Loved your "amen"! If seriously, you're right if he had to die, there should have been another death - as a hero!
Oh, it's a very long explanation for each. If you are really interested, message me and I'll explain. For now, let's leave it at the fact that I REALLY hate them, and I have a reason to.
It's WAY too long and I'm not really sure I feel like typing it all out again, so if you're THAT curious, message me with the question and I'll answer you. For now, it's WAY too long to write, especially in a comment.
Sirus, he was my fav character. I always wished for him to return. And by the way, they didn't made the things right on the movie, they did a stupid death moment for him. Hated the 5th movie because of that. --'
Fred's death was also one of the saddest, he was just noticing that Percy made a joke, and then.. Poor Fred. :'
posted over a year ago
i had to leave the part when sirius dies i couldnt bare to watch it as i new i would have broken down. i waited till i got home and yea i cried but they ruined the moment
i didn't like any of the deaths, but i understand that some of them was necessary for the plot... so the ones i think doesn't really change anything are the death of Fred, Lupin, Tonks and Hedwih.. (and of course there r more from the battle but i didn't cry about them or sth..) however,except the four i mentioned, i'm not gonna forgive rowling for killing sirius!!
I think that all of the deaths made sense except one: Fred Weasley. He was one of my favourite characters and I would have loved to see him live. George just isn't the same without Fred.
dobby!!! it was just totally unnecessary and malicious!!! oh, and hedwig.. i mean really, she killed off THE BIRD?!?! you've got to be kidding me... actually now that i think about it, a lot of the deaths were just totally pointless.....
posted over a year ago
i agree that she shouldn't have killed dobby but his death wasn't pointless.. if he hadn't died harry would have learnt bout aberforth helping him and harry wouldn't probably have made those decisions...
Here's for whom I cried (which means I want them alive): Cedric, Dumbledore, Sirius, Mad - Eye, Hedwig, Dobby, Fred (I was sobbing until I couldn't see the letters anymore; the same with Dobby and the rest of them), Snape (duhhh!), Lupin and Tonks!!!
But I know J.K. had a reason to kill them, so...
Hedwig,Fred, Tonks and Lupin. Oh and Dobby too. Instead Kreacher can. Severus absolutely deserved an honourable death. I was so shocked when he died *tears*.......
Fred. Nobody should loose a twin. Why did she have to kill a twin? George will be a alone. I would HATE it if my twin died. i would really consider suicide if she died
1)SIRIUS BLACK!!! he didn't even get a decent death!
2) FRED i am a twin and i know how horrible it is when your other half dies
these are really what made me roar with tears. i loved dobby as well it was sad for him to go but... it just seemed like jk wanted to kill everyone
I cried over every1 and no1 should have died but I was upset for week over Severus's death and I cried for like 5 days.. Severus is my fav, I have the HBP poster of him on my wall over my bed and a replica of his wand!! SNAPE LIVES!!!
But if they where still alive then it would not work, they needed to die. If Sirius hadn't died than(personal the one i cried most about) then the ^6th and 7th book would not have work as well. Remus' death made sadness come over you and made you cry without it then the whole break during the war wouldn't be so sad and tearful. Severus needed to die maybe most of all, it not dead then the entire ending could be changed.
Lupin, Tonks, and Fred. Snape didn't deserve it, but it was kinda nessacary for the plot...Fred was kinda out of nowhere and Lupin and Tonks were too...they were my favorite two characters too...=(
posted over a year ago
And I forgot Dobby. That was just really sad, but if he didn't die, Griphook never would have trusted Harry...
I think that it makes Harry Potter, all the deaths, try to imagine it with one person not dying, it would make it something else, you need the climax and you need the drama and without Sirius or Tonks or Dobby dying the whole story would change and get twisted.
I cried at many, many deaths of Harry Potter characters, and I always wish to myself that they had not happened. I cried at all sorts of deaths from Sirius to Dobby to Cedric to Fred to Hedwig. I cried for just about everyone (just about). Some of the deaths were extremely horrible and cruel, such as Snape's death. I always wish these characters, as well as others, could have been spared and lived a happy ending.
That being said, I believe that JK Rowling knows what she is doing. I think she made each of her deaths for a specific reason. She did a marvelous job, and though I may resent it, I do not think she should have taken back what she has written. It's really great that she is able to make us feel so much care for her characters, and it is good that she plays with emotions like that. (Imagine if she had been afraid to kill any good guys off, like certain other books that I know of? It would have been pretty bad. O_O)
I think all of their deaths were necessary, the saddest death was Sirius, but he needed to die for the plot to move forward. The most unnecessary- probably Lupin and Tonks . I absolutely loved them.
Sirius, I cried a lot when he died, and then Hedwig, Dobby and Fred Weasley. But Sirius death is the saddest, until the last books I always hoped that he come back somehow. But it didn't happen anyway.
Fred Weasley! He should never have died! He was hilarious, and now George won't have his twin. Also, Lupin and Tonks had just had a baby, and they both died at the hands of Death Eaters. That's so sad... And Hedwig! HEDWIG! She was the best owl on the planet! Hedwig!! And Sirius was amazing as well, he was so kind to Harry, and he was an Animagus. And Dobby as well, Dobby was couragous and loyal... So Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Hedwig, Sirius and Dobby should never have died.
