answer this question

Harry Potter Question

Why don't you like James Potter?Give the reason plz.

I think he was more handsome than Snape & I lv him, he's one of my favs.
But I've noticed that sum of us, HP fans, hate him.
WHY?
 Hermione30 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter  best answer

lilith84 said:
There are few reasons why I don't like him. He's a bully for starters. Yes, I know that Snape gave as good as he got, but as it was pointed out in the books, it was four against one and it was James who started the whole thing, during the first ride in Hogwarts Express (Deathly Hallows, Prince's Tale). He's also a manipulator and a liar. He got Lily to date him by pretending he changed, but behind her back he was still bullying Snape (Order Of The Phoenix, Sirius admits it to Harry himself), he is also a bit of a narcissistic moron and a show off (also Order of the Phoenix). Plus as a Snape fan I have to dislike him on principal :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
^Well-said (:
xXSweeneyXx posted over a year ago
*
Don't be so horrid
Hermione30 posted over a year ago
*
I agree with lilith84. That's why I was never able to warm to James. Also, Hermione30 I feel like maybe I'm missing an in-joke or something, but what about a well thought out answer that uses facts from the book as back up is horrid? *Is confused* :)
Mermaid-Tail posted over a year ago
*
Well said lilith84! *votes best answer*
bri-marie posted over a year ago
next question »

Answers

volleyblue13 said:
I don't hate James :) I like him even though he lied and bullied Snape, because I believe in the priciple of forgiveness and the fact that he changed. People have changed before, and I think we should give them a chance. James obviously got better when he married Lily, because we were not told that he was arrogant after that. Knowing Lily, he probably became somewhat more humble and she probably altered his personality. Being with someone can change you sometimes. Plus, the fact that James (BESIDES Peter) had very loyal friends that would stick by him said something, too. He was a leader, whether he mistreated Snape or not. But lets not forget that Snape had done things to James, too. We may have mostly seen Snape's point of view in "The Prince's Tale", but they both bullied each other, even if it may have usually been James.

All in all, I think James is a great character, and I like him :)
select as best answer
I don't hate James :) I like him even though he lied and bullied Snape, because I believe in the priciple of forgiveness and the fact that he changed. People have changed before, and I think we should give them a chance. James obviously got better when he married Lily, because we were not told that he was arrogant after that. Knowing Lily, he probably became somewhat more humble and she probably altered his personality. Being with someone can change you sometimes. Plus, the fact that James (BESIDES Peter) had very loyal friends that would stick by him said something, too. He was a leader, whether he mistreated Snape or not. But lets not forget that Snape had done things to James, too. We may have mostly seen Snape's point of view in "The Prince's Tale", but they both bullied each other, even if it may have usually been James.

All in all, I think James is a great character, and I like him :)
posted over a year ago 
LilyCullen108 said:
GASP! How can you h8 James Potter? He such a brilliant character. I know he bullied Snape - and, in the end, I liked Snape - but he was a great person after that :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I guess I just don't like the sweet type of characters in general, I loved Snape from the very first book and by the end of HBP I realized I would have still loved him even if he turned out to be a real Death Eater after all. I don't like James, I don't like Lily, I strongly dislike Ron, I am also not a huge fan of Harry :D
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
I LOVE ALL OF THEM!!!!
harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
harryandsiriusx said:
All-in-all, i like James Potter. I know he bullied Snape and stuff, but thats what happens when people don't like eachother, right? I am a Snape fan and a James Potter fan, it was still wrong the way he treated Snape, and it is bad he made Lily go out with him by lying, but it's all good for the story-lines :).
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
harrypotter-rox said:
I LOVE HIM, ok he WAS a bully, but arnt alot of boys (esp spoilt ones like him) like that in there teens?! (i love severous snape 2 (as a kid))
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
HE DIDNT LIE TO LILY!!! HE ONLY BULLIED SEV WHEN HE PICKED ON JAMES!!!!! AND HE LOVED LILY!!! this is what i am refering to; and it is bad he made Lily go out with him by lying
harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
*
soz frm me too, i also didn't mean to start a fight
Hermione30 posted over a year ago
*
all is good :)
lilith84 posted over a year ago
nisrn said:
I don't hate James.he's harry potter's father!! He gave up his life to save Harry.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
sooooo tru!!!!!!!!!!
Mugglestar96 posted over a year ago
jadore_renard said:
I don't really hate him per say...

I didn't like how he treated other people. Especially Snape. He was really arrogant and a bit pf an ass.

I do like him more when he matures.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
TeamSiriusBlack said:
He's ok. :) But I like Sirius so I have to like him anyway :D!
But, siriously, James is a good character. When people say he bullied Snape behind Lily's back, Lily didn't even like Snape anymore. He called her a mudblood, didn't he? Also, Sirius said that Snape hex, jinxed, and/or cursed James, and he wasn't going to take that lying down, was he? But even if it wasn't mentioned, Snape loved Lily and hated James, so if he (James) was going out with his (Snape's) crush, he would most likely try to kill him.
James isn't a manipulator either. He actually did change and deflated his head. He stopped hexing people and stealing the snitch. Plus, James mostly hexed Snape, but the others didn't. They just egged him on. Snape was just as bad. Lily said, on the night Snape tried to apologize to her for calling her a mudblood, that Snape and a group of Slytherins did something bad to someone else.
So, yea, I do like James and Snape, but James isn't a bad person, nor Severus. They were just teenagers and liked the same girl.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
you do have a point. We don't really know that much about how James was when they all grew up. What I sad about James was about the teenage version of him, which I don't like. Snape wasn't a saint either, I give you that, but still, it was James and his gang who started it all.
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
^Agreed. James did start it because Snape said he wanted to be in Slytherin, and James disagreed.
TeamSiriusBlack posted over a year ago
caitie_cool said:
i don't HATE him but he was a total bully to snape when they went to school together.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »