Which do you like more? (Please only consider the book versions!) Poll Results - Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Which do you like more? (Please only consider the book versions!)

1109 fans picked:

Tonks (Harry Potter)

63%

Alice Cullen (Twilight)

37%

duckey94 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

209 comments

Pages: 1 2 3

« Older | Newer »

	cowgirlfromhell picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Tonks is really cool too though. posted over a year ago.

	duckey94 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): This is so hard! I love Alice, but I love Tonks just the tiniest, tiniest bit more. posted over a year ago.

	ihaveojcandocd picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): omg this is so hard for me!!! i've read all the harry potter books twice and all the twilight books twice!!! I LUV TONKS SO MUCH DON'T GET ME WRONG BUT I JUST LOVE ALICE'S QUIRKYNESS JUST A .5% MORE THAN TONKS BUT I LUV THEM BOTH SOOOO MUCH!!!! posted over a year ago.

	FinOBrien picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Once again, no competition. Alice rocks so much more than Tonks. posted over a year ago.

	jacob4ever57 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): WTF IS TONKS?!?!? posted over a year ago.

	isabell118 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): wats Tonks? posted over a year ago.

	trishna1693 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is cooler. posted over a year ago.

	kateliness2 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Not even a contest. posted over a year ago.

	w8ing4myedwrd picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice can read minds! posted over a year ago.

	duckey94 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): For those who, sadly, do not know: Nymphadora Tonks is an Auror and a member of the Order of the Phoenix who was introduced in the fifth Harry Potter book. She is a metamorphmagus (or however you spell that) and usually wears pink hair. posted over a year ago.

	eclipse64 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks rules! There is no question about it..... posted over a year ago.

	Kidna picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Go Nyphadora!!! posted over a year ago.

	SexyNo8 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Harry is wwwwwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyy cool! I mean, i've had a pretty hard time in the last few years and i have a bit of a problem controlling my anger (i like to express it)and harry's just been there and helped me calm myself a bit. posted over a year ago.

	mrsblack_1089 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): um...sorry no idea who tonks is... posted over a year ago.

	alexajaye picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): I picked Alice because she's got some classic one-liners and she's immensely cool. But I also like Tonks. She's got spunk, and she's feisty. They're both awesome. posted over a year ago.

	king_wa picked Tonks (Harry Potter): You guys need to read harry potter! Tonks rox! posted over a year ago.

	jessica101 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice posted over a year ago.

	konyomi picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): For me the best is alice cullen but I like tonks too..... posted over a year ago.

	alicia_twilight picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): i have read both books but tonks was never one of my fav charictors and alice is AWESOME posted over a year ago.

	alynn picked Tonks (Harry Potter): i'm not saying this because i'm against twilight or something but tonks is my favourite character in hp all time! posted over a year ago.

	Nymphadora07 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): lol ReAlY tough question cause as u can see my picture is alice and my Fanpop name is Nymphadora.....but I'd have to say Tonks cause she runs into things a lot, like me and she sort of has an "Alice personality". <3 alice too though! posted over a year ago.

	phelpsfanatic2 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice is always so happy posted over a year ago.

	uRie_RosS picked Tonks (Harry Potter): i know, but tonks is first posted over a year ago.

	edwardshottie picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): ALICE IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	Kairi_Kairi picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice Is On Top And Who Are The Tonks? posted over a year ago.

	Bluefire picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice is my fave :] posted over a year ago.

	KathyHalliwell picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Love Tonks,but I just totally adore Alice posted over a year ago.

	pixy_friend picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): of course Alice i really havnt even read of seen all the harry potter movies SO OF COURSE ALICE!!!:) posted over a year ago.

	tyfsoa picked Tonks (Harry Potter): if they consider the book ... the result would be 100% Harry Potter posted over a year ago.

	sagigrrl1097 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): i have to pick Alice because, I know that Tonks can change her appearance, but ALICE CAN SEE THE FUTURE!!! posted over a year ago.

	ryomaidol picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Harry Potter rockS!! Twilight SUCKS!!! posted over a year ago.

	EdandJa picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): TWILIGHT ROCKS !!!!!!! AND HARRY POTTER IS SORTA GOOD posted over a year ago.

	LeggoMyGreggo picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Well Harry Potter is THE BOOK OF THE BOOKS....twilight is just a magazine!!!!! xxx posted over a year ago.

	Alice_Cullen_ picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice, Alice, Alice, Alice!!!!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	Ovybo picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Sorry, but yeah. posted over a year ago.

	TEAM-EDWARDxxx picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): ALICE ALL THE WAY SHE CAN SEE THE FUTURE!! dahhh who wouldnt pick her lol??? and LeggoMyGreggo Twilight isnt a magazine its a book!! haha Harry Potter just dsnt make it to my Fav books.. posted over a year ago.

	nataliespn picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): I love Alice but I love Tonks too posted over a year ago.

	valao picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Tonx may rocks BUT Alice rules! posted over a year ago.

	BookwormJD picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice is fun in the book! But, there's not much of Tonks in the book. But I like Tonks in the movie! posted over a year ago.

	countrysinger21 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Very hard question.. posted over a year ago.

	gamegirl380 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice! It's a no-brainer! :) posted over a year ago.

	meow_girl picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Who the hell is tonks?! posted over a year ago.

	mebanana17 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice Cullen is really nice and does the best for everyone she can. She also spent approx. 1 million dollars just to go through a gate so she could get to Edward faster to save him! Also Alice can see the future and is probably the second nicest Cullen to Bella. I also think that Alice hates Rosalie which is a good thing as I hate Rose aswell.The reason I hate Rosalie is that she told Edward that Bella committed suicide so Edward tried to copy but Bella didn't commit suicide. Just for the record ALICE CULLEN IS WAY BETTER THAN NYMPHADORA TONKS. posted over a year ago.

	mebanana17 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Well Tonks is quite nice too.If it was out of Emmett and Tonks then she'd have my vote! posted over a year ago.

	AliceCTagle98 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice no ? because she can see the future and she is really thoughtful she spent 1million $ to save edward and she is so cool that is y my name on fanpop is AliceCTagle98 (the c stands for cullen) alice roxzz!!!!!!!!!!!! no ? posted over a year ago.

	Lackson4ever85 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): in the books i love Tonks more that alice,both in the movies both is Amazing posted over a year ago.

	FranKoRocksNite picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is WAY cooler! posted over a year ago.

	ilovecreed13 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): tonks is so much more awsome than alice posted over a year ago.

	itachifan1 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): HA HA AGAIN twilight won twilight is MORE POPULAR AND IT ROXS!!! posted over a year ago.

	vampiressJazz said: neither and TWILIGHT IS LAME EXCUSE OF REAL VAMPIRES posted over a year ago.

	Mrs-Grint picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is amazing!! She's a METAMORPHAGUS or however you spell it! She's an element of luuurve in the books with the whole Tonks/Remus thing. She's great!! posted over a year ago.

	iamwhatiam picked Tonks (Harry Potter): tonks is awesome... btw... twilight is only winning because all the twilight fans have not bothered to read harry potter before judging characters. and if you've read harry potter... you would know who tonks is. posted over a year ago.

	dylin1 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): They're pretty much the same, but you gotta luv tonks! posted over a year ago.

	LadyLilith picked Tonks (Harry Potter): itachifan1, the majority of the picks, answers and basically everything on this spot Harry Potter owns, nuff said. And Twilight is only more popular by the hormone crazed fangirls. And people, if you don't know who Tonks is READ DUCKY94'S COMMENT FOR CHRIST'S SAKE. Instead of asking the same goddamn question repeatedly like on your precious Twilight spot (i.e. "Team Edward or Team Jacob?" "Who's Hotter? Edward or Jacob?" Blah blah blah), why don't you...you know...READ? How in the world did you people get through the Twilight series? Tonks is awesome. And HP will always be epic. No one will give a damn about Twilight soon enough. posted over a year ago.

	LadyLilith picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Well said vampiressJazz! posted over a year ago.

	topez99 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): D: I LOVE THEM BOTH! posted over a year ago.

	XDRoseLuvsHP picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks. She is actually funky. Alice is just bubbly, but not at all weird or funky or anything, just boring. Also, Tonks isn't anti-feminist, and she risks her life to save those she loves and she dies trying to ensure a better life for her baby. Would Alice ever do any such thing? Of course not. posted over a year ago.

	snapeislove picked Tonks (Harry Potter): and again, i love alice, but i prefer the wizards,. tonks is cool..! posted over a year ago.

	Twilightfan277 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): tonks is wat better and itachifan1, just because alice was picked more often DOESNT mean twilight is more popular..it just means they like her CHARACTER better posted over a year ago.

	Ivashkov picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): This was SO hard. But I decided on Alice because Tonks gets all depressed and then dies! :'( RIP Tonks! I hate how they never mention her afterward apart from saying she was dead on the floor! posted over a year ago.

	crazyduds2 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Dammit. You Twilight fans will do anything. Tonks can change the color of her hair. What can Alice do? Oh yeah. Decorate. posted over a year ago.

	caralina100 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR harry potter is way way way better than stinkin twighlight P.S. crazyduds2 makes a good point posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	-ToujoursPur picked Tonks (Harry Potter): If you knew who Tonks was, you would definitely like her more. itachifan1: Read my words: TWILIGHT.WINS.§HIT. posted over a year ago.

	volleyblue13 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is the BEST! :D posted over a year ago.

	volleyblue13 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): and agreed with -ToujoursPur- "TWILIGHT.WINS.§HIT." posted over a year ago.

	MrsRadcliffe said: ITS LIKE MAKING ME PICK BETWEEN FRED AND GEORGE. IDK!BTW TWILIGHT IS JUST POPULAR BECAUSE OF ROBERT,TRUST ME I KNOW. posted over a year ago.

	BellatrixCissy picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): she can see the future no wonder Aro wants her sooo badly to be in the guard lol posted over a year ago.

	Catbr picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks =D posted over a year ago.

	Elena_Damon picked Tonks (Harry Potter): You Twilight fans all say you've read Harry Potter and that Twilight is way better. If you have read Harry Potter how can you not know Tonks? posted over a year ago.

	ToyletGnome picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Dora would be such a cool person to hang out with. Plus she comes with an adorable werewolf husband and she's not afraid to risk her life for the people she loves. posted over a year ago.

	sleazy_weasley picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Okay, she has pink hair. That totally kicks Alice's sparkly little ass. And at itachifan1, HAVE YOU READ THE OTHER PICKS/ARTICLES/ANSWERS?! Do you know who's more popular, who has more valid arguments, etc? And besides ... Harry Potter will only cease to exist when none here are loyal to it. Don't know what I'm talking about? Not surprised. posted over a year ago.

	kilie picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): ALICE posted over a year ago.

	Athiya picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Definitely Tonks. Alice is one of the character that actually had a personality in Twilight, but Tonks is a F*cking. Metamorphagus. Who can change her appearance at will. Who really fight to win Remus' heart. Who died to save the wizarding world. Who's an Auror. And Alice can see the future. Not really, she could only see people's decision. Right. posted over a year ago.

	ABDCFan- picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Why is Tonks on here? Srsly. She is just WAYYY too cool for Alice. C'mon people! Tonks can change her hair colour!! :D posted over a year ago.

	XDRoseLuvsHP picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Umm... I'm just saying that I don't think you should pick unless you know who both characters are. I've seen comments saying that someone doesn't know who Tonks is, so I don't think it's fair to pick. (Of course we know who Alice is, being a huge Twilight character) posted over a year ago.

	Queenoftard picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Alice can see the future, but I bet Tonks can do divination if she wanted to. How about that? Tonks is really cute. Alice is just annoying. posted over a year ago.

	AceofHearts picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks, by far. :) She's bubbly. And normally bubbly characters are very far away from my favorite character list because they're normally annoying. But Tonks...Tonks is just plain amazing. And she probably could do Divination anyway. posted over a year ago.

	boolander25 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is a lucky bee-yotch who got to marry Lupin. LUCKY!!!! Except then she died, so I'd like to think of that as karma. R.I.P. Tonks posted over a year ago.

	potterandtdi picked Tonks (Harry Potter): How isn't Tonks in the lead? SHE ROCKS! Did A** marry a werewolf and not let that get in the way of having Teddy? NO! She didn't marry a werewolf or die for her son! I would die for my son than have him killed and me safe and alive. Tonks will curse any T-word lovers and make them love her! Teddy raises the middle finger! TONKS FUCKING ROCKS MY SOCKS! And se'll f* your t******* undies and then throw them in the trash. TONKS WILL CURSE YOU FOREVER! then this is what happens to her: link posted over a year ago.

	abitofaLunaTic picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Wow! Loads of people voted for Alice without even knowing who Tonks is.Go and find out who she is before you vote! BTW, she's an Auror(Dark Wizard catcher) which means she's pretty tough, super smart and can change her appearance at will. Besides, she's really independent, which is not something I can say for a female character out of Twilight! posted over a year ago.

	vskparaimer picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks! In the movie she's not quite as i thought she'd be, but she's still fantastic (both in books and films). i had no doubts. posted over a year ago.

	bamagirl5899 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice like i said she has great tast in clothes and can make a fast getaway posted over a year ago.

	joose32 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is so crazy and funny and clumsy. Plus she's a METAMORPHMAGUS!! Tonks is cool :D posted over a year ago.

	Leolynn picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Umm, hard to choose... posted over a year ago.

	londonsrock picked Tonks (Harry Potter): this was a close one imho posted over a year ago.

	kwlski4ever picked Tonks (Harry Potter): mrsblack_1089 lol that means you didn't read HP XDD itachifan1 Since when "popularity" was a part of being awesome ? posted over a year ago.

	Confuzzle picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Come ON people. THIS IS TONKS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT! posted over a year ago.

	kwlski4ever picked Tonks (Harry Potter): meow_girl , TONKS IS FROM HARRY POTTER NOT FROM FRICKIN' TWILIGHT !!! This is harry potter vs twilight , not TWILIGHT spot !! If you don't know who's Tonks ,then DON'T answer , DON'T join this club !!!!! I agree with Confuzzle posted over a year ago.

	hardrocknroll picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): its not do u like twilight or harry potter better, its alice cullen or tonks, and i love HARRY POTTER wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better, but alice cullen is just so cute and hot posted over a year ago.

	TeamSiriusBlack picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is Totally Awesome! posted over a year ago.

	vanessanicole24 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice is really funny and cute so i would pick her! and i like Twilight more than Harry Potter. posted over a year ago.

	LoopyLuna96 picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks is far better than Alice! Also, you can't pick fairly if you don't know who characters are. So, if you don't know who either one is, don't bother. posted over a year ago.

	IsabellaMCullen picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): Alice. posted over a year ago.

	CupcakeKiller picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Alice is weird, and Smeyer dont know how to describe her.. TONKS ALL THE WAY posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Aquilia picked Tonks (Harry Potter): The funny thing is, Tonks can look like Edward If she wanted to. Lolz. - Adding to the confusion of Twilight fans since 1973 - posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	WolfPatronus picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Tonks could look like any of them and impersonate any of them, since I'm quite sure Aurors have to be experts at this. Besides, Tonks was awesome! She's an Auror, a Hufflepuff that was actually COOL, and she kicked some major butt. posted over a year ago.

	kyaira picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): twilight rocks woohoo! posted over a year ago.

	Jalice21 picked Alice Cullen (Twilight): alice is soo cool i wish i could be her posted over a year ago.

	venvargie picked Tonks (Harry Potter): Alice annoys the hell out of me. >:K posted over a year ago.

	DJ_Squeaky picked Tonks (Harry Potter): I love Tonks! She's one of my favourite characters! :) posted over a year ago.