Reason 10

cassie-1-2-3 That never happens..

zanhar1 What never happens? She jumped off a cliff for Edward, Hermione did try to punch Ron.

cassie-1-2-3 Bella never tried to kill herself.

zanhar1 Then why did she jump off a cliff to see Edwards face?

cassie-1-2-3 Adrenaline rush. Cliff diving is a recreational sport.

Italktosnakes Adrenaline Rush...

Andressa_Weld She was just trying to see his face, she wasn't trying to kill herself!

Italktosnakes After she saw Jacobs friends diving of the cliff she got the idea. Then put it into place. Gotta admit though, bit of a weird thing to do, just to see Edward's face.

zanhar1 But still, she chose the wrong time to do it (stormy wether) and she shouldve had someone with her in case something happned and she didnt even know how to do it right she should've asked Jacob how to do it properly first. Even if it wasnt suicide it was still a stupid reckless move.

Italktosnakes Yeah true. She knew that she was most likely going to die. I do agree either way. Rather idiotic :L x

bri-marie Actually she [i]does[/i] stop trying to get to the surface of the water after she jumps of the cliff: "I didn't want to fight anymore. And it wasn't the lightheaded-ness, or the cold, or the failure of my arms as my muscles gave out from exhaustion that made me content to stay where I was. I was almost happy that it was over. [...] I saw him and I had no will to fight (New Moon, Page 361)." She gives up trying to save herself because she can't live without him. In a way, that's considered suicide. The entire Ron/Hermione thing was awesome in this last movie and this was the best part ^.^

zanhar1 ^ There you go in-text proof it was suicide.

Italktosnakes I stand corrected. I HATE twilight, but that was the one thing I could remember from the whole books. I have a Twilight book, but it's unreadable, seeming as it's covered in 'WHO THE F*** IS LAUREN' and 'WHY DOES NOTHING PLEASE YOU' and various Alex Day/ Nerimon Quotes :) x

starberry Ron and Herminone is awesome couple! Have nothing to say about Edward and Bella...

1-2vampire ^^ Hehe Nerimon ;)

RealSunshine Hermione stood up !!

cassie-1-2-3 Accepting death when it's right there in front of you is not suicide.

bri-marie It wasn't right in front of her. She could have fought - swam- had she really wanted to live. She didn't. She gave up because she didn't want to live without him.

Gred_and_Forge ^ I agree. She could have fought to save her life. Bella willingly went into those dangerous situations knowing she could possibly get hurt or killed. Talking to dangerous bikers; riding on the back of a motorcycle with said biker (in movie version); cliff diving without someone there to watch her. Even scuba divers never go diving alone, no matter how experienced they are. They always go with a partner for safety reasons. I get what cassie-1-2-3 is saying, but I don't believe Bella was in her right mind when she did those dangerous things.

MrsRadcliffe That's because Hermione is more of a normal human than Bella, well she was never a human, she had to become a vampire to become "normal".....

VampPhoenix99 Cassie-1-2-3, yes, yes it is. It`s just LAZY suicide.