Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Article: Why Harry Potter is better than Twilight

Why Harry Potter is better than Twilight

posted by Love4Hermione

So Harry Potter is MUCH better than some stupid book about wimpy girls and sparkly fairies. First off:
ALL the Twilight people are UGLY! I mean seriously, Taylor Lautners muscles are gross and he has ugly man-boobs. He looks like a creep on steroids. and Robert Pattison looks like a bum, and Kristen looks like a drug aggict as Bella. I mean, EW! Who wants to watch a movie with eyesores like them? Harry Potter is WAY better, I mean we have HOT guys, and the girls aren't half bad either! I mean. we have Lucius, Draco, Sirius, and Snape to say the LEAST! Plus like a zillion other eye-candy dudes! And can you say HOT about Chamber of Secrets teenge Voldemort??? AND Hermione and Bellatrix and the other girls look like people and not stoner mannequins like Bella!

Second, Twilight is too realistic. I mean it's not like it's fact or anything, but it's all boring cause it's set in the real world and all. Stephenie Meyer didn't have to do anything to write it other than to put her crappy ideas on paper. JK Rowling actually did research and stuff for Harry Potter, which is much more exciting, and WAY less realistic! I mean it's so much more creative too!

Also, Harry Potter provides more stuff for people. Like there's a HP musical, theme park, clothing, etc. All Twilight has is a few movie and posters and shirts and stuff. And who'd WILLINGLY go around wearing a shirt with Eddykins's face on it? EW! GROSS! YUK! Anyways that proves that Harry Potter is the best and Twilight is what i'd pick up dog shit with.

AVADA KEDAVRA HATERZZ!!

Peace out
-Liana Rose

(this is my first article what do ya think?)

bri-marie This actually doesn't really prove that Harry Potter is better than Twilight - everything here is all opinion. [i]ALL the Twilight people are UGLY![/i] Opinion. People find different things attractive. I happen to think Nikki Reed, Taylor Lautner, Cam Gigandet, and Peter Facinelli (without the pasty make-up) are regulation hotties. Also, as (probably close to)hundreds of people have said here, "Looks are not a valid reason to say something is better than the other." [i]Second, Twilight is too realistic.[/i] Again, opinion. I found Twilight to be extremely unrealistic. With the exception of the fact that it was set in the "real world" nothing- from the plot to the characters- was realistic or believable. [i]Also, Harry Potter provides more stuff for people. Like there's a HP musical,[/i][b]There's a Twilight musical as well.[/b][i]theme park,[/i][b]Twilight has a cruise ship and a hotel[/b] [i]clothing, etc.[/i][b]Again, Twilight has this.[/b] Again, this doesn't prove that Harry Potter is better.

lalaland21 Are you a Twilight fan? Because I swear that I heard you say that Twilight was realistic. TWILIGHT IS NOT REALISTIC. It's set in a real place, but so what? NOT a valid reason. You're using the same reasons as the dumb Twilight fans, but using them for Harry Potter. "The Twilight people are UGLY!I mean seriously, Taylor Lautners muscles are gross and he has ugly man-boobs. He looks like a creep on steroids. and Robert Pattison looks like a bum, and Kristen looks like a drug aggict as Bella. I mean, EW! Who wants to watch a movie with eyesores like them? Harry Potter is WAY better, I mean we have HOT guys, and the girls aren't half bad either! I mean. we have Lucius, Draco, Sirius, and Snape to say the LEAST! Plus like a zillion other eye-candy dudes!" Sounds scarily like "EDWARD IS HOT!!! HARRY POTTER IS UUGLY BUT JAKOBS ABS ARE SEXY!!!!!!!!" Wait a minute, it sounds pretty much EXACTLY like that!I'd better not see you diss Twi fans for saying things like this.

GemonkDruid Is this a joke? You just basically used the shitty arguments that us Antis disapprove of. (and you hate potato.)

Aquilia Excuse me? My brain yelled fallacious throughout the article... *sighs* I'm sorry to say but the argument that "Harry is hot therefore HP is good" is the inverse of the Edward-fallacy, it is false because even if a piece of the examined object demostrates wanted behaviour, while the same conclusion may not be applied to the entire object, it is a false extrapolation of the whole. Your singular axiom that Twilight is too realistic is refuted by the postulation that Breaking Dawn is unrealistic: [url=http://www.fanpop.com/spots/harry-potter-vs-twilight/articles/82322/title/dulce-et-decorum-est-pro-patria-mori-commentary-on-breaking-dawn-see]here[/url]. The rest is Argumentum ad Consequentiam, an appeal to consequences and another fallacy. The last argument is non sequitur, the statement is independent of its postulated proofs. I however will applaud your effort even if it took me less than five minutes to conjure an counter-argument.

PotterForever Oh dear, this is not good. I agree that HP is better, but you just did exactally the thing people hate Twilight fans for doing. (Shallow invalid arguments) Lets go through it: 1. How "hot" the characters are is not a valid reason. 2. Twilight is far from realistic. Yes it was set in the real world as opposed to a fantasy world, but nothing about it (the characters, the plot) are even close to realistic. 3. Yes, HP provides more stuff for people, but that has nothing to do with the book's quality. I agree that Harry Potter is better than Twilight, but these reasons are exactally the kind of shallow invalid reasons people bash Twilight fans for using.

GemonkDruid SHE IS ONE OF LOBSTER'S MINIONS!!!! BAPTISE HER IN THE HOLY JUICES OF POTATO!!!

PotterForever YES WE MUST BAPTISE HER IN THE NAME OF POTATO!! IT'S FOR HER OWN GOOD!

GemonkDruid WHY ARE WE RAPING THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE BY TYPING IN ALL CAPS????

PotterForever BECAUSE POTATO'S IMPORTANCE REQUIRES THE USE OF ALL CAPS.

GemonkDruid OH RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!! GO POTATO!!!!!!!!!

PotterForever YYYYYYYYAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYY POTATO!!!!!!

GemonkDruid POTATO KILLED TWO STONES WITH ONE BIRD.

KateKicksAss I do completely agree that Harry Potter is better, but this is a horrible article. I agree with you, but this sucks. This is the worst article I've every read about why HP is better.

MissKnowItAll I don't want to be rude, but... this article is rubbish. :/ You are just using the same shallow arguments for why Harry Potter is better that the Twihards use. (By Twihards I mean the psycho crazy ones.)

SerialFangirl Oh, I thought that this was a dig at Twi-fans, using the same arguments as them but twisting it into a Potter-fan point of view. I was going to say that it was really clever.

alexthedog This is kind of funny!

ChocoLuvr101 I agree that Harry Potter is better than Twilight, but this article is just rubbish. Your using the same invalid reasons the crazy twitards would use.

Ashmita2001 This article dose not prove that Harry Potter is better than Twilight. Well its...its like your opinion. You are telling that Twilight characters are bad-looking. I mean.....that's insane! A movie is not compared by its character's face! And you are talking about Bella...aren't you? Come on man....she is like that. Not everyone in this universe is Fun or a Talking Train? And then you're telling about the Harry Potter products. That just isn't making any sense. This article is about "Why Harry Potter is better than Twilight?" It isn't about "Harry Potter products are better that Twilight products?' I am a Harry Potter fan and equally a Twilight fan. But I am sorry to say that this article dose not make any sense with the title of this article.

A video about TRUE love

added by HaleyDewit

ron and hermione-accio love

video

harry potter

ron

hermione

true love

accio love

A different kind of love

added by Gred_and_Forge

Source: Me

Deathly Hallows Part 2 World Premier

added by Kiniko90

Source: All over bloody Tumblr

2

The Final Battle: Part 5

posted by harrypotterbest

Harry and his friend entered the hotel in high spirits. Hermione, Ron, and Ginny were already there, and one look told them they had been very worried. Ginny glanced at Harry’s wide smile and the newcomer, and said, very icily, “Who is she?” to Harry.
Harry grinned even wider, and J K smiled. “This, Ginny, is the one and only J K Rowling!” He saw their looks of astonishment. “You know,” he added, “she wrote our books!”
“Oh,” said Ginny, sounding rather relieved. Ron laughed.
Hermione looked surprised, but knowing as to why he had brought J K.
“And why did you bring...

1

The Final Battle

posted by TeamSiriusBlack

Luna looked back and shouted, “EXPELLIARMUS!”
The Death Eater’s wand flew out of his hand.
“Nice shot!” Neville said, looking at her impressed. Luna beamed brightly, as the two continued to run. They both slowed as they neared a room filled with smoke. Neville ran in first and Luna followed close behind. They heard shouts coming from every direction.
“CRUCIO!” There was a scream of agony.
“STUPEFY!”
“AVADA KEDAVRA!”
The last spell seemed closer and both ducked at the same time. They heard a thud as a body hit the floor. Luna ran over there, despite the spells flying everywhere....

3

Stop the Hate

posted by potterrox

People are passionate about defending their books that they love. I know that and I’ve done it. What’s really disturbing is when the users of Fanpop use this site to bring people down or just to openly hate.

Harry Potter and Twilight are going to be compared. No other two books have the same rabid following and they both have strong roots in the supernatural. I welcome debate and exchanging of opinions, when it’s friendly. Some of the comments I’ve seen on these forums could not be called friendly debate. It just makes me sick when I know that there are people out there that are willing...

8

Helena Bonham Carter

added by Gred_and_Forge

Source: Tumblr

4

why Ron/Hermione pwn Bella/Edward

added by angelwarren

3

why Ron/Hermione pwn Bella/Edward

added by angelwarren

10

Hilarious 2

added by bessmarvin1

5

No, Fred, No!

added by Gred_and_Forge

Source: Tumblr

21

Percy Jackson agrees with Harry

added by HecateA

Source: I don't remember, sorry :(

24

funny twilight and harry potter pictures

added by Ash24

Can 35 Million Book Buyers Be Wrong? Yes. (by: Harold Bloom)

posted by VampiresRevenge

Taking arms against Harry Potter, at this moment, is to emulate Hamlet taking arms against a sea of troubles. By opposing the sea, you won't end it. The Harry Potter epiphenomenon will go on, doubtless for some time, as J. R. R. Tolkien did, and then wane.

The official newspaper of our dominant counter-culture, The New York Times, has been startled by the Potter books into establishing a new policy for its not very literate book review. Rather than crowd out the Grishams, Clancys, Crichtons, Kings, and other vastly popular prose fictions on its fiction bestseller list, the Potter volumes will...

5

why Ron/Hermione pwn Bella/Edward

added by angelwarren

5

why Ron/Hermione pwn Bella/Edward

added by angelwarren

21

Role Model Wars (Ginny, Hermione and Bella)

posted by bri-marie

Note: This is my opinion, but I use facts from the book.You are more than welcome to have a different opinion than my own and feel free to state it. I was not rude in this article (and I use facts to support my reasoning) so please be curious and do the same :)
____________________________________________________

Education:
Ginny-
Not much is known about Ginny's education. Since Harry Potter is told in third person, and focuses entirely on Harry, Ginny tends to get pushed into the background. So, this part is all assumption.
We know she is an accomplished Bat-boogey hexer (it's why Slughorn took...

1

Kristen Stewart at Mulberry Fashion Show

added by Andressa_Weld

1

Vamps dont sparkel

added by angelwarren

Edward is my life

added by youknowit101

Source: trollblogs@tumblr