answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

Do you think that it's possible to love/like Twilight AND Harry Potter? I do...

OR we can all just love Dear John!!!!
Do you think that it's possible to love/like Twilight AND Harry Potter? I do...
*
I just want to say: I asked this because a lot of people I know think they have to hate Twilight because they love HP, or vice versa. So stop asking.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
I hate Dear John. Worst movie EVER!
MissKnowItAll posted over a year ago
 alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

Queenoftard said:
Obviously. Or are you trying to tell us you can do impossible things...?
Edit: Ah, wait. I misunderstood the question. I thought you said you liked both.
Anyway, yes I think it's possible. I know several people who do. (Even if most of them only like Twilight as a guilty pleasure)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I do like both, actaully.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
Then why question yourself?
Queenoftard posted over a year ago
*
Sorry...haven't looked at it until now. Forgive me. actual*
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
DivyaHarry said:
Not really. Mind you I don't hate Twilight. It is the kind of book for narrow-minded people who think looks are everything and if you look good you'll get all you want. Plus the only friendship we get to see in the book are from others not from the moaning heroine. All in all I cannot relate to the book in any way. And for those who say it's a love story please seek therapy.

Harry Potter is more realistic than most think.
1) The love is based on emotions not looks or smell. Remember Ginny was in Harry's life for 5 years before he developed any feelings for her.
2) Friendships matter more than anything else. And it was not like everyone were gushing on Harry the day he stepped in Hogwarts. They even hated him in book 4. He has 2 friends who were always loyal to him.

I've touched upon only 2 subjects, Love and Friendship, because these are the common ones in both books.
HARRY POTTER WINS, WANDS DOWN.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree with most of what you said, but I think narrow-minded people can like Harry Potter too. They just won't see the same depth as a lot of the other fans.
Queenoftard posted over a year ago
*
Are you serious? I can't stand Twilight, but it IS possible to love/like both things. It's not a crime, you know. Just because one is more realistic than the other, it doesnt mean that one wont enjoy Twilight because of it.
Mongoose09 posted over a year ago
*
I've seen people who like both. My friend is crazy about both the series.
DivyaHarry posted over a year ago
emmaterry said:
hhmmmm...there will forever be a battle between harry fans and Bella fans but it might be possible...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
True...
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
stephlutz said:
Yes i like both but i like more twilight
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Good.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
ew,i HATE twilight
emmaterry posted over a year ago
*
That' amazing
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
That's*
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
italiangirl976 said:
Why can't you? their totally different.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Look at my comment in the actual question
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
ew,i HATE twilight
emmaterry posted over a year ago
MissKnowItAll said:
Yeah.
I don't mind people who like Twilight, even though I'm a HP fan ( In fact, 2 of my closest friends are Twilighters) it's just when they go psycho on you for pointing out a fault in the books that annoys me.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Because I could point out faults in the HP books, and I would get people going psycho too.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
OK. I'm not saying there are no faults in HP. I simply said that when people go mad at you for pointing out the faults in Twilight that annoys me. Please stop twisting words and making it seem like everyone is against you. I didn't insult anyone, no one here really has, so don't act as if they have. Also, why did you start your comment with 'because'? You weren't continuing a point of mine (I put a full stop) or questioning anything.
MissKnowItAll posted over a year ago
*
I'm so very sorry to have offended you. I made a mistake, and I'm a bitch. Let's end the conversation.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
*
?...Ok. Lets end this conversation.
MissKnowItAll posted over a year ago
LadyLilith said:
Of course you can, it just depends on who you are and what you like. I love HP, but I don't like Twilight. That's just my personal tastes, but people could like both.

Nothing is really stopping anyone, except for maybe the prejudice as seen in this spot, saying that one series is better than the other. I just encourage people to like what they like, and don't let anyone influence them and become stereotypical fans.

I know a couple people who like both. :) It is possible, lol.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Good answer.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
iceprincess7492 said:
Me. I am a fan of Harry Potter and Twilight. Maybe not equally, but i still like both. Please respect everyone's opinions and don't call each other mad for liking one and not the other... everyone has a right to like and hate things... some people like both, some people may even hate both or like any one of the two...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Good answer.
alice_cullen_12 posted over a year ago
boxxybabe said:
i think it is possible to love and like twilight and harry potter i mean theres nothing wrong with that right and we can also love dear john to i mean they are all good movies right
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Calypso_ said:
I'm with you and I love both! I really don't get way people say you can't, I mean they're both really great books, now the movies, I must say are a completely different story, you can still like both of course but the twilight movies are really, really bad, (Kristin Stewart CANNOT ACT!!!) but yeah, it is completely plausible and possible to love/like both seires
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »