answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

WHY do Harry Potter fans not want a time capsule?

I'm not convinced that it has nothing to do with Twilight for a lot of people.
I asked two picks. One that asked if Potter fans would like one like Twilight. The majority said no.
Then I asked if you would like one if Twilight didn't have one. the majority said yes.
The same people voted in both picks, right???

Why does Twilight's websites make you not like it anymore?

You people that say it has nothing to do with Twilight, explain why you wouldn't want one. Not just "I'm not interested". explain WHY you're not interested or WHAT about the idea is bad.
 goodtimes posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

bri-marie said:
I picked 'maybe' both times. But my answer had nothing to do with Twilight. I was actually thinking about Pottermore.

Pottermore was supposed to be this awesome thing full of awesome stuff that was totally awesome. What it ended up being was this boring... thing that didn't work right majority of the time, and really didn't even have an riveting information like it promised.

For me, it would depend entirely on how they did it. Pottermore had the potential to live up to the hype. It could have been great. It wasn't.
A time capsule could be awesome. Doesn't mean that it would be. It could end up flopping, which would be a pretty big waste in all kinds of ways.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
They are still editing Pottermore so it could get better. I can't get onto pottermore until they open it to the public
theelderwand posted over a year ago
TheBreeze said:
Honestly, some Potter fans are pretty biased. If Twilight has something, they don't want it. I think some Potter heads have an idea in their heads that being first and being original is best, and don't want anything to do with Twilight.
And it's pretty stupid.
At first I didn't know what the Twilight time capsuale was, but then I googled it. And I think it would be pretty cool.
But like Bri says, it could be a total flop.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
zanhar1 said:
I'll just copy some of my comments from before and put them here;

I'm still on the fence. It's not that Twilight had it first, but I don't want Twilight fans to feel like HP copied them. But other then that it'd probably be cool.

It's not the website itself, it's the fact that I don't want to sound hypocritical. I was one of those people who thought Twimore would be stupid because it copied Pottermore. Like wise I don't think I'd be cool if HP stole the capsul.

Part of me does want to pick that option, not just because it was Twilight's first, but because most HP fans complained when they thought Twimore was real and it would be hypocritical to not accuse HP of copying Twilight. I simply wouldn't want an HP time capsule because it's copying Twilight. Besides we have Pottermore.

In short it's not about who had it first or second, so much as I don't want to sound hypocritical. I was one of those people who disproved of a real Twimore as it would be copying Harry Potter and it was unoriginal. Like was if Harry Potter took the capsule, I  would think it's unoriginal and it copied Twilight. Besides we have Pottermore, to make another website is kind of over doing it.

I can't speak for others but, when you said you weren't convinced that it had noting to do with Twilight, for me it really doesn't have anything to do with Twilight, except for the fact that Twilight has the capsule. What I mean is I wouldn't want the capsule of say Lord of the Rings had it first either. The capsule is something Myere came up with for her series I don't think it's cool to just copy it. Likewise I don't want to see Twimore. Same goes for any other book; I wouldn't like to see Ringmore or Narniamore, or have Harry Potter take website ideas from LotR or Narnia. I think Rowling should just continue to come up with her own things.

I hope that made sense.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
NarniaMore and RingMore sound so awesome xD
TheBreeze posted over a year ago
Narniamore would be fun :3
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
Ringmore actually sounds like some kind of adv. for food...
ClaireVoyant posted over a year ago
lukita said:
heh, not the same people pick both answer,
you ask four question
1.Would Harry Potter fans want a Harry Potter Time Capsule like the Twilight fans have?=NO
2.Potter fans: If Harry Potter had an online time capsule exactly like the Twilight one and Twilight didn't, would you like it?=NO
3.Potter fans: Would you rather: I didn't answer this one because there are no just NO pick
4. themepark: duh! like someone said theme park has exist for a long time and have different theme to attract people so there is no plagiarism included.
as long as pottermore not open I have no interest to join another interactive website....

and just because it have a HP name on it doesn't mean I'll mindlessly buying it
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
xxhpgalxx said:
I'm a Harry Potter fan, and I wouldn't like another site simply because I don't like to keep up with all of them. The only two sites I typically go on is here, on fanpop, and
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »