answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

The 'battle' in Breaking Dawn: possible outcomes?

I posted a pick where I asked who would you want to die if there were an actual battle in BD--Bella or Edward. A lot of people said that if one of them died, the other would probably kill themselves, which would probably be true. Hypothetically speaking, if Edward or Bella did die in the battle, do you still think their love for each other would make them commit (or attempt) suicide like in New Moon? Would they be so blinded by their pain that they would actually kill themselves, even knowing they have a daughter? Would either of them pawn off their child to their family, or even Jacob?

I'm not sure if they would, but I wouldn't doubt it. They're both very selfish and only think about each other and not the feelings of others. Would the possibility of losing their other half forever make them go insane and kill themselves? Even if they didn't commit suicide, how long do you think they would grieve, and how good of a parent do you think they would be to Nessie during this moment of grief?
 Gred_and_Forge posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

bri-marie said:
I think Bella most definitely would have. She couldn't even stand not being with him in New Moon - and he was alive and, as far as she knew, happy. Had he died in the battle, there's not doubt in my mind that she would have followed soon after, despite having Nessie.

I'm not sure about Edward. He (seems to be) a little more stable than Bella. I think he would have stuck around just until she was "an adult" before he killed himself.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
^ Agree about the New Moon reference. He was still alive and she did those reckless things just because they weren't together. I think Edward is slightly more stable, but not by much. He would probably take care of Nessie for awhile then give her to Rosalie if it came down to it.
Gred_and_Forge posted over a year ago
*
Well, it's not like he'd have to wait long for her to be an adult, or least old enough to take care of herself.
bri-marie posted over a year ago
*
I agree
SuperSnuffles13 posted over a year ago
GemonkDruid said:
I honestly think they would kill themselves.

Since apparently, Edward is Bella's life, and vice versa.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ThePrincesTale said:
Yes, they are selfish, and yes, they would probably kill themselves, regardless of the feelings of the loved ones left behind, and regardless that Renessmee would be orphaned.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Drisina said:
Well honestly i would've really liked to see Jacob dieing , even tho i started liking him because well he was getting on everyone nerves and he was funny but it would have been quite a drama.Then as for Edward dieing i don't and can't tell how Bella would've react
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »