Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

Twilight fans, give us some real reasons

Twilight fans, we want to know why you think Twilght is better than Harry Potter, we want to hear some real reasons backed up by facts from the books, we want you to explain yourselves. The reason you guys are always made fun of is because you never provide any facts to back up your argument, and it comes across as childish.

DO NOT use a character's physical appearence as a reason, and try not to give shallow easily debatable reasons. If you want people to stop making fun of you, than you need to stop giving people reasons to make fun of you. So why is Twilight better? Speak up, and provide facts to back yourselves up.
 PotterForever posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

GemonkDruid said:
Even though I'm not a Twilight fan, can I answer?

1. It brought many of us sensible Antis together. *glomps*

2. At least everyone's not obsessing over how hot zombies are.

3. The storyline COULD have been interesting, if it wasn't written by such a fail author. I bet if a monkey wrote it, you'd like it.

4. It increases our knowledge on literature. Like the show "What Not to Wear", you can learn what not to read, and avoid Mary-Sue infested books in the future.

5. They advertise Italy. Come on, HP didn't mention Italy at all. And I like Italy. Even though my Italian teacher is a total bitch.

6. It got me into Buffy. Well, it was partly Twilight and partly Bones... but still. Buffy is too epic to even put in words.

7. It inspired people to broaden their artistic talent and computing skills (e.g. the Toilet pic)

8. Potato doesn't REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY hate it. He just REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY hates it. That's one REALLY short.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah! it got me into Buffy to because i wanted to know how other people portrayed vampires, so i watched Buffy, read alot of vampire books and i then realised how shit Twilight was
IzzyOzera posted over a year ago
*
XD best answer
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
HaleyDewit said:
........................................................................................................................................................................................................
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bamagirl5899 said:
Okay why most of us like twilight is it has love and romance and almost all the cheractors history and even new york times thinks their good and could u guys give twilight a chance I mean I gave hp a chance and like it but I like twilight better.And their's different enimeis nnot like in hp with voldemort being behind everything but in twilight it's different u have james, then his mate victoria and a army of newborns ,then the voulturi im not saying both arent good but thats why i think twilight is better
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I did give Twilight a chance, I read all 4, and saw the 1st movie, and didn't like them, but it's only my opinion be calm about it.
PotterForever posted over a year ago
*
i am or trying to be.
bamagirl5899 posted over a year ago
Hiding 5 comments... click to show.
*
Yeah. I was an honest-to-Primus Twihard. But the movies made me look back at the books and realize, I really didn't like them as much as I thought I did.
DrHookandCo posted over a year ago
uniquezandy said:
I love both but:
The one reason I love it because, (I know this could sound weird,) but Twilight is kinda like my movie I like 2 watch by myself when I want 2 or I am bored because it's like a my own movie. Harrypotter is one to watch when all my family are together and we are all watching it on a good day to put us in a family moment. Thats one reason I like.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lalaland21 said:
Why do you like Harry Potter?

A. Twilight has characters with depth. I'm not talking about Edward and Bella, but Rosalie and Alice.
B. IT HAS A PLOT. The writing isn't the best, and even I will admit that there are things that should be changed, but the plot isn't ALL that bad.
C. I posted this in the 1000 reasons why Twilight is better than HP spot, but I'll say it again: It has love. NOT Edward and Bella's 'love', but Rosalie and Emmett's love, and Alice and Jasper's love.
D. It turned me on to reading. I NEVER read, but since I read Twilight (and Harry Potter) I've been reading a lot more.

Good enough?
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I do like this, and you do a good job backing up your case. I just don't understand why Rosalie and Alice and all of the other small characters were not backed up with more plot. Yes, the love that is between Rosalie and Emmett may be true, but it was not played up to an adequate level. By having the main characters of the book shallow, and by having them be involved with the 'wrong type of love', then I don't understand the appeal that these this series brings. But again, I applaud your dedication and I wish there were more fans like you that would comment.
justliveitlive posted over a year ago
*
Better arguements then I've seen i can agree with some things you bought up.
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
*
yea! twilight 4evr!♥
xXJacobsLadyXx posted over a year ago
dmoon101 said:
There are no hot ppl in hp but in twilight there are and hp is good just not better than twilight.... SORRY....
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Did you read the question? The "hottnes" of characters do not count as real reasons. Why? Because 1) it's shallow and 2) everyone thinks differnt things are attractive. For example: I think there are only two hot guys in Twilight and about ten in Harry Potter.
bri-marie posted over a year ago
*
3) You can't see if someone's 'hot' in a book.
HaleyDewit posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
yea! i totlly agree wit u! I LUV JACOB HE IZ SO HAWT OMG
xXJacobsLadyXx posted over a year ago
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!