Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question
Have you HP fans read Twilight or seen the Twilight movies? Did u like it?
|
mitchie19 posted over a year ago
|
|
next question »
|
|
Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers
|
V-GIRL96 said:
Yes, read the series in a week, didn't like it. Saw the first movie, hated it. Not willing to see the other movies.
|
|
|
BatBogeyHex said:
Yes!!! cuz i am a "twi-hard" and an HP fan!!! hey, i can be both. and i must admit i love both the movies and the books. very much!!!!
|
|
|
june13 said:
yes i have read the books there so so but don't as good as harry potter
|
|
|
bri-marie said:
Yes, I've read all the books and seen all the movies that have come out. I like the books when they first came out, but when I reread them (and when Breaking Dawn came out) I stopped liking them. I never really cared for the movies.
|
|
|
XxkillthebunnyX said:
Yeah, I read all four books and loved them at first, but later I thought about them more and realized how dumb they were. I have seen the movies too. And those? Well, they suck.
|
|
|
LifesGoodx3 said:
I'm actually a Twilight fan. But when I first read them I loved them, now I just thin they're okay. The movies? The first one sicked, the second one was not much better and eclipse was actually okay.
|
|
|
GemonkDruid said:
Yeah, all the movies and books, plus a bit of Midnight Sun, a bit of Nightlight, and Vampires Suck. I don't like it though. XP
|
|
|
zanhar1 said:
Both and honestly I liked the movies better Twilight was really boring too me in book form.
|
|
|
Ash24 said:
yes i read all the books, though i only watched the first movie which wasnt that good so i havent watched the rest
|
|
|
RavenclawPride said:
I've read every single book, seen every single movie, and hated them. At first I was a huge " OMGZZZ EDWARD AND JACOBB ARE HOOOOTTT!! "
And now I'm back to HP, though I never really left it.
Plus, I don't think Twilight has shoes as awesome as these.
|
|
|
Avp_m-s_Fan said:
Yes I read them, no I will not watch them, no I hated them.
Bella- two timing slut. Sorry but true. She keeps going back between Edward and Jacob and then says she feels bad by hurting both of them, and does nothing to help the situation.
Edward- Has no will power. Is only attracted to Bella because of her "scent" and because she is the only one that he cannot read the mind of. Also, lets Bella get away with being a two timing slut.
Jacob- Supports Bella when she is "hurt" after about four months. When Edward comes back he is almost completely forgotten, and yet he still follows her around like a dog. Lets Bella get away with being a two timing slut.
|
|
|
boolander25 said:
I've read all the books (and I particularly liked BD best out of all of them, except the ending which made me want to shoot myself) and I've only seen the first Twilight movie and therefore was smart enough not to watch the rest. If you're wondering if I liked it, don't bother. Didn't I already state that I am an HP fan by writing this answer?
|
|
|
potterandtdi said:
Yesterday, me, my sis, my friend Anthony, and my cousin all watched it and we made fun of it. We all screamed,"EDWARD CULLEN HAS THE SECRET LIFE OF A GAY FAIRY! HE'S GAY WITH JACOB!" and we also said," That cactus is going to up her ass if she doesn't drop it right now. We were laughing like crazy. Best night of my life that had something to do with Twilight.
|
|
|
MarauderForever said:
Yes. When I first got Twilight, I couldn't put it down. I had needed new reading material and happy I got it and it was new to me because i never really read about Vampires before.
I was Team Edward. And loved the series. I even went to the opening of Breaking Dawn, and out of Tradition and still go to the Midnight viewings of the movies.
But I love Harry Potter a lot more. And can't even pick Twilight up and read it again.
|
|
|
-Alohomora- said:
Read all the books first, then watched the movies. I used to love them, but I grew tired of them, and the more I think about it, the more I realize how pathetic they are. :/
|
|
|
grapecandy said:
Yeah ive read the books as well as the movies and i used to like them but as i reread them i kinda of got put off by it as i actually relized the movies as well as the books are not as good as i thought they were....
i don't know what drew me in at the time but i think maybe because it was so popular and the fact that i will like anything to do with vampires (even sparly ones)...lol...
|
|
|
NataliaLidia said:
im not an hp fan but i don like twilght ether. i red the books nd seen the moves nd i didnt like them at all!!!
|
|
|
TeamSiriusBlack said:
Contrary to popular belief, many HP fans have read Twilight. The only thing I liked about it was the Volturi and Ronian Coven :P
Also, I saw the movies and they sucked, pardon the pun.
|
|
|
jedigal1990 said:
i am actually reading the first book right now and don't like it bella is getting on my nerves the only reason i'm reading it is because i don't wanna bash something i don't know about even though i could care less if people like it or not i just get mad at the obsseive fans who get mad anytime anyone says something against it
|
|
|
clutzs said:
read first page of twilight couldn't stand it saw ten min. of twilight so stupid i started to cry.
|
|
|
elmi said:
I am a fan of both Harry Potter and Twilight both is=f them r good in their own ways though I have to say that Breaking Dawn was a bit disgusting for teenagers like us!
|
|
|
manyofhorror said:
When the first book came out I was actually happy. I can´t say I loved it but it was a good read. Then I went to the first movie and I was actually surprised, well you see it and think it´s pretty cool, because the budget they had wasn´t that big.
But when I told my friends about the movie, since I went to the premiere.. (I believe 5 people in the largest cinemahall) 'They were all like Omg, what? About vampires..really? That
s so stupid.' and then I was like SCREW you guys, you don't even know what you are talking about.
But after a week everyone was like; Omg! twilight is so epic! this that.. you know, huge hype. Telling me thinks I already knew for about a month because I did research and stuff. And that's kinda when I started disliking Edward and whole twilight thing.
But I still gave it a shot, so I read the second book, but I could only annoy myself about the ten pages; explaining me how hot it is when edward lifts his eyebrow. I didn't even finish the third book, didn't start at the end. Because we all know what's going to happen next, Bella is going to get pregnant become a vampire.
That's it you know. I do still watch the movies but, from the second movie you are very aware that in the fifth she's going to be a bloody vampire. The third was the best, but they are really stretching the whole thing.
I've always been the hardcore potter fan, and I always will be. The final was full of surprises, each and every book had something new. These books are here for a life time, it was actually unique.
|
|
|
ravenclawgirl5 said:
I have read all four books. I have seen the three movies so far. Everything sucked.
|
|
|
EighthHorcrux said:
I skimmed Twilight and was interested enough to finish the series, despite the awful writing style and lack of differing vocabulary. I can now honestly say it was the worst written book I have ever read (and that is saying something) with the most pathetic plot ever written.
|
|
|
ELEPHANT98 said:
YES I'VE READ EVERY SINGLE BBOK OF THE TWILIGHT SERIOUS ND I'VE SEEN THE MOVIES ND ABSOLUTLEY LOVED THEM.
I LIKE HP ND I'VE SEEN THE MOVIES BUT I HAVENT READ THE BOOKS ND I PROBLY WONT BECAUSE IM NT A REALLY BIG FAN OF HP LIKE I AM OF TWILIGHT.
|
|
|
renrae said:
Um, yes. And people shouldn't be on this spot unless they've read both series or at least seen both movies.
I've read the entire book series more than ten times, seen the Twilight movie three times, and seen New Moon once. I haven't seen Eclipse. I've also read Midnight Sun (atleast, what was posted on SM's website.)
There was a time when I was a fan of the series, but I've since had a reread with a chance to actually analyze the books and I realized I didn't really like them.
|
|
|
bessmarvin1 said:
I read Twilight 1 & I got so angry that I wonder why on earth did Edward fall for a loser like Bella
|
|
|
slytherinangel said:
I read the first 3 books, 40 pages of the 4th. I saw all three movies and the movies are terrible but I get dragged to them every premiere because my friends are twi-hards while I'm a potterhead.
|
|
|
Mannu967 said:
First saw Twilight movie , then read New Moon book , and then watched New Moon movie . And that was all I could handle . I was kinda forcing myself to like it , dunno why . But them I decided it sucks ... I don't know it that actually made sense , but yeaa . :D
|
|
|
Angel-Trix said:
I read the books
They were terrible!
The second time I read them, I laughed at Stephanie Meyer's stupidity
I watched Twilight and nearly gagged
I watched New Moon and was laughing at all the times that were supposed to be sad
The girl sitting behind me was sooooo pissed! LOL
I didn't even bother to watch Eclipse
|
|
|
Evanescent said:
Yes, I read all saga and I didn't watch movies. I like books for Jasper, Alice and Jake, I hate for Bella/Bella & Edward. HP is better. All the way.
|
|
|
KishuandIchigo said:
I'm reading Twilight now, and it's ok, but she has figured out hes a vampire, but hasn't asked him yet. Meh.
|
|
|
Ms_Mea said:
I used to LOVE twilight to death...I bought every book and freaked when Twilight was being turned into a movie...
Until I realized how stupid and anti-feminist it was
I began to slowly and surely hate it, and it all began with an article explaining how daft Bella is
Now, I have to admit I'm on the edge of hating Twilight! :)
|
|