answer this question

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Question

What is one thing you hate about the whole Harry Potter vs Twilight arguement?

For me, it's when the opponent fans go to far. When they start demanding for you to go fall off a cliff, or jump in a hole and die. Do you have any idea how inexplicably rude and harsh that is? To tell someone to go kill themselves over a book series? It's just demonic and horrifying when you actually get the chance to think about it. If people are going that far to tell you to end your life, well, 'cruel' doesn't even begin to describe that. More like 'psychotic'. Even if you say it and you don't mean it, it's still horrible and morally wrong. ~Rant complete.~
 ThatDamnLlama posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Answers

ToyletGnome said:
Thte are actually two things I hate:
1. When people cross the line and make personal attacks rather than presenting proper points.
2. When idiots can't type properly. This applies to both sides, I'm not singling out Twilighters
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Confuzzle said:
I don't like the fact that everyone's trying to badmouth everyone else.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I only badmouth when people bash me. I'm not gonna sit here & take that, I gotta say my opinions.
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
Amen Cullen!!!
Abilei posted over a year ago
*
Thankies. The same, Cullen.
Confuzzle posted over a year ago
Abilei said:
I hate a lot of things about these arguments. The first thing is I hate everyone always seems to go off track. Like the argument will start and then all of a sudden will be like "your stupid" or "your a stupid ass." Then everything gets personal, I'm like "Wait, how did my mom come up?" (You get what I mean.)

The second thing I hate is how JUSTING USING THIS AS AN EXAMPLE!!!! But I hate how some Twihards get so nasty and vile with things and make the rest of we Twilight lovers look bad. I mean serious most the people who are argueing and getting personal are preteen freaks. (No offense, I know not all preteens are like that.) And I know its not always Twihards, it is HP lovers sometimes aswell.

Third thing I hate is how everyone picks at every little thing. Like say I misspell Potters name and don't realize it until I'm getting yelled at by some HP lover. I'm like "Whoa calm down..SORRY! My bad." (Just using this as an example.)


Something else I hate is how some people act like Twilight and HP are life. Like if they don't defend their book/movie then the world is going to stop turning. All I want to say about this is...This stuff really isn't going to matter years down the road.

Over all I'm just sick of all the arguments. I will say though..I have gotten myself into some arguments about both HP and Twilight and about the only way I get myself mixed up into the stupid arguments is if you come at me. Just thought I'd put that in there...as a side note.
select as best answer
I hate a lot of things about these arguments. The first thing is I hate everyone always seems to go off track. Like the argument will start and then all of a sudden will be like "your stupid" or "your a stupid ass." Then everything gets personal, I'm like "Wait, how did my mom come up?" (You get what I mean.) 

The second thing I hate is how JUSTING USING THIS AS AN EXAMPLE!!!! But I hate how some Twihards get so nasty and vile with things and make the rest of we Twilight lovers look bad. I mean serious most the people who are argueing and getting personal are preteen freaks. (No offense, I know not all preteens are like that.) And I know its not always Twihards, it is HP lovers sometimes aswell. 

Third thing I hate is how everyone picks at every little thing. Like say I misspell Potters name and don't realize it until I'm getting yelled at by some HP lover. I'm like "Whoa calm down..SORRY! My bad." (Just using this as an example.) 


Something else I hate is how some people act like Twilight and HP are life. Like if they don't defend their book/movie then the world is going to stop turning. All I want to say about this is...This stuff really isn't going to matter years down the road. 

Over all I'm just sick of all the arguments. I will say though..I have gotten myself into some arguments about both HP and Twilight and about the only way I get myself mixed up into the stupid arguments is if you come at me. Just thought I'd put that in there...as a side note.
posted over a year ago 
*
awh. i'm team switerzland
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
I 100% agree.
VampiresRevenge posted over a year ago
eli218 said:
I hate when people write really really mean things just because the other fans do not agree with them i think we all should respect the opinions of others and have a normal discusion
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Haha. Normal. We're talking about witches & vampires here. Haha
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
CullenProperty said:
I hate the entire thing cause it's just never gonna end. One person is always gonna say that HP is better than Twilight & vise-versa. Everyone is gonna get stepped on or called some name & they're gonna bash back. I hate that we all can't get along and act like we like either or what we don't. It's just never gonna end & that's what I hate.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah, agreed. Or pretend to pretend to like each other.
Abilei posted over a year ago
*
haha. i don't think i'd pretend
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
Persephone713 said:
I hate that the damn effing media started this war, confrontation back when promotions for the first Twilight movie came out. " Oh it looks like we have a new Harry Potter" " Stephanie Meyer is the new J.K. Rowling." " Twilight fans are giving Potterphiles a go for their money." all this stupid crap I read, that isnt true. I dont care if girls/woman/whoever read twilight. But I dont need to hear about it everytime something happens or I dont need to see Twilight everywhere I go. And Harry Potter certainly doesnt need replacing.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
italiangirl976 said:
I think the whole thing is stupid. They are totally different. You can compare them and discuss which one is better but when you have someone calling you stupid just because you like Twilight? That takes it too far. Yea I understand Twilight fans get judged because of all the crazy, creepy, obsessive fan girls who will attack anyone who criticizes Twilight but not all of us are like that. Some of us are sane. And I love Harry Potter and Twilight. But I am more of a Twilight fan.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
So technically you like the debate, but you don't like attacks? I think that's how everyone feels. When people make personal attacks and start being rude it just takes the fun out of everything.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
*
i dont see the harm in debating about the two, obivously people are gonna agreet to disagree about things and thats cool but that doesnt mean for people to bite others heads off! I think people have forgotten the reason these spots on fanpop are for: making friends, discussions, etc not starting unnecessary fights!!
Faith-Rulz posted over a year ago
*
Yea I agree. I love debating things but when it starts getting mean its not fun anymore.
italiangirl976 posted over a year ago
top-star said:
i think its that how its NOT a hp vs twilight, its more like a hp crushes twilight.there should also be limits of answering,people should just give facts and reasons not abuse the other.if they do do this i think they are just too dumb(sorry) to answer logically
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I agree, but this is a debate, and people should still respond to points, as long as they stay civil and open-minded. I think the reason there's so much of a "hp crushes twilight" mentality is that most of the Harry Potter fans are willing to debate further and make rebuttles to pro-Twilight arguments, which is how debating should be, whereas the Twilight fandom usually don't. Most of the time, it's hard to find Twilighter's reasons to begin with, let alone an actual debate. I think if the Twilighters responded with points more often, this debate could become a bit more even, but everyone still needs to be polite. Rose wrote a very good article on debating vs. attacking, which I think everyone should read, so yes, I agree, people need to stop being rude, but everyone should still respond to points so we can get some proper debates going.
ToyletGnome posted over a year ago
next question »