i say jacob because i know he will...
-always love her
-always take care of her
-wont want to eat her
-will not be to protective

Bella picked Edward...it doesnt matter what we think...would you like it if everyone kept telling you who you should and shouldnt be with?...and have you really read any of the books? Edward will love her longer because he can never die..Edward will always take care of her..True Edward wanted her blood at first..but he doesnt want it anymore and he would never eat her....and with Bella turning into a vampire...Edward would never have to be "too" protective again.

There Soulmates! They belong together! End of story!

way i look at it, if bella hadnt picked edward then all four of them (nessie, jake, bella, edward) wouldve (never been born.. and) never be completely happy... so to be fair even people who say "i prefer jacob" should really say edward... see what i mean? lol. :)

She should die. :P

i love jacob!!!!!!

yes i have read the books and this is just a question...gosh!