dont get me wrong, im a total Jake fan but i wasnt in love with him when Edward left so i cried for pages.

he broke her heart. stupid git.

i did! my mom was like y r u crying? and i was like y don't u read these few pages and she said theres no reason to cry over it. and i was like u have to read the first book to understand it and she was like y would i read those books then i said how could u not want to read these books their soooooooo good! my mom must be insane cuz hse thinks their stupid and not worth her time! i told her its a great romance and u'll totaly fall in love with edward! so i had her read the discripion of edward and she said there r cuter guys out there and there so totaly isn't!

i was just really really mad that he left. not necessarily that he left Bella, but the fact that I thought he had left the book! I love Edward, and i totally would have died if he disappeard out of the books! i had a few tears, but not many cuz i was so angry.

apparently I cry a lot. lol. but yeah. my mom did the same thing she walked into my room and was like "omg what happened" and i was like "the book...", but my mom actually did read all the books, even though she didn't cry atleast she understnads. but yeah i was totally crying like for pages and pages. and i've reread the books like 2-3 times. and EVERY time I cry all over again.

i cried in eclipse, i couldn't stop crying, but i din't cry when edward left bella.

edward was being a extreme butt head and i was sick of bella and i was glad wen he came back

Are you kidding? I cried when I realzied that he was going to do it, I cried right before he did it, I cried while he did it, and I I cried like 60 pages after he was gone!

I DID NOT CRY CUZ HE LEFT BELLA, I CRIED CUZ IT FELT LIKE HE LEFT ME TOO! just to clear things up. :D

I know he left me and i was so upset, and i was in the car driving to sydney with my grandma and she was all OMG whats wrong and she thought i was having some sort of fit! lol

i just don't cry alot, though i was really sad

i agree w/Meg i cryed because it felt like if he had left me... but i still have some care for Bella...

~Andrea Isabella~

i agree with meg n annie. its like some1 left me at that same time. i cried for hours. my mom laughed at me. my ex-boyfriend julez keeps sayin "y do u waste ur time on those stupid books. now ur crying." i said "stfu ur jus jealous i dont shed tears for u." that shut him up. that book is sooo heart breaking. but sometimes i laughed soooo hard. 1 time was cuz she fell off the motorcycle. & then she gets up & says "lets do that again." hill-air-e-us

I cried but I wasn't exactly bawling..

goodness that was a sad moment in the book i was like "what?!?!?! NOOOOOOO!!! he cant leave Bella!! what the heck! how is the rest of the book pan out without edward in it?" i was in denial for like 10 chapters till he came back! hahaha i kept thinking he would come back every time bella would think she saw someone or whatever i would always hope it was edward, but it wasnt. AND, as like Bella when she actually saw him in italy she didnt believe herself that it was him and so did i..haha but yeah it was so sad i was crying and i almost didnt feel like reading the book, but the fact that edward has to come back is what kept me reading the book. lol

I was mad, but I soon got over it. I think that's why I liked Jacob, because I kind of just moved on.

it took me a while to realise he actually left...I was like, naahh he'll be back soon, then I got to the part where it had the months go by and I was like OMG :(

How could anyone read that and not cry?
I was angry and sad at the same time. Part of me died only to be brought back when Edward came back. It kills me whenever true love isn't allowed to be.

i was sad but i didn't cry when Edward left, i had actually stop reading th book for a day, and new moon is the only book that i haven't read, it still gets to me when Edward isn't there

yeah i was in reading class and i almost cried but i held it in!

Ok he can live without us, but he can't live without Bella! lol Jerk face should be miserable without me though. . . lol jk

i was so pissed and so sad when Edward left it practically tore me in half. but he wont live without Bella for long.

I was sooo sad when he left. I had to take a break from reading because i couldnt see the words on the page through my tears!!! I'm so glad he came back. I wouldnt be able to handle it if she stayed with Jacob. Stupid Jacob.

I was heart broken when he left i was quite like bella i couldnt eat and i didnt want to do normal things and i didnt have a warewolf best friend to get me through it lol he came back though and thats all that matters :)

I didn't bawl for Edward (teared up), but I DID bawl for Jake! Still sad :P

It was so sad.

But afterward I was upset 'cause it would never happen.Otherwise I
was PISSED on the acount of being Bella ofcourse.

i so agree with gileygirl and Meg08
This is wat they said the first is gileygirl then Meg08 they like summed it up 4 me!!!!!!!!!!!1

goodness that was a sad moment in the book i was like "what?!?!?! NOOOOOOO!!! he cant leave Bella!! what the heck! how is the rest of the book pan out without edward in it?" i was in denial for like 10 chapters till he came back! hahaha i kept thinking he would come back every time bella would think she saw someone or whatever i would always hope it was edward, but it wasnt. AND, as like Bella when she actually saw him in italy she didnt believe herself that it was him and so did i..haha but yeah it was so sad i was crying and i almost didnt feel like reading the book, but the fact that edward has to come back is what kept me reading the book. lol


Are you kidding? I cried when I realzied that he was going to do it, I cried right before he did it, I cried while he did it, and I I cried like 60 pages after he was gone!

I just don't care about Bella, I hate pretty much everything about her. Because of that, I think I was incapable of feeling sorry for her.

not even kidding