I'm still shocked I thought he should've had a heart attack when jacob did waht he did. But I guess he was strong. I was glad though. It made things a lot easier!

yes! i was so shocked! he always seemed like one of those dad's who looked strong, but wen he was actually told he wood faint... and then wen he wood wake up he wood kill edward! thats just my opinion tho... lol

Honestly...

i did know that he was strong enough... i just didn't think that jake would b that stupid!!! OF ALL PEOPLE!!!! but i knew that he was stronger than harry... he could handle it

i think he can handle wat he knows, maybe not the stuff he doesnt, and remember edward told bella once that he is happier thinking one thing and not looking to deeply, which is probably wat he did in that situation

like edward said..in eclipse..
"Charlie is happier when he pretends to swallow your sories. He'd rather lie to himself than look closely."
though i alwayz had a feeling charlie would at least find out about Jake.. ..
eslecially in the end of eclipse..lol
he was like.. there were a bunch of howls outside like if 1 of them were in pain.. then the howls disappeared as fast as they came..
next thing u kno Jake n his friends come in thorugh the door..
jake's cussin ..

I was more surprised that he found out. But he does love bella so much that as long as he was with her he wouldnt care!

i wanna know exactly what they told him, it never tells you!

I was so gald - but i knew he was strong, but he loves his girl, and thats strong! lol :D If you get waht i mean !

yeah i was suprised but then again bella could handle all of it and he loves her and he might liek have a simular brain to her to not make him as scared adn shocked but