answer this question

Twilight Series Question

DO YOU FIND EDWARD BAD WHEN HE WANTS TO ABORT THE CHILD ON BELLA'S WOMB? OR HE IS JUST BEING A CONCERN HUSBAND TO BELLA BECAUSE HE KNOWS THAT THE FETUS IS KILLING HER?

 alexandria12 posted over a year ago
next question »

Twilight Series Answers

CullenProperty said:
I'm kinda on the fence for this question. I feel, because it is your fault for conceiving a kid, even if you didn't want or know you could, it's still yours to bare. & if your choice is to kill it, then your murdering a living being. How terrible is that? I am 100% against abortion; If you didn't want to have a baby, then you should have used a condom! Anyways, to Edward;

I sorta kinda did find him bad, now that I think of it. But, also, killing one person to save another is still a hard discission to make too. Although if the story did go that way, Nessie killing Bells, then Edward wouldn't have made it through the procedure, he would have went straight back to the Volturi, I think. So, yes I think was bad for wanting to kill Nessie, but also he was just being a concerned husband. Even though he probably should have been more of a concerned father. IDK. Now I'm probably just confuzing people.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
alexandra101 said:
he is so not a bad person he loves bella more than his own life when he thought she was dead he tryed to kill him self so she is the most importasnt thing to him ever so he was just doing it out of love becuase he was so sure that the reason for his exsitence was going to die becuase she wouldnt abort the baby so of course he would want to abort it to save bellas life
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
weirdcandy said:
yes
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
kenya124 said:
I think he's very confused on what he wants to do,
because, like even though he loves his baby, all he sees is the baby killing his love.
So yeah, very confused.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MrsJonasLautner said:
I'm against abortion.. ( PRO-LIFE!) But, since the baby is sucking Bella's blod form the inside, and is killing her, then, I don't think he's being a bad person by telling her to abort the baby. In real life, you're killing an innocent human, but since Breaking Dawn's conflict is such a BIG deal, than, no Edward is not being a bad person.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Jacoblackswife said:
Nope,i wish he would have just riped the damn thing out of her stomach
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
luvutoo said:
I think he was being a concerned husband. Remember this is something that is made of concrete that will suck out her blood growing inside of her. He was rightly concerned. As far as protection and knowing it could happen, i doubt that. This was something new to them and none of the other company edward kept obviously had to use it or think of it. Who would have thought a vampire could get anyone pregnant? But as always when Edward saw a threat to Bella he reacted. I see nothing wrong with his reaction.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
megan-ox123 said:
Well honestly I think that if any guy love a girl as much they would do the exact same, I did not think he was bad or find him mean he just wanted the best for her like Jacob and all the other guys. It's just guys don't get what it's like to have a child even if it's not born yet it's inside of yoou and apart of you and you love it it's jst a womens natural instincts I also no if I was in the same posision I would not get an abortion and If I was in Rosalies position I would probably do the same as her.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
shorty01 said:
I think he's very confused on what he wants to do,
because, like even though he loves his baby, all he sees is the baby killing his love.
So yeah, very confused.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
shingkai said:
he's very confused and totally out of character for wanting bella to abort their baby. yes it might kill bella but he always mention that he only wants bella to be happy and the baby is what she wants and what makes her happy. and besides they already agreed to change bella so if something went wrong if bella couldn't make it (delivering the child) he can bite her so bella will turn into vampire then he'll explain what happen to the baby. But instead of making bella comfortable he keeps on showing his strong desire to kill the baby. thanks to rosalie nessie was born.
still i can't blame edward because everybody has their own weaknesses and the thought of bella being hurt or worst dying was the one thing edward couldn't bear.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »