|
mandapanda said:
Well, first. Let's all calm down. lol I know Breaking Dawn is a very sensitive and controversial topic with the imprinting, babies, and all that good stuff :)
However, I hated Breaking Dawn. Lol The only good thing about it was the wedding, honeymoon, and the last two pages. I liked Bella's power. Everything came full circle. She came in being the physically, weakest character to being the strongest character. That's what the book cover signifies if you didn't know.
Things I didn't agree with: (fasten your seatbelts. This may come off as bashing, but it's not)
-Imprinting. Yes, I get that imprinting is considered a 'beautiful' thing. It's starts off as a brother, a friend, a guardian. But, it could turn into something more. That is the "reason" behind Jacob's intense feelings for Bella. We all know Bella isn't a normal person. She's sometimes very very irrational. So, let me ask you this: If Jacob's feelings were because of Renesmee, then what's the reason for Bella's feelings? It's completely contradictory!
-The characters are completely OOC. Edward is completely out of character. I mean, he would NEVER stoop as low as having Jacob sleep with Bella to give her a baby. Alice is MIA in half the book. Really. If you read all of the books back to back, the first three are COMPLETELY different character wise.
-I've said this many times, but it makes no sense that Bella and Edward have a baby. NO SENSE! The logic to the situation that Stephenie Meyer feeds us is ridiculous and illogical. Edward has no flowing blood. No fluids. And, by no fluids, that automatically means no sperm. There is NOTHING swimming upstream.
-Again, I say this everytime a question has to do with Breaking Dawn: All of the books, SM has said time and time again that even though there are fantasy creatures such as vampire and werewolves, the myths are false. She established that the stereotypical myths were false. She established a new mythology. Yet, in Breaking Dawn, a prophecy was foretold? And it came true? Talk about hypocritical and contradictory!
As you can see, I have major issues with Breaking Dawn. I try not to dwell on it or the future movie and how it will turn out. I think it will be a disaster, but I can't be positive. Judging by the scripts Melissa Rosenburg has submitted involving the Twilight movies, she can even mess up Breaking Dawn's story.. or possibly make it better because Breaking Dawn was rather... ~crazy to put mildly.
|
|