Which Twilight guy would be better for Bella if Edward wasn't there? Why? Whose a better friend if Alice wasn't there? Why?

If Edward wasn't there and no werewolves are allowed I'll say Tyler because;
1. Mike is too stalkerish
2. Eric is into that Katie gal and didn't seem too interested in Bella after Twilight
3. Mike belongs with Jessica, they're perfect for each other.

Angela is the better friend because SHE IS ACTUALLY INTERESTED IN BELLA and not just looking for gossip.
Everything doesn't revolve around Angela eitehr.

Oh crap! I want to say Jacob... but no! I'm just kidding. Probably Tyler. He's the only one with nothing to bad about him. And for the girl thing, I don't know. Sorry my mind is blank, so, the one who is not annoying and dosn't care about gossip!