What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

The Vampire Diaries TV Show 5.05 → Damon and Elena 'giving' Katherine on a silver platter to Silas!!

61 fans picked:
They did the right thing !
   61%
Wrong On So Many Levels !
   33%
meh , don't realy care about what happened ...
   7%
 laurik2007 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

15 comments

user photo
laurik2007 picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
Damon went so over the line imo! even though Kat was never a victim plus she has done some horrible things in her life, for Damon to lure her to the boarding house , and practically feed her to Silas it was unforgivable ,specially now that Kat is human and defenceless. At one point I was screaming for Elena to jump in , do something but she just stood there, and for what to get Bonnie back, I get that they want Bonnie Back and Klaus gone but this is not the way ,they practically gave a human being to a vampire to drain her dry .... ...he might be my favorite character but as I saw it he shouldn't done that ...

I'm curious to hear your thoughts ?
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
XxMakus picked They did the right thing !:
Not exactly the right thing, but I would not judge them at all
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
MariLena16 picked They did the right thing !:
I understand that he wanted to help Elena. Make her happy...What he did it's what Damon would do. It wasn;t OOC.

Also why it is wrong? Because Katherine did nothing bad in the episode right? But we seem to forget all the bad things that she did to all of them all this seasons. He manipulated Damon & Stefan. She was selfish all along. I'm happy that she didn't died because she was my favorite character in the episode but making her the victim? Hell no! She was bad to them all along so it's wrong for them to be bad as well?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
bionsi picked They did the right thing !:
He did what he had to do, what needed to be done. Yes, it wasn't pretty but it was the only way.
And even though she's human now, I can't regard Katherine as an innocent victim. What happened to her in the last episode was exactly what she did to Jeremy.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
carambolas picked They did the right thing !:
I mean I love Katherine, but she would have done the same, she has done the same, many times. She killed Jeremy the same way.
Just because she was nice this episode and has been sympathetic lately, does not change what she has always done, put herself first, not caring who dies.
Also this wasn't Damon's plan A, but it had to be done. So I saw nothing wrong with it.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Delena_Is_Love picked They did the right thing !:
^^^^ What they already said. Katherine is not exactly innocent... She had it coming... I was like "OMG what is Damon doing" but i understand his reasons and it was a very good scene actually.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
Sakkara98 picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
I always loved Katherine,even if she has done loads of bad things,but they all did bad things !
Kat was so scared,I really thought that Elena would stop Damon,and she didn't. Plus,she has just found her daughter,she deserves to know her and spend time with her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
thisthat12 picked They did the right thing !:
I'm glad she's still alive, but there was nothing wrong with what they did. They don't owe her ANYTHING, and honestly, taking everything she did to them into account, they were too kind to her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
I kinda agree with @thisthat12 .
I stood there with my mouth wide opeen expecting and hoping Elena would jump in or Damon show some sympathy. The show would SUCK without her especially in this season , so I `m thrilled she didn't dieee
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
overthedges picked They did the right thing !:
Well i love Kath but they should have killed her a long time ago. It was the easiest way, and it's not like Kath treated Damon (or Elena and her friends) well in the past. She would do the same in their position, no doubt. Anyway the scene was amazing, Ian was amazing. He was scary and you can see the remorse for a second right after. Very good acting.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
JAlanaE picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
I just don't think Damon's plan is good. I'm sure Bonnie is totally disgusted that they want to bring her back to life by teaming up with the person who slaughtered her dad. Just when Silas was finally unable to harm anyone, they just recklessly reanimate him. Who knows what he's going to do? And even if he cooperates with them peacefully without screwing them over somehow (which I doubt), the turnout of their plan might still have horrible consequences as Bonnie pointed out...
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Talice picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
That was so wrong! It was awful to watch her begging Damon to stop, ugh, such a disturbing scene.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Sora7395 picked They did the right thing !:
I would have been mad if Katherine died because I love her character. However I don't judge Damon and Elena at all. She destroyed their lives! And not just their lives, many of the other characters too! Katherine had it coming a LONG time ago...
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
MaryElizabeth picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
Giving Katherine for Bonnie? No thanks!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
RoswellGirl13 picked Wrong On So Many Levels !:
I was pissed! She is human now and was actually terrified! She just found her daughter and wanted to live for her! However, with how everything worked out, it's all okay because Katherine is alive...for now. I also agree that Katherine is way better than Bonnie. I don't want Bonnie to come back everrrr. I love Katherine! I never want her to leave. I kinda love Silas right now too. I love seeing Paul play a character like Silas. He is so good at it. But poor Nina having to play three characters in one episode! She is so amazing. I don't think it matters that Katherine deserved it! When Nina is playing a character and is begging for mercy you can't help but feel bad. She is just that good.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago