do you think john hutcherson would make a good peeta?

I think Josh would make a good Peeta. I know Hunter is the fan favorite, but to me, he's too old. When I saw him in 17 Again, the character he portrayed was such an arrogant jerk it's impossible for me to envision him as Peeta. It's the same for Alex Pettyfer. If the books were released earlier, and they got Alex Pettyfer when he looked younger, he would've been good. He was really cute in Stormbreaker. ^_^ But back to Mr. Hutcherson, he's one of the next best options. I think his facial structure fits, and besides- Peeta's supposed to be cute, not hot. ;) (Sorry Josh!) It's not my best hair color change, but maybe the photo helps? I dunno.

I don't know anything about his acting but his being brunette bothers me. If they dye his hair blonde, it will look fake and he doesn't have blue eyes. Contacts will look fake, too. I agree with everyone that said Peeta's not supposed to be super hot. His face shouldn't be too gorgeous but still cute and his body shouldn't be too perfect. I think Hunter Parrish is too gorgeous for the role and his body looks way better than how Peeta's body should look like. I don't want Peeta to look like a greek statue. Alex Pettyfer looks too edgy looking, I think. Peeta should look cute.

Yes compare to some of the she would make a very good Peeta

Not really because he doesn't have the right face for it it's too buff looking and I think that Hunter Parrish is a waaayyy better choice than him though none of them are the perfect peeta in my mind anyway....

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

No I think Alex Pettyfer is a better choice

I actually think he would. He's still 19 [or something] and can easily pass as a 16 your old. Peeta is supposed to be of "stocky build" and compared to other choices made, he fits that description best. Also, I find him to have that "Peeta look". I personally don't find him to have that "LOUD" attractiveness like Alex or Hunter, his is more subtle, more boyish, which is what I imagined for Peeta. Plus he's not the worst actor either, not the ABSOLUTE best, but not terrible. At least I can take him more seriously than Alex. I can't say anything about Hunter's acting though since I've never seen any of his movies.

I never really though about him as an option until just last week and I'm surprisingly fond of him for the part. Honestly, he's probably one of the best choices made.

i think benjamin stone would make a good Peeta, other than his slight british accent he is good. He has natural dirty blonde hair not sure about the eyes and he is tall....no to bulky though