Star Wars club for girls Article: Am I the only one who think's this about episode III?

3

Am I the only one who think's this about episode III?

posted by GalindaGirl

Okay, I have a question for you all, I'm having trouble on how to put this.

Okay, I'm one of those kids who was taken to see the Star Wars prequels because parents were fans and wanted to see them, I was pretty young, and when I saw the third movie I was old enough to remember and be more into Star Wars. Episode III’s ending broke my little girl heart. I thought “What? What a terrible and sad ending! What happened to everyone?” And whenever I watch episode III, I get the same feeling. So I definitely don’t like it that much. I haven’t watched since I was sick a few months ago, and I was confused on some things, so I got the book on CD from my library. I never finished it because I had to return it, but that explained some questions. But I feel like crying at the end, luckily I don’t cry over sad endings, and I pry would if it was expressed better. So I really don’t like episode III, I was never into Star Wars until very recently, the Clone Wars series came out, I was interested and got the movie from the library when it came out on DVD. I enjoyed it, I had seen small parts of the show when we still had cable, and it inspired me to write a Star Wars story, and so I got into Star Wars more and is now obsessed!!!!!!!!!! And am I the only one who doesn’t like episode III? Or is it just me and a few BFF’s who don’t know much? Opinions welcome, but please keep langue clean. And its okay if you like it, its pry me.

opaquemystique, marvel517639 and 1 other like this

jedigal1990 i agree to you in some degree i agree it was a very sad ending and i did almost cry i hated seeing anakin go to the dark side and seeing the clones who i really have come to like since clone wars came out turn against the jedi it was almost as heart breaking to see cody shoot at obiwan as it was to see anakin and obiwan fight. i still like the movie i think its an important movie in the series i really like the begining of it when anakin and obiwan are working side by side before the clone wars came out you didn't see much of that. i also like seeing the middle you can tell anakin really is struggling with his feelings he hates turning evil but he wants to save padme but i still think there is always a part of him thats saying what are you doing this is wrong anyway back on topic i do see why you don't like it and i agree with you but the beginning is fantastic and its still a great movie depite the sad parts great article though

GalindaGirl I half like it and half not, I can watch it, and I just hate it when they show you the clones shoot down all the Jedi. But if you read the Star Wars Revenge Of The Sith book, it explains so many unanswered questions and says facts. I think there might be more than one, I almost finished the one by Mathew Stover. There was like, one funny part and one "aww sweet" part. I was so close to the end. But it's so sad, but if I ever watch it with someone, they will not like me yelling at the TV. And I also have been gocking at the episode III visual guide, tells you some cool stuff. I love looking at visual guides! But I know so much about episode III further than the movie, and it still makes me wanna cry. If I never had the problem of getting emotional durring books and movies, I would cry. I can maybe if I get myself emotional enough. Anyway thanks for the comment please tell your opionion!☺

jedigal1990 yeah i read one of the episode 3 books can't remember the author and i liked how it put more detail in it i love reading the books but i agree i yell at the tv too i hate seeing the clones go against the jedi and anakin fighting obiwan its sad but its still an awsome movie

GalindaGirl Thanks for the comment. ☺ I would hate being Padme', no wonder she died. I would have wanted too LOL! I would be her and a mix of Ahsoka.

GalindaGirl Anymore commetns welcome please do I want to hear other opionions.

XNaley_JamesX Well, I expect everyone's opinium, including yours. But for me, ep III is the best/my favorte movie. (together with ep II) I think it's probably cause you watched the movie when you were still a bit too young and that's why you're kind of 'schocked' everytime you see it. I agree that it's a sad movie, but that's just what's so great about it! For me, it doesn't always have to be happy to love it, I mean, I just love crying when I watch a movie! It makes it more deeper, and you really get dragged in the movie. And that's the power of SW! When you really feel the pain & emotions of the characters that you relate too, I just think that it's awesome! So yeah, I really really love it, but I also understand it if you don't.

GalindaGirl Same here, I just can't cry. But my sister trained herself too. But I get so sad when I watch it. But not cry, I still need to break that wall down so I will. I also get confused, I don't see that many facail expressions, the acting isn't the best. I know because I'm an actress in training. The actress of Padme' Nattile Portman did an awesome job. She was starting to cry, now that was good. But Anakin's, Heyden CHristisen? He didn't do the best. I was about 7 or 8 when I first saw it. But now, I yell at the TV, and try to cry. Because writers need to cry when the write a sad part of a story. Thank's so much for the comment!!!!☺

Icepaw_Kenobi I actually like III best. I thought it was the best acting in the prequels. I thought Ewan and Natalie did a really good job and Hayden could've done better but it was still really good. It might just be me though. My favorite movie besides Star Wars is about Joan of Arc. I always cry in it. It's the only movie I've ever cried in. But, back on topic, I really liked Revenge of the Sith and the ending wasn't really supposed to be happy. I mean, we already knew that Darth Vader was Anakin. Also the fact that it was the first Star Wars movie I saw (My best friend spoiled every movie for me before I saw any of them) probably had something to do with it. I also agree with what XNaley_JamesX said. I wasn't that bothered by it by watching at a yong age though, I watched it when it first came out at seven or eight. I really don't know why I like it so much, but I think it's mostly because it's so well written and emotional.

jedigal1990 you guys make good points and it still is one of my favorite movies though i hated seeing some of the stuff i still loved the moive like Xanley_jamesx said it doesn't have to make you happy to love it. you definitly get the emoition from this movie and i think thats important i mean you feel happy sad excited etc all during one movie it does mess with your emoitons and its great.

GalindaGirl I still feel really sad in the end, I wouldn't clasify it as a fave though. Well also when I wrote this I wasn't as big as a SW fan that I am now. I know much more than I did when I wrote this. But still, not a fave. Well to tell the truth I can't EVER choose a fave.

Cagirl304 Oh I so understand, I can watch eps III, but only the first part as soon as Ani bows to the Enpiear, I can't watch it from there. That is the only SW movie I have seen in the theater, I was 8 at the time and did not know about Luke and all of the others then, even though I saw the movies, then I thought Padma was Leia so when she died I could not stop crying. So your not alone.