UM DUH she should be, she LIVED with her . aww shes like the kid karen never had (besides lucas) .
but if you think about it peyton is basically just as close cuz they worked at tric together & karen is such a leytoner .

Yeah, i agree with lila, but i think brooke is still a bit close to Karen.


But just wait because LP will get married and Peyton will be karens future Daughter-in-law..lol!! I hope that happens!

oh karen is definately a leytoner even though i think she's closer to brooke

i agree with lila, but i think karen cares for peyton just as much, she was asking brooke about her when she arrived back in tree hill. yer karen is such a leytoner :P - it didnt even show karen with lindsey :P

karen is a leytoner no doubt about it but brooke is like her own daughter, somehow karen sees a daughter in brooke and brooke sees a mom in karen coz karen is the nurturing type of mum that brooke never had so that way brooke is much closer to karen

"karen sees a daughter in brooke"
LOL wth i totally don`t know where that came from. she sees just as much of a daughter in brooke as she does in peyton. after some consideration i have decided shes just as close w. both, theres no one over the other w. her .

I dunno...but I always thought Peyton's a little bit closer to Karen ( = I mean...they ran Tric together and right now I'm thinking of that prom (???) in season 2 when Peyton was so miserable and Karen tried to help her. Or in season 5 when she talked to her (and Brooke haha) right before Lincas' wedding ( : And she's ESPECIALLY to her closer since LP are married and had a daughter!