Peyton was so original in season 1, so much more complex. Leyton were at their best in season one and they had way more chemistry. Plus she looks best in season 1!
Peyton has got worse as the seasons have went on. I miss bad ass P.Sawyer ;(

Yeah i agree about her being more original and complex in season 1...i liked her more in the earlier season!

The only season that I really dislike her was in S5!

i agree completley with 3_ThePretender, i LOVED peyton s1 to s3, but as the seasons progressed she just kept getting worse. but my fave p.sawyer season is 2 forsure, shes awesome with her music and being a good friend and with jake and jenny <3

i love original p.sawyer as much as anyone else does... but i preferred the seasons when she was truly happy. which i think are either seasons 6 or 4. she was a wreck in the other seasons lmao

Love her in every season but I also love happy Peyton, so 4 & 6, then 1

I love the 1st season Peyton like everyone and that's true she was a more complex character with a really strong personality and her story lines weren't just base on Lucas like in her 3 last seasons.
Personally I really love the different storylines she had in season 3 maybe it was most of the time dramatic because of the loss of another mother, being shot and at the end the loss of her friendship with Brooke but I really love how she made her decision and it was really interesting to see that evolution between P.Sawyer season 1 and 3. Then I wasn't a big fan because it was more Leyton or Breyton than Peyton.

6 and 1

I connected more with Peyton season 1. Like I really got a good look into her mind.

All of them!

I could write a book on this, I love Peyton's journey through all season's!!! Just starting to find herself, a good relationship with Nathan and having some awesome friend's in Lucas, Brook and Haley. Finally a good relationship with Jake! But most of her time between it felt like she was a train wreck but she bounced back and was getting happy in season four but I think the happiest in season six!!!