no doubt about it...that was the best fight scene...and leyton is true love always....also hilarie and chad did a really awesome job with that scene

even tho i choose BL fight, i think that PL fight was pretty intense...P was acting like a psycho, she scared the crap out of me!

"Why wont you let me all the way in!" omg i cried when i heard that!!! LP was just scary BL was emotional and deep!

it was so intense luke was thinking that she didnt care but she does care with all of her heart. Then Peyton trowing His books at Luke and saying you said i was great,you said i could be Great,you said we were distend to be together you said it to the world you said it to me and i wish you never have because you didn't mean any of it. IT WAS A GREAT fight

I cried as well chlarkfan! Sophia did such an amazing job! and those words brooke said were sad! And that BL fight was one of my fave. Scenes, but the LP fight totally knocked that scene right of my fave list i mean the BL fight still my fave, but the LP fight i thought so much better and it was emotional and deep! And those lines peyton said "I was great, you said i could be great, you said we were distined to be together you said it to the world you said it to me and i wish you never have because you didn't mean any of it."--that really got me!! Hilarie and Chad did a really, really great Job!! They got so into character!

there was so much tension between the 2, u cud tell they still loved eachother

the brucas fight was so sad..

this fight was so intense
the brucas fight does not even compare

i liked when peyton through the copies of his book she bought i was rotfl

I really liked this fight, it was the best one on the show. Not only did it turn out great but I couldn't look away from the TV. Chad and Hilaire were awesome they have great chemistry together. I wil say the Brucus fight was good but dosen't come close to this one.

The LP fight was really angry! The Brucas fight just made me cry, so neither.

LP's fight was disturbing...it was like they REALLY hated each other...I guess true emotions showed ;)

BL's fight was amazing soo sad but you could feel the love at the same time and then the dance and the kisss aaaaahhhh*thud*

Awww it was like so amazing! I cry EVERY time! That was such an awesome scene and there was so much emotion!

they were both amazing scenes but sophias acting and her crying was wat did it for me hils acting was good but not a patch on sophias

Aw for me it was totally the other way around Hilarie really blew me away with her acting!

I picked Brucas, because they were an actual couple at that time, and it really moved me. But I'll have to admit I think that Hil has some great acting in that scene. But I agree with saBrucas because I really thought that they had reached that point of no return with Leyton there. But overall great emotion in both!

this was just incredably sad!

NO QUESTION ABOUT IT!!! Hil and Chad are amazing!! ESPECIALLY HIL!

I cry everytime I watch this scene. Sophia Bush is just an amazing actress! And I really hated Lucas at this point. I really understood her frustration...
I can't remember that Leyton Fight exactly, so I think it wasn't that good :P But Hilarie can act great, too! As proved in 4.15 Breyton Fight...

Beyond amazing, so much angst and passion