Best fight (TRY not to be biased on favorite couples & go simply on who had the best)? Poll Results - One Tree Hill

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

One Tree Hill Best fight (TRY not to be biased on favorite couples & go simply on who had the best)?

153 fans picked:

Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it'

43%

Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in'

42%

Naley, 'one more day like this nathan & i promise you you will have -nothing'

12%

Brulian, 'High school brooke graduated'

Jeyton, after peyton looses Jenny (sorry, couldnt think of any big jetyon fights)

no votes yet

AMYonetreehill posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

51 comments

	carambolas picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': It was so passionate and heartbreaking, then the brucas fight posted over a year ago.

	girly_girl picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': This was just so sad! Sophia's acting in this scene was breathtaking! posted over a year ago.

	leytonfaan_18 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': So passionate! Also the Brucas one I suppose, Sophia was amazing in it. posted over a year ago.

	Kirkir picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Also, the Brucas fight. posted over a year ago.

	Team_Brooke picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': ^Agree with girly_girl! posted over a year ago.

	hhw picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': the Brucas fight too posted over a year ago.

	lauren1102 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Also agree with girly_girl! ♥ posted over a year ago.

	VictoriNoRisuu picked Naley, 'one more day like this nathan & i promise you you will have -nothing': I loved Joy's acting here... So powerful & heartbreaking! Then would be Leyton (loved Peyton throughing the books where Lucas lies about them!) & brucas - she was so heartbroken & her words so touching... Btw, do you see that girls rule these fight? Guys are standing there, listening, not able to find the words... posted over a year ago.

	AMYonetreehill picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Leytons, was incredible -the drama and passion that went into that fight,her shouting & throwing books -you could just tel that all they really wanted was eachother back -so intense. Followef by Brucas' -Sophia's acting here was amazing, faultless nd so full of emotion, you could see the hurt in sophias eyes. Then it would be Naleys -really anger fuelled. posted over a year ago.

	gossipgirljade picked Naley, 'one more day like this nathan & i promise you you will have -nothing': Joy was amazing! I just loved this scene, it was so powerful. Brucas comes VERY close : ) PS: Every scene here was ruled by the girls. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Shanice_12 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': This is like the HARDEST PICK EVERR! To be honest, I wasn't going to choose, because I love all 3 including Naley, Leyton and Brucas! <3 The girls totally nailed it! In all of them, their acting was just, beyond words! Just Amazing! ♥ But I think I choose this one cause Sophia's acting was unforgettable, she was going through a lot in season 3 with the whole Chophia break-up and this scene was too breath taking! And I believe that she did that great because it did feel so real to her. So that's why I choose that one, but after it comes the NH & LP one, they were both really really touchy and heart breaking and i can never choose between those two! posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Rolemodel2011 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Brucas, Leyton, then Naley. Yeah, I agree with everything everyone has already said! posted over a year ago.

	xQueenOfHearts picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Come on! LP fans cannot even deny that BL fight was like the ultimate & saddest fight ever. Sophia's acting was heartbreaking & this scene it's like so amazing because Sophia was literally Brooke. Like for real. What she was going through with Chad she just put it all in the scene & look in Chad face. He's obviously hurt & he feels like Sophia too. But of course, me, as a Bl fan, I cannot deny either that the LP fight it's sad. It sad & I really liked the script on that scene. It's one of the few LP scenes that I like. Hilarie acting was amazing! & hell yeah! <3 the girls kick ass when it comes to fights xD posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	TizzFan4evr picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': I don't like Leyton but Hilarie was sooo good in this scene! I loved it. posted over a year ago.

	Jessica4695 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': love this one , I think for me here isn't competition. but I also loved the Naley one <3 and the BJ fight wasn't so good , the 'You told Alex I can't have kids' one would have been better , I think if that would be posted I would choose that [: posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Jennifer_B picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Chad and Hilarie just nailed this scene! posted over a year ago.

	kellyerin87 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Definitely Leyton and Brucas'... the Naley fight didn't really phase me much. Yes, Sophia's acting was great in the Brucas scene... But so was Hilarie's AND Chad's in the Leyton scene. As far as the actual fight itself... I hands down have to go with LP's. It felt like more of a FIGHT to me. the Brucas scene was good, but it just felt like more drama, rather than a fight. In the Leyton scene, Lucas was actually arguing back with Peyton more ("I gave up on us?!? By PROPOSING I gave up on us? Oh that's great Peyton! Alright fine, you wanna talk truth? Let's talk truth! You gave up on ME!")... Which made it more of a two way argument, and made it much more intense. The angst, passion, tension, resentment, and animosity in the LP scene is just undeniable. You could really feel that they each had these feelings built up inside for SO long, and when they finally got them out it was so intense. It was the only fight out of these options that gave me chills. Plus the fact that it showed us LP in a new light made it much more dramatic. We hadn't seen them fight hardly at all before that, so seeing this big fight between them left more of an impact on me. As opposed to the other couples, who had fights all the time. This scene just proved how much they each were really hurting, in order to be THAT angry at eachother. Because we had NEVER seen them that angry before. But with Brucas and Naley, for me it was like "oh, another fight". But for LP, It was really out of character and out of the ordinary for them. Which made me take it a little more seriously than the others. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	SG1-090 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': For me it's no competition. This is my favourite Leyton scene ever! I know weird, right? The emotion, the acting, I cry every single time I watch this scene, it is breathtaking! The whole thing is strangely beautiful. They're acting is just....they were both top of their game here and Hilarie especially I mean WOW. Plus everything they said, Peyton was just so right and so angry and hurt and I just hated Lucas so much in that scene, but then Peyton starts throwing books at him! It was just SO great lol always makes me laugh <33 posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	-carola-fan- picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': I think this was the best. The fight in all of s 5 was really heartbreaking... posted over a year ago.

	ns_23 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': All. Damn ! posted over a year ago.

	livexthexlife92 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': no competition for me. this scene was utter perfection. it captured an emotion, Sophia's performance made this scene GOLDEN. you could feel her heartbrake. but i have to say i actually like this LP scene, i hate LP, but i liked this fight, not cuz they were fighting but hil did a good job acting lol. idk it was just a good scene lol. but nothing beats this BL scene. honestly i cant even remember naleys. and well jeyton never fought, but umm i guess i good fight is the one they had in s3 when peyton says "every song ends jake, is that nay reason not to enjoy the music?" but idk if that was really a fight fight? lol posted over a year ago.

	Dansea08 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Brulian had better fights.Jeyton...well...no.Brucas....now that's where you start getting to the great fights.I think Sophia's acting was BRILLIANT and I had so much sympathy for Brooke in that scene and it's the BEST Brucas fight BUT it was NOT the best fight out of these choices. I wasn't surprised to see the leyton fight because well that was an awesome fight...but then I saw the naley icon.I remembered the storyline and I picked the "naley fight" option. But then...... I had to watch these scenes again..and had to change my answer. As much as Naley's situation was more heartbreaking,that scene wasn't amazing...it was great...but not amazing. I watched Brucas's fight and for the first time I didn't get annoyed at a specific line that Brooke said(that made me not absolutely love this scene) Sophia stole that scene with her acting skills! And then I watched the leyton scene....(a scene that I have watched so many damn times) but I wanted to be fair and compare it now rather than what I remembered from awhile back. Also I thought that maybe for the first time I would pick Brucas's fight over Leyton's fight. But then Chad's acting skills surfaced in the Leyton fight.Even though I think everything that Lucas said was BS....Chad's acting was AMAZING. What can I say about Hilarie and that scene besides...WOW. The intensity level was sky rocketing! After watching that scene...it was easy to pick....Sophia's acting was brilliant,but Hilarie and Chad's acting combined in that scene was......absolutely magnificent! I think Joy had a few great parts in that scene but overall with the lack of amazing acting from James(which was the case for Chad in the Brucas fight...but Sophia's acting made the scene brilliant!)...Joy's acting wasn't strong enough and therefore there was no chance of naley being a contender. <sorry that's it long.....> posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Lisiii picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Although I don't like Leyton...this fight was really intense! They were both so...angry and frantic. But the Brucas and Naley fights were bad as well / = posted over a year ago.

	Leytonfan4ever picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': For me it was between LP & BL, BUT I gotta give to LP! I'm not biased AT ALL! The LP scene was SUPER intense, and to see LP really get into an ACTUAL fight gave me CHILLS! BUT i won't lie, BL's scene gave me chills too, but that was just because of Sophia's acting, it was AMAZING<3! posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': No fight compares to this one. LP bring the emotion like no other in this scene. The intensity and epicness was just off the charts! U-N-B-E-L-I-E-V-A-B-L-E posted over a year ago.

	Cas_Cat_2 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': no competition for me. this scene was utter perfection. it captured an emotion, Sophia's performance made this scene GOLDEN. you could feel her heartbrake. but i have to say i actually like this LP scene, i hate LP, but i liked this fight, not cuz they were fighting but hil did a good job acting lol. idk it was just a good scene lol. but nothing beats this BL scene. ^ THIS. <3 The BL scene was BRILIANT. Love the NH scene too, it was so sad watching them that way. =[[ And i also like the LP fight; if someone ever made pick the top 5 LP scenes or something, i would include that fight. The BJu fight was good as well, but compared to the 3 scenes i mentioned above, can't really stand a chance. And the same with JP. posted over a year ago.

	XNaley_JamesX picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Leyton, Brucas & Naley - AMAZING SCENES!!!!!!!!! posted over a year ago.

	oth_leyton_tla picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': This was so emotional & tense. Hilarie Burton did an amzing job and she really just let herself go emotionally. I really felt for Peyton in this scene. I also liked the Brucas scene which is very rare for me but I must admit that this scene was so sad, it really got to me. Naley's scene was very emotional, Joy was great. It was amazing to see Haley get that way because she rarely does! posted over a year ago.

	Nibylandija picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': NO FREAKING COMPETITION HERE. SOPHIA WAS JUST BRILLIANT. posted over a year ago.

	BellaScott picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Sophia was great in the brucas scene but Chad didn´t really do that much in the scene. In the Leyton scene they were both equally upset and heartbroken posted over a year ago.

	Dean-girlx picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': The best [acted&emotional] scene on OTH. EVER. ♥ and then the Naley "are you even going to SAY anything?!" posted over a year ago.

	brucas4ever picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': also Best Acting In ALL Of OTH. posted over a year ago.

	brucas4ever picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': The LP scene was a knock off BL tears scene. To me it the brucas one actually fit in the show posted over a year ago.

	Bubbly1 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': It was such a long time coming, they was so tension before that, it neede to come out somehow.. LOL a BL know off, that was funny posted over a year ago.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': LMAO ok... how in the world was this LP scene a "knock off BL scene"??? Just because heaven forbid, another couple was fighting besides BL for once? I know BL pretty much trademark fighting lol, but that doesn't mean that every other fight in the show is a knock off of BL. This LP scene was NOTHING like any of BL's fights actually. It involved different topics of discussion, different emotions, completely different circumstances, completely different time, different setting, BOTH characters were angry and really involved in the fight, different outcome... I could go on and on. This fight was discussing why a MARRAIGE, and a life together didn't work out for them, and the hostility they both had because of it. It wasn't some petty high school drama. It was a serious adult fight.. discussing serious, life altering, adult issues. BL have never had a scene even remotely close to that one. It's so funny to me how some BL fans claim that everything is a copy of BL. First Brulian, but now Leyton?!? I'm sorry, but nothing about Leyton will ever be a knock off of BL. That statement was just ridiculous. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	brattynemz picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': This brings me to tears every single time I watch it. I just feel so heartbroken! I loved the LP one too, KICKASS acting on Hil's part. Ya know if Peyton wasn't acting like a psychotic ex-girlfriend in s5 I would've liked LP back then. LOL! Idk, Joy is an amazing actress but during that particular scene I just didn't feel anything. IMO Naley had better scenes. The BJu scene does NOT even compare to the BL/LP scenes. Not even the Naley one. Even Dan/Karen had better fighting scenes than BJu, LMAO. posted over a year ago.

	KathyHalliwell picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Or the Leyton one. But I tried not to be biased, as you asked, so I eventually picked Brucas. posted over a year ago.

	3_ThePretender picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': and LP's scene. Both were amazing. posted over a year ago.

	bright_angel picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': And Leyton fight! posted over a year ago.

	Chlarkfan picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Sophia when she starts crying i cry! Her face and her emotion and portrayel in this scene is absoloutly stunning. posted over a year ago.

	OTHGossipGirl picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': Well to tell the truth this is probably my favorite LP scene every! I mean sure I have others but this one I loved. It was heartbreaking, I cry everytime I see it. but the Naley and BL ones were damn good too. posted over a year ago.

	SG1-090 picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': The LP scene was a knock off BL tears scene. LMFAO seriously? Right okay then...rolls eyes posted over a year ago.

	sophialover picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': No effin need to get biased. posted over a year ago.

	PrettyGirl93 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': ive never seen a more emotional scene on one tree hill than this one, the acting was perfect and it gets me every time. imo no other scene even remotley compares to this one. ♥ x posted over a year ago.

	dancerbabe16 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': "I'm not pushing you away Lucas, i'm holding on for dear life. I just need you to need me back." Breathtaking. Sophia was stunning and even the broken look on Chads face was brilliant. One of my favorite scenes ever. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	katsa picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': BEST.FIGHT.EVER. posted over a year ago.

	benjaycami_amor picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': By far! posted over a year ago.

	Kate1800 picked Naley, 'one more day like this nathan & i promise you you will have -nothing': She was pised at Nathan posted over a year ago.

	Leyton4ever picked Leyton, 'you did not mean any of it': I love this scene. The reason that i love it has more to do with how fantastic i thought both chad and hilarie were in this scene, especially chad as his acting isn't always the greatest but the emotion and intensity they brought to this scene made it fantastic. I don't know why but this scene to me just showed how much leyton loved each other and how they were meant to be together no matter how much lucas fought it. scenes like this make me miss him. if chad had matched how fantastic sophia was in their scene i could consider picking it, but he's not even close, lol. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Movie_BUFF024 picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': Leyton is a close second, followed by Naley. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	Drisina picked Brucas, 'why cant you ever just let me all the way in': From these totally Leyton or Brucas but for me personally it felt more intense the BL one , seeing Sophia cry her eyes out and for the simple stunning acting that she put on. posted over a year ago.