Anyway let me first say that this scene is one of my all time favorite scenes ever in OTH. Chad and Hilarie do such an amazing job with this scene.

Well I've rewatched this scene a few times, as people make up picks or ask questions and such. And the more I watch this scene the more I wanna take Lucas's side on this whole arguement they had.

Let me just make this clear I'm saying I wanna take his side in this particular scene and I'm speaking only about this scene. I think they were both wrong in some of the things they said. When I first watched this episode I immediately took Peyton's side...