One Tree Hill Article: brooke and peyton, have the same type?

16

posted by gossipgirljade

lucas, the boy who started all the sharing...

So you guys already know brooke and peyton have shared many boys, but I wanted to compare the relationships they had with each guy so here it goes...

. Lucas- he's the main boy they shared. i think they both had great relationship's with him. ultimately, peyton ends up with him but, brooke brings out the wild,fun, and crazy side of him that we all love.I think that overall brucas had the better relationship, they made lots of mistakes and grew as a couple from them.

. Nathan- They didn't really share him, but brooke did sleep with him. Brooke has a great friendship with nathan,but we never see a lot of nathan/peyton scenes. overall, Neither really had a good relationship with him romance wise.

. Julian- Brooke has the better relationship with him so far. but we don't know much about the peyton/julian relationship in the first place. peyton and julian could of had an amazing past for all we know,but for right now i think the fan favorite is brulian.

. chase/pete- brooke was with chase. peyton had a fling with pete. peyton kisses chase in season 5, and brooke kisses pete in season 3. that evens the playing field. I just thought i'd bring this up.: )

So, brooke and peyton have shared many boys, but they're still best friends for life. If you guys have any other opinions on the relationships they shared comment and let me know. : ), GGJ

still, best friends : )

clairemig22, othobsessed92 and 14 others like this

Leyton4ever i actually think that peyton and julian probably had a really good relationship but their relationship ended because he realized she was never going to let go of lucas.

Laurencia7 True, they have a type. But the same reason they are Best Friends, people are usually BFF with people who share common goals, and interests with...therefore they would be attracted to the same types of guys. It is all relative.

rosangie "Brooke has a great friendship with nathan,but we never see a lot of nathan/peyton scenes." Disagree completely. Both friendships rarely have a scene together. The rest: I agree. They do have a type and it sucks for them, but there is nothing they can do about it.

gossipgirljade well, they had a few scenes earlier this season where nathan talks to brooke and sees how she's doing. he checks in on her. they've had at least 4 scenes together, but i haven't seen any peyton/nathan scenes.

Leyton4ever throughout the seasons nathan and brooke and nathan and peyton have both had scenes...but i don't think i would say brooke and nathan have a great relationship...i'd say peyton and nathan are closer but we don't get to see either relationship much which sucks

svety74 "Brooke has a great friendship with nathan,but we never see a lot of nathan/peyton scenes." Where do you see this great friendship I dunno. They surely didn't have many scenes together and except the time where Brooke was beaten up and Nathan see how she's doing I don't really think they had such amazing scenes. The one which came to my mind is when they were 'playing' about the splinkers but other than that the only scenes they had together in S5 were about Jamie. With Peyton on the other hand he had a relationship for two years. They were together in 1x18 'To wish impossible things' and they seemed pretty close to me. In S2, when Haley left Nathan passed sometime with Peyton. In S3 Peyton took his side against Haley and for the first half of S3 they seemed good friends. In S4 they had the 'Pictures of You' episode together.In S5 she took him to the hospital. I don't know but for me they are better WAY better friends than Brooke & Nathan at least from what I see.