answer this question

Movies Question

which do you like better, the twilight saga or the harry potter series?

 sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
next question »

Movies Answers

Mrs-Grint said:
Harry Potter. Since this is in the movie spot, I won't say why the books are so amazing, just the movies.

Movie One - Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone: This movie for die-hard fans was pretty damn good. The music by John Williams was excellent! Chris Colombus stuck to the books well and the acting wasn't too bad for a few ten year olds of which two of them hadn't any proper acting experience at all. The only thing that I could critise about it is, although it kept to the books, it was quite long and boring. But altogether a really sweet movie.

Movie Two - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets: When I first saw this film when I was six I absaloutley adored it and nearly screamed when the Basilisk started chasing Harry around the chamber. It was the darkest film I had ever seen at that age, especially with the blood writing on the walls. Another Chris Colombus film, it was quite long and sometimes can be boring. But I still love it. <3

Movie Three - Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: OH MY GOSH! This is my favourite movie... I think. I still adore it. It's just.. so epic. Alfonso Cuaron is DA BOMB!! I can't actually put into words why I like it soo... next one.

Movie Four - Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire: This is another one of my absaloute favourites. I love Dan Radcliffe's hair in this movie because it looks exactly like Harry's hair is described (in the other films he looks like a frog). It was brilliant, emotional, amusing. Ralph Fiennes was excellent. Well done, well done.

Movie Five - Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix: I have to admit, in my opinion this movie SUCKED! David Yates made a butchery of it. It was the longest book, with so many important events, one of the BEST books. It didn't deserve a movie as crappy as this. At least Dan Radcliffe did justice in the scene where Sirius died. It was very good. Oh yeah, and Helena Bonham Carter was EXCELLENT! I love her.

Movie Six - Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince: Another David Yates movie, but it wasn't as rubbish at OOTP. I quite liked it, but it's not one of my favourites. I thought Tom Felton's peformance in the Lightning-Struck Tower scene was AMAZING! And the wand fight in the bathroom. It was his time to shine! Once again, Helena was brilliant. Altogether a DECENT movie. I just hope Yates doesn't mess up Deathly Hallows. Or. I. Will. Kill him.

I fell asleep in Twilight and New Moon, well not literally, but it was so boring that I played with the drinks bottle I had. Kristen Stewart, in my opinion, is a really terrible actress. So.. there we go!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I like the bit at the start, where Bellatrix & Narcissa are at Snapes house, and she picks up that thing, and get's told not to put things down, and the way she puts it down, and her facial expressions make me laugh so much! :D Nice one btw (:
ABDCFan- posted over a year ago
*
I love that scene, too! Bellatrix is so funny, yet so evil. That's why she's one of my favourite characters - Helena was a contributing factor due to how epic she is. :D
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
*
that's a great answer! and I agree btw ;)
Simply_Indigo posted over a year ago
Hellohoudini said:
I like both. And I just dont understand why people keep comparing the two....they only have four things in common
1. They're both geared towards a younger audience.
2. One is an adventure story..the other is a romance.
3. They're both fiction.
4. They were both written by females.

So why do we have to choose? Why cant we like both? Why is there this on-going-war between Twilight fans and Harry Potter fans? It makes no sense.

Sparklechild5....if you are going to continue asking questions like these...you need to learn to respect others people's opinions and stop bashing them if they are different tfrom yours.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
THANK YOU! I'm sick of Harry Potter and Twilight being compared, the insults from both sides (obsessive fans and haters), and this whole damn war altogether! Maybe Twilight wouldn't be so bad if SOME people just left it the hell alone. And the girl that's posting these questions needs to stfu if she's going to act like an idiot whenever someone disagrees with her or says something.
sapherequeen posted over a year ago
*
im not "acting like an idiot". i like hearing people's opinions about which is better which is WHY I ASKED THIS QUESTION duh. its too bad u feel that way
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
then if your asking questions like this and wanting other peoples opinions then putting them down, isn't that a little, oh what do they call it???? HYPICRITICAL? yeah. I went there & I bought property!!!!
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
CullenProperty said:
In my opinion, the Twilight Saga; I've read all the books and watched both the movies. I'm a Twi-hard at heart. I've never been able to get into the Harry Potter series, books or movies, the wizard thing just isn't for me. Twilight has more of a romancy story to it and I'm a true romantic at heart, so Twilight all the way baby!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
twilight, romantic? lolz.
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
it is. if you dont think it is, something is wrong wich u!
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
what the H E double hocky sticks are you friggin talking about? okay, frankly, i don't care.
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
shomill said:
I don't watch either.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
sinner!!! just kidding!!! everyone each their own!! :D
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
then y'd u answer da question?
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
thank you?
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
Desdemona-Kali said:
HARRY POTTER!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
artsyblue said:
idk i like both
twilight is gettin kinda old
so maybe harry potter
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lexirae26 said:
I myself like the twilight saga best.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
DIDO!!
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
i *think* u mean "ditto"...slow much?
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
f off
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
chiccs said:
Definately the Harry Potter series. They contain everything from violence to romance. From fantasy to reality and well... everything. Not saying anything against the Twilight Saga but I think they lack the variety and excitement Harry Potter brings with it...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i think it's just a fact that the harry potters are written better.
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
rwlol said:
????????
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
wuts ur problem? y'd u even answer the question just to say that retard?
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
don't call people retards
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
you are the waste of time. people have opinons yours is just rudeness!!!
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
Shepard14 said:
HARRY POTTER RULES!!!
I ♥ the movies!!!
(and the books but this is the movie spot after all)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
allen101 said:
Harry Potter!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
anime-teo said:
harry potter of course
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
mswaldass said:
Definitely, most definitely Harry Potter.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
jedigal1990 said:
definitly harry potter actually i'm super biased because i haven't seen twilight and i have nothing against it i'm just tired of hearing about it over and over again everywhere you go and the twihards are getting annoying. but sticking on topic i got to say harry potter i have loved it since it first came out. I love the plot and the variety in it
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
it is a really great series and yeah, twihards are SO OBNOXIOUS! it's like "ooh taylor lautner" "what are you, team jacob or team edward?" like laame.
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
how are we so obnoxious and harry potter fans aren't huh? I mean, come on daniel radcliff.... not the hottest guy I'VE ever seen... taylor lautner on ther other hand.... LOOK OUT BABY!! WHOO
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
*
mhm. hmh. okay both of u are just really getting on my nerves now. so frankly sir, i don't give a damn!
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
Hkiara said:
I was so bored when I saw twilight! My friend said it was so good, but I was soooo bored!!!

Harry Potter is better!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
did you read the books?
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
ilovethexfacter said:
Twilight series i love twilight 1 - 2
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lifesariot said:
harry potter for sure!!! i'm sooo sick of twilight.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
melikhan said:
the twilight saga
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ThatDamnLlama said:
Harry Potter has a PLOT. and dynamic characters, significant messages, actual vampires that DON'T SPARKLE, real werewolves, and it shows the importance of friendship. it has mulitple genres; fantasy, adventure, action, suspense, comedy, and romance. Twilight is just fantasy. (no romance at all: you call a 100 year old virgin stalking a teenage girl LOVE?!?) overall, Twilight is just a fad, and Harry Potter will last way longer then a lifetime. you can't possibley compare something as boring, cheesy, and plotless as Twilight with the amazing, life changing series, Harry Potter. that's an insult!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Just an FYI...they're both fiction which means there in fiction world anything goes...and there arent really "actual vampires" or "real werewolves" or "wizards". Harry Potter is just a fantasy too. Twilight has a plot and a significant message.
Hellohoudini posted over a year ago
*
love knows no bonds...yeah. mongoose you had a good point. that was hilarious that the main theme/message of twilight isnt love knows no bonds but "feel free to stalk people as long as ur sexy" lolz!!
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
mongoose; twilight has been around for 6 years, almost a decade. so i can call harry potter a fad just like u can call twilight a fad. hellohoudini; nice way of saying it. sparkle; no one stalked anyone. PLUS: SOME CALL IT STALKING, I CALL IT LOVE.
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
gsaid885 said:
twilight sucks
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Ooops! That's short and not sweet at all! You have a straight opinion. It’s your right but a bit narrow-minded. I do understand that you are a HP fan then. So am I. Does that mean that Twilight fans suck and are your automatic enemies because you are not on the same page? If they would say that HP sucks, what would you say? The question was which one of the two you liked better, not the one that sucked. Something is not automatically bad because the choices are different. Take a look at my comment just under and tell me what you think about my theory. Hope to hear from you soon - LuvAlwaiz♥Jj9
juicyjossy9 posted over a year ago
juicyjossy9 said:
Both actually. But definitely and obviously not for the same reasons at all! And I’m sure I’m not alone thinking that… The only similarity being the fiction of the extremely well-written stories and the planetary success, it's like comparing apples and oranges. Both delicious fruits but don’t look the same. Both sweet and tangy but don’t taste the same. Do not grow in the same country. Potter and Twilight series are both delicious, sweet and tangy, but our human senses are not treated the same way and on the same level at all. I don’t think I’m wrong by saying that a 6-year old would love Twilight as much as Harry Potter. What goes on between the ears for one does not generate that “something between the legs” the other does. I am very proud to say I will own both complete series, books and DVDs. But I could also say that I’ve never felt the urge to read/watch Potter in the evening and through the night as much as I did for Twilight. To my opinion, Potter is my orange and Twilight my apple. I equally love apples and oranges, but for me, the urge is a lot more easier to calm down by eating an apple... ‘cos I don’t have to peel it. And I can eat as many as I want to without ever get sick. To the contrary, it’ll only make me feel better! And it’s always there, always available when I need it... like a magic potion. – Thanks Sparklechild5 for asking this great question! – LuvAlwaiz♥Jj9
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thank u for the compliment!! i <3 your answer; u r one of the few ppl who actually answers it instead of yelling at me for asking something controversial
sparklechild5 posted over a year ago
*
Glad you are happy. Is this not was it's all about? Are we not here to share opinions on various subjects. Controversy??? Why should there be controversy?? Those two are indeed popular, but I don't undertand why there should be a war because of that. If everybody on Earth had the same opinions and tastes, life would be kind of dull, don't you think? I just wanted you to know that I've added a little comment to gsaid885's one on the sucking... - Snuggz LuvAlwaiz♥Jj9
juicyjossy9 posted over a year ago
*
yes your right it probably doesn't
gsaid885 posted over a year ago
x-TLF-x said:
The Twilight Saga :D x
select as best answer
The Twilight Saga :D x
posted over a year ago 
*
YES
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
domiqqq said:
the twillight saga of course!! Harry Potter si good too, but i run with vampires...thats just me, :DDDD and i think i love more the story about a human and a vampire in love than a famous young wizard :DDDDDDP
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
agreed. love ur icon btw.
CullenProperty posted over a year ago
HCx said:
i liked the twighlight films the first one was good the second one was quite boring but the third ine was great but overall i would have to say i prefered harry potter i have seen the all like 10 times and for me i think the twilight films have the same story in all 3 of the movies like there all really similar but in the harry potter films they all have different plots and things. i thought the first one was good ,the second was was really good , my fav was deffinatly the third one , i really didnt like the forth one , the fith one i thought was great and the sixth on i thought was good. i hope the last two are brilliant , they look really good but i dont know how they will turn out because the actors all look really old now soo .. i hope they will be great and btw tom felton is the fittest out of harry potter and twilight!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Persephone713 said:
Well, no offense to any Twilight fans. But I cant take Twilight anymore. I was never even a fan. But I just cant take looking at any of those people any longer. They are all over. And yes there are such things as fads and classics. Sorry to say Twilight is a fad that is already dying off. But if Summit was wiser and didnt overexpose it so much. That probably wouldnt have happened. 1. Hot Topic stuff is downsized for the Eclipse movie by 3/4 because no body bought the Twilight and New moon Merchandise, it ended up in clearance.
2. They have big opening weekends then drop off severely. Not good.
3. UH..Harry Potter is in the Classics section of the Book Store and Twilight series is in teen reading.
4. If people find things like the Burger King commercial and Vampires Suck more funny than the actual movies than you know you have a problem.
5. You have a right to call it love. But I think Twilight promotes stalking, and Pedophilia and Bella is a horrible example for young girls.

So to answer your question now that I backed up my answer. Harry Potter. I have been a fan of the books since 98 when I was 9. And seen all the movies and read all the books. Cant believe its been 10 years for the movies and 12-13 for the books. Sad. But it will live on forever.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
xflow said:
TWILIGHT SAGA all the way!!!!!!!!!!!


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ledbychrist said:
Twilight Saga is so much better. The suspence of the movie makes you feel as if you are actually apart of the movie, and the graphics are real.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Simply_Indigo said:
I like Harry Potter better. Twilight's just not my type of thing.
select as best answer
I like Harry Potter better. Twilight's just not my type of thing.
posted over a year ago 
next question »