House M.D.
House M.D. Do you want Cameron@The new spot banner?
This question is now closed
69 fans picked: |
Yes, of course
|
|||
No!
|
|||
I would even want Kutner on it (-:c...but actually I like the current banner.
(added by caramelmilk)
|
|||
No.I want banner only with house
|
|||
I not want new Banner&Icon
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
The show House MD is not only what's happening right now, it's a story that currently starts its 7th season, but that doesn't mean the 6 previous seasons are forgotten, does it?
Jennifer Morrison worked for that show for almost 6 years and Allison Cameron was a very important character, so I ask myself: Why are some people open-minded enough to ship Huli although Hugh Laurie is married or to ship couples that haven't actually happened on the show but are too close-minded to have Cameron on the spot banner?
Rant over.
she is my fav character, and i agree with Cami, people who don't want her in the banner is only cz they don't like her :/
The thing about opening credits is something different since these are the season 7 opening credits and Jennifer Morrison isn't a regular season 7 cast member.
That someone would suggest having a reccuring character on the banner that has only appeared in a handful of episodes instead of a regular character of 6 years seems rather obscure to me.
Okay, I made my point 8)
I love to see cameron@the banner.I not love her,i not hate her i just dislike her but i understand what JMo do for the show and what the show do for her.I not understand the fans.But on other side...She is not anymore@the show.I'm not talking for the openning theme.Please god everyone is talking for that big deal and when they upload a house episode from the net who watches the theme?Who?Yeah nobody.The opening theme was the same but in s5 i think was having Kutner.As JMo say she not contacted for any house ep.She is not in this season...so far.Have any sense to put her in the banner...i don't know.I want her.I want chameron but just think have sense.Not think for the past or for the future.I mean exactly now...I not know.I thin i will cry.All season Huddy,Wilson will be with sam...The show is not the same...Have a sense to watch it...Everyone have their option and in the end the pick will say what we must do.
1) Need to first of all say that I have never been in favour of the banner reflecting the most current season. I personally think that that is unnecessary and ignores the history of the show, and opens us up to debates like this current one about who should feature on the spot banners.
2) The argument that Cameron is no longer in the show is the exact same argument that was used against Kutner fans when we wanted him to remain in the banner. Therefore, that is the argument that should win out here. Cameron is no longer in the show permanently, therefore she has no right to be in the banner.
I, of course, think that is silly. I thought that was a silly argument for not putting Kutner in the banner. I protested that, along with other Kutner fans, yet we lost that argument simply because he wasn't on the show anymore.
BUT in fairness to all fandoms, Cameron cannot be allowed to be in the banner. Cameron and Kutner were BOTH important characters on the show for different reasons, so the "importantance" of the characters is irrelevant can't be used to decide this issue. The only way we can resolve this issue is having clean-cut criteria for who is in and who is out of a cast banner.
When it came time to make the last banner, it was decided that due to Kutner being killed off, he should no longer feature in the banner. Thus, now that Cameron has left (almost) permanently, she should no longer feature in the spot banner. All fandoms need to treated (roughly) equally, and it would be phenomenally disrespectful to the Kutner fans who wanted him in the banner last time to then let Cameron fans have their way by having her in the banner despite her being out of the show this time around.
So, I am in favour of now only including House in the banner, because, while it sucks that we can't honour all the characters/cast, it makes these kinds of arguments redundant.
I'm not gonna comment about all the Cameron issue, it's breaking my heart. I just don't want new banner or icon, I think they're fine.
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment