I recently found a strange contradiction in the concept of wizarding money.I'd like to know if my idea is true or if there is a counter-argument against it.
In pg.65 of HP and the Chamber of Secrets,we learn that Muggle money can be exchanged into wizarding money.
We also know that potentially valuable(in a Muggle point of view) objects such as chairs can be Conjured by magic(eg:Dumbledore does this in the courtroom in HP and The Order of the Phoenix).
So any wizard who knows basic Transfiguration can Conjure objects such as chairs,sell them to Muggles to obtain Muggle money and then exchange this money into Galleons,thus obtaining an infinite amount of wealth.
Doesn't this contradict the whole point of wizarding money?
Thanks in advance for any help.
In pg.65 of HP and the Chamber of Secrets,we learn that Muggle money can be exchanged into wizarding money.
We also know that potentially valuable(in a Muggle point of view) objects such as chairs can be Conjured by magic(eg:Dumbledore does this in the courtroom in HP and The Order of the Phoenix).
So any wizard who knows basic Transfiguration can Conjure objects such as chairs,sell them to Muggles to obtain Muggle money and then exchange this money into Galleons,thus obtaining an infinite amount of wealth.
Doesn't this contradict the whole point of wizarding money?
Thanks in advance for any help.
I thought of all these myself, so don't go saying I copied off of you!
In The Store
#1: Hum Hedwig's Theme or the Sorting Hat's song very loudly, and maybe throw in some spins
#2: Point your wand at everyone you see and mutter spells
#3:Ask the manager if house elves do the cleaning, and if it's dirty, tell him or her that they should get clothes
#4: Ask at a mall cafeteria if they have pumpkin juice
#5: Look for licorice wands at local candy stores
#6: Attempt to withdraw galleons from the bank
#7: Ask if any local stables have hippogriffs or threstrals
At School
#1: Ask you teacher when Potions class starts
#2: Ask lunch ladies for cauldron cakes
If any of you have anything to add, please do so i comments.
In The Store
#1: Hum Hedwig's Theme or the Sorting Hat's song very loudly, and maybe throw in some spins
#2: Point your wand at everyone you see and mutter spells
#3:Ask the manager if house elves do the cleaning, and if it's dirty, tell him or her that they should get clothes
#4: Ask at a mall cafeteria if they have pumpkin juice
#5: Look for licorice wands at local candy stores
#6: Attempt to withdraw galleons from the bank
#7: Ask if any local stables have hippogriffs or threstrals
At School
#1: Ask you teacher when Potions class starts
#2: Ask lunch ladies for cauldron cakes
If any of you have anything to add, please do so i comments.
Hogwarts News 11/7/10
Dear all students,
Hogwarts has some very interesting news for you all.
Last night Professor Dumbledore and Professer
McGonagall decided to get engaged. They plan to have their wedding in about 2 weeks.
Ronald Bilius Weasley has lost his rat, Scabbers. He came back to his dormitory to find an empty cage. He is very worried.
Ms.Norris got lost a few days ago and now we found out that she had been donated to a charity in Africa.
Professor Snape has been sent to the wizard police for examination.
Thank you, Hogwarts School News
Dear all students,
Hogwarts has some very interesting news for you all.
Last night Professor Dumbledore and Professer
McGonagall decided to get engaged. They plan to have their wedding in about 2 weeks.
Ronald Bilius Weasley has lost his rat, Scabbers. He came back to his dormitory to find an empty cage. He is very worried.
Ms.Norris got lost a few days ago and now we found out that she had been donated to a charity in Africa.
Professor Snape has been sent to the wizard police for examination.
Thank you, Hogwarts School News
Harry woke with a start as Teddy’s cries pierced the small room. He groggily climbed out of the warm bed and stumbled over to the bassinet by the window. In the moonlight he could see that Teddy’s hair was bright pink. Chuckling to himself, he lifted the baby out of the crib and started over to the rocking chair.
He fed Teddy some warm milk.He stopped crying. Harry smiled,and Teddy smiled back.Harry put him back in the crib.Instantly Teddy fell asleep.
He fed Teddy some warm milk.He stopped crying. Harry smiled,and Teddy smiled back.Harry put him back in the crib.Instantly Teddy fell asleep.