answer this question

Harry Potter Question

Do you think Snape ever had a relationship with anyone?

We all know that Snape loved Lily but do you think he ever had "relations" with anyone else or do you think he died a virgin?

Sorry if this question sounds quite crass...
 yermam posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

lilith84 said:
I don't think he ever had any meaningfull relationship, but he definitely was no virgin. A man like Snape, who basically radiates sensuality and power was definitely not a virgin :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
he was too
EmoSixx posted over a year ago
*
XD
Vixie79 posted over a year ago
*
I read one 'Virgin Snape' fanfic one time that I actually believed.....I just remember they were fixing to get involved and he told her something along the lines of "I may be a virgin, but I am not inexperienced" and then preceded to show what he meant.......One day I will find that story again. LOL Can't remember the rest of it, but DEFINITELY remember that chapter....LOL
karenmiller1972 posted over a year ago
TaladarkieJJ said:
A real relationship? No, I don't think he was that kind of man and he was too focused on Lily to even try something with another woman.

But a virgin too? It could be. Ofcourse we don't know for sure. He was still a man.. So I assume he also had desires, so maybe occasionally he just had sex to fulfil his wants and needs. Nothing serious. No ties. Plain and simple.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I definitely think he had casual sex sometimes. All that pressure in his life, he'd have exploded if he also added sexual frustration to it :)
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
Right. All work and no play? He had to have some relief. :)
TaladarkieJJ posted over a year ago
*
exactly ;)
lilith84 posted over a year ago
bri-marie said:
I don't think he ever had a long-term, romantic relationship with anyone. I don't think he ever could have, after everything with Lily.

As for dieing a virgin? Sex and love don't always mix together (one night stands, anyone?). I don't think Severus never touched a woman in a sexual way, either before Lily died or after. He was, after all, only a human with human needs.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LadyNottingham said:
I don't think the question is "crass". I'm playing with that notion of his being a virgin actually in a fanfic I'm writing (and maybe how he's going to lose it).

Though I totally agree that love and sex are 2 different things - especially for a man. One night stands do exist, he was a Death-Eater, maybe he was compelled to have sex with Death-Eater victims, etc. (I also played with that notion in another fanfic of mine.)

I read a paper about "late virginity" : it can be due to several causes, men and women alike. The paper gives several reasons but I identified 3 of them that could correspond to our Severus :

- they have witnessed/sustained unhappy sexual experiences. They are traumatized. Maybe Severus have seen collective rapes when he was a young Death-Eater and it disgusted him from sex ;

- a deep, sublimated love that prevented the person to move on in another relationship - these poeple are in general unable to cope with a disappointed/unfulfilled first love. They are mourning an idealized image of that love. Looks like our Severus here ;

- an absent or intrusive mother, which led them to feel rejected, ugly, unwanted, they generally feel ill-at-ease in their lives. Could be our Severus here too, his mother being abused by his father (to what extent ?), he had also been neglected by his mother, she seemed to have been particularly missing at some point.

Of course, the above relating to Severus' case is sheer speculation from my part. However, it does fuel my thinking about that fanfic I'm writing...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Intelligently written and explained though I think rape would be a rarity in the wizarding world
TangoThang posted over a year ago
*
Maybe in the wizarding world as they seem to have achieved more gender equality than in the Muggle world. But not among Death-Eaters. Rape is still a way to put pressure on people, a way to frighten them and punish them too, a way to reward the warriors too. Nothing new under the sun, alas.
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
*
Thanks for your kind words btw !
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
BellaLovett said:
i think he didn't have a relationship with anyone..i'm pretty sure of this..
yes he died a virgin..duh
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
EmoSixx said:
no way
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
TheSilverDoe said:
I think the fact that his patronous remained a Doe until the day he died, illustrates that his love never died for Lily. If his feelings for her had subsided, he may not have continued to protect Harry for her until the very end. So this suggests that he didn't have a relationship with anyone else. To be honest, he was so torn up with regret, anger, self-hatred and pain over losing Lily I expect he closed himself off from loving another woman again. This would also suggest that he remained a virgin....which is also a damn loss to all women lol If he did 'get with' other women they would soon have tired of him because none would ever be as good as 'Lily'.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
why do everyone mix love and sex? those are completely different things. He was a Death Eater! By choice! I'm pretty sure he had no problems just f*cking some random women in his younger years.
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
I think the question was whether or not he had a relationship after Lily which usually involves love ;) However, u make a good point on the 'casual sex' thing, especially since his anger and regret over losing Lily led him down a dark path, I'm sure he had some rumpy pumpy back then; Lily was off with James so why shouldn't he have some 'fun'? Which could mean that he didn't die a virgin after all.....Huzzar!!
TheSilverDoe posted over a year ago
*
oh trust me my friend, me too ;) without second thought :D
lilith84 posted over a year ago
Vixie79 said:
I don't think he did. But if he did, he should have looked me up.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Simply_Indigo said:
This is just my opinion, but after Lily left him I can't imagine him ever being interested in anyone else...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
miketoff said:
yah...i think snape is bad because harry potter is his crush..for my own opinion only.....
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
donnafajardo said:
i don't think so..cause all he ever wanted was lily..
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
frostdragon2010 said:
I believe he may have had uncommitted with the bar keeper in hogsmead as many others had. The story made references to Rose Merta and her friendly open door policy and how everyone wanted her. To me I took it that she warmed many a mens beds and was many young wizards first. lol
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
haha XD
yermam posted over a year ago
BestNameEver123 said:
i'm pretty sure he never loved anyone else, but i don't think he died a virgin. he was a death eater for the years after he left school and i believe he would most definitely have sex in that time. he was a man and most men do not live to the age of 38 being a virgin even if they did have an undying love for someone else...but that's just my opinion just as some people believe he died a virgin, if he did die a virgin can i say that would be a waste ;)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
simpleplan said:
No idea if he ever did but I know he cant now he kind of dead
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
superwalrus said:
All clues suggest he never loved anyone else, but I don't think he died a virgin. I can't imagine him doing it with someone, for all the love he had for Lily. It is possible though that in their younger years that Severus and Lily had sex one summer night ?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »