answer this question

Harry Potter Question

something Lupin says in Prisoner of Azkaban movie...

He tells Harry about his mother Lily and how she was 'there for me at a time when no one else was'. Its something thats always puzzled me. Could he have confided in her about his 'little problem' before telling his friends about it or is he alluding to something else? I don't recall him saying anything like this in the book and just wondered what everyone else thought about it. thanks.
 yermam posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

JAlanaE said:
I don't think this quote is based on the books in any way. According to the books I don't think Lupin and Lily knew each other THAT well. Probably they just put this into the movie because it makes the scene more emotional or something like that.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Vixie79 said:
I believe it was about that yes. I always pictured Lily the kind of person that was really easy to talk to and someone that could keep a secret well. Also, someone that was never judgmental as well. I never really saw her as nosy, maybe curious. But yeah, That's why I think Lupin trusted her with it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bessmarvin1 said:
Maybe Lily knew about Lupin being a werewolf along with the other Marauders,u know,she's very nosy.Maybe that's why he told like that about her
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
emilykuru said:
'there for me at a time when no one was;

this is probably becuz he had told his secret to lily as she is a trustable person standing up for truth.

orelse,_at a time where no one else was- HE COULD BE REFFERING TO THE TIME WHEN WEREWOLVES WERE ABHORRED BY THE MINSITRY.Lupin mentions this to harry on his 17 bday saying he has to leave with tonks when the minister was coming.

nothing else makes sense for waht he said.

do u like this????
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »