Harry Potter Vs. Twilight

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Book elimination (for both Twilight and HP fans)

PotterForever posted on Oct 06, 2010 at 06:19PM
Simmilar to the character elimination forum, this one works in the same way. All HP and Twilight books are listed. Each starts out with 20 points. Remove a point from your least favorite, and add it to your favorite. The last one standing is the winner.

Sorceror's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisoner of Azkaban - 20
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 20
Twilight - 20
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 20

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight 90 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 90

over a year ago boolander25 said…
+ Chamber of Secrets
- Twilight


Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 20
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 20
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 20
over a year ago harrypotterbest said…
+ DH
- BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 20
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 21
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 19
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
+ PoA

- BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 21
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 18
over a year ago nati30 said…
+Deathly Hallows
-Breaking Dawn

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 20
Deathly Hallows - 22
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 20
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 17
over a year ago Angel-Trix said…
+Half Blood Prince
-New Moon (We get it Bitch, THERE'S A FUCKING HOLE IN YOUR CHEST! SHUT UP ABOUT IT ALREADY!)

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 21
Deathly Hallows - 22
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 19
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 17
over a year ago harrypotterbest said…
-BD
+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 21
Deathly Hallows - 23
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 19
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 16
over a year ago PotterForever said…
-BD
+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 21
Deathly Hallows - 24
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 19
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 15
over a year ago harrypotterbest said…
-BD
+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 21
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 21
Deathly Hallows - 25
Twilight - 19
New Moon - 19
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 14
over a year ago KishuandIchigo said…
- Twilight
+ POA
Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 22
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 21
Deathly Hallows - 25
Twilight - 18
New Moon - 19
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 14
over a year ago Angel-Trix said…
- New Moon
+ Half Blood Prince
(See, even the title of the HP books are better!)
Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 22
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 22
Deathly Hallows - 25
Twilight - 18
New Moon - 18
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 14
over a year ago HecateA said…
smile
-BD
+ Deathly Hallows

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 22
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 22
Deathly Hallows - 26
Twilight - 18
New Moon - 18
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 13
over a year ago IzzyOzera said…
smile
- New Moon
+ Half Blood Prince

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 22
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 26
Twilight - 18
New Moon - 17
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 13
over a year ago HaleyDewit said…
big smile
- Twilight
+ Deathly Hallows

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisoner of Azkaban - 22
Goblet of Fire - 20
Order of the Pheonix - 20
Half Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 27
Twilight - 17
New Moon - 17
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 13
over a year ago Herm-o-ninny said…
-New moon
+ Order of the phoenix

Sorcerer's Stone- 20
Chamber of Secrets- 21
Prisoner of Azkaban- 22
Goblet of Fire- 20
Order of the Phoenix- 21
Half Blood Prince- 23
Deathly Hallows- 27
Twilight- 17
New Moon- 16
Eclipse- 20
Breaking Dawn- 13

*how many times can we do this? is it just the once or as many times as we like?
over a year ago Ultimately57 said…
big smile
-Breeding Spawn
+ Deathly Hallows


Sorcerer's Stone- 20
Chamber of Secrets- 21
Prisoner of Azkaban- 22
Goblet of Fire- 20
Order of the Phoenix- 21
Half Blood Prince- 23
Deathly Hallows- 27
Twilight- 17
New Moon- 16
Eclipse- 20
Breaking Dawn- 13

I'm slowly watching Breeding Spawn going down. Can we go into the minuss?
over a year ago Ms_Mea said…
+PoA
-Twilight

Sorcerer's Stone- 20
Chamber of Secrets- 21
Prisoner of Azkaban- 23
Goblet of Fire- 20
Order of the Phoenix- 21
Half Blood Prince- 23
Deathly Hallows- 27
Twilight- 16
New Moon- 16
Eclipse- 20
Breaking Dawn- 13
over a year ago DracoLuver said…
+GoF
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 21
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 27
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 15
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 13
over a year ago KishuandIchigo said…
+ Goblet of Fire
- BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 22
Order of the Phoenix - 21
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 27
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 15
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 12
over a year ago NymphadoraXD said…
+DH
-BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 21
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 22
Order of the Phoenix - 21
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 28
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 15
Eclipse - 20
Breaking Dawn - 11
over a year ago cassie-1-2-3 said…
-CoS
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 22
Order of the Phoenix - 21
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 28
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 15
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 11
over a year ago emilyroxx said…
+ OOTP
- New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 22
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 28
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 11
over a year ago cassie-1-2-3 said…
-GoF
+BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 28
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 12
over a year ago SerialFangirl said…
+ DH
- BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 29
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 11
over a year ago Italktosnakes said…
smile
+DH
-BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 30
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 10
over a year ago Italktosnakes said…
smile
Cand I just point out that Cassie-1-2-3 voted twice. DI don't want to be THAT person, but it defeats the object. I'm just saying :) x
over a year ago AvatarPerkins said…
-BD

+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 20
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 31
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 21
Breaking Dawn - 9
over a year ago cassie-1-2-3 said…
-CoS
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 19
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 31
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 22
Breaking Dawn - 9
over a year ago justliveitlive said…
-BD
+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 19
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 32
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 22
Breaking Dawn - 8
over a year ago PotterForever said…
-BD
+DH

Sorcerer's Stone - 20
Chamber of Secrets - 19
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 33
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 22
Breaking Dawn - 7
over a year ago Love4Hermione said…
SS+1
BD-1

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 19
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 33
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 22
Breaking Dawn - 6
over a year ago cassie-1-2-3 said…
(Just noticed Italktosnakes' post. It's safe to say that harrypotterbest voted three times and Angel-Trix voted twice BEFORE I even went once, so I don't think it makes any difference)
With that said:

-CoS
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 18
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 33
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 23
Breaking Dawn - 6
over a year ago youknowit101 said…
^LMAO

-CoS
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 23
Deathly Hallows - 33
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 6
over a year ago Italktosnakes said…
smile
(Just noticed Cassie's post- I never said that nobody else didn't. I just noticed yours, because yours was the one just above mine at teh time of writing it. I'm still gonna stand my ground though, it does TOTALLY defeat the purpose of the book elimination-and that goes for the people that I like as well. I might as well just take away 10 points from Breaking Dawn and add 10 points to Deathly Hallows, if I'm gonna go ten times anyway) x

over a year ago xDark_Angelx said…
+ Half Blood Prince
- Breaking Dawn

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Godblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 33
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 5
over a year ago Quaila said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Breaking Dawn

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 22
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 34
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 4
over a year ago NymphadoraXD said…
+OotP
-BD

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 23
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 34
Twilight - 16
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 3
over a year ago merlinsbeard said…
+OOTP
-Twilight

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 34
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 3
over a year ago duncylovescourt said…
+ deathyl hallows
- breaknig dawn
Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 35
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 24
Breaking Dawn - 2
over a year ago Ms_Mea said…
Haha Breaking Dawn only has 2 left :P
over a year ago youknowit101 said…
-Cos
+Eclipse

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 35
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 25
Breaking Dawn - 2
over a year ago LoopyLuna96 said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Breaking Dawn

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisonor of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 36
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 25
Breaking Dawn - 1
over a year ago BellaCullen96 said…
+ Deathly Hallows
- Breaking Dawn

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 37
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 14
Eclipse - 25
Breaking Dawn - 0

I've eliminated Breaking Dawn! I feel proud XD
over a year ago PotterForever said…
+Deathly Hallows
-New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 24
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 38
Twilight - 15
New Moon - 13
Eclipse - 25
Breaking Dawn's gone.
over a year ago emilyroxx said…
+OOTP
-Twilight

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Azkaban - 23
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 38
Twilight - 14
New Moon - 13
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago SpeedyGonzalez said…
+ POA
- New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 38
Twilight - 14
New Moon - 12
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
+ COS
- New Moon

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 38
Twilight - 14
New Moon - 11
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago mina_sit said…
smile
+ Deathly Hallows
- Twilight

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 39
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 11
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago KatiiCullen94 said…
+New Moon
-COS
Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 39
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 12
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
+CoS
-NM

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 17
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 39
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 11
Eclipse - 25
over a year ago KatiiCullen94 said…
-CoS
+NM

Sorcerer's Stone - 21
Chamber of Secrets - 16
Prisoner of Askaban - 24
Goblet of Fire - 21
Order of the Phoenix - 25
Half-Blood Prince - 24
Deathly Hallows - 39
Twilight - 13
New Moon - 12
Eclipse - 25
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!