Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Article: HP vs TWILIGHT(??)

7

posted by roobiip

My question is Is anyone alse tired of this "HP vs Twilight" things??
Because it is driving me crazy..

First of all I need to say I LOVE THEM BOTH so much!! I think HP was extremely original I grew up with it and I looove it.. and Twilight is so romantic, I mean, could they be more crazy about each other?? (NOPE!!), and I looove it too!! (L) =]

However one thing is true:
Most twilight fans ARE crazy, annoying, funny, scary, etc.. being one I talked to many and some were really funny (they actually believed they were going to marry Edward) and others really scared me (because I loved HP too they told me I should burn my Twilight books and couldn't say I was a Twilight fan anymore) XD

BUT it doesn't mean we are all crazy, or stupid.. some of us are more critical and realize Twilight is not the best book ever, and SM is not the best writer ever, and Edward Cullen isn't real LOL X)

Oh and yeah, I know SM's writing is simple, but JKR's is not that different.. they're both easy to read ADMIT IT (they were written so kids and teens could read it!!!).. they're quite simple but if you are smart enough to read "between the lines" you'll see they both deal with "grown up" issues..

WHAT I WANT TO SAY IS THAT THIS IS REALLY STUPID.. ONE STORY IS ABOUT MAGICIANS AND FANTASY, AND THE OTHER ABOUT VAMPIRES AND FANTASY.. ONE IS ABOUT LOYALTY, FAMILY AND FRIENDSHIP, AND THE OTHER ABOUT LOVE, FRIENDS CAUGHT IN A LOVE TRIANGLE AND FAMILY..

SO PLEASE STOP THIS.. THEY'RE DIFFERENT!!!!!!
I LOVE THEM BOTH AND I'M REALLY TIRED OF CHOOSING THINGS FOR ONE SIDE THEN FOR THE OTHER JUST BECAUSE ONE OF THE FANS INSULTED ONE BOOK..

this is crazy that's all.. they both have amaizing things and they both have not so good things.. for example:
-VAMPIRES DON'T SPARKLE!! X)

I hated that.. but also:
-WAS IT NESSESARY TO KILL SO MANY CHARACTERS IN HP?? X)

I mean it! it was STUPID killing so many charactes WE ALL LOVED SO MUCH! X(

and well, many other things that made no sense in both books.. but THEY ARE BOTH SO AMAIZING, I LOVE THEM SO MUCH THAT I DON'T EVEN CARE!!
YEES, VAMPIRES *SPARKLE* IN THE SUN SO WHAAT?? AND YEES, EVERYONE DIES SO WHAAT??

THEY ARE SOME OF THE BEST STORIES EVEEER AND I LOVE THEM!!

[Is anyone else tired of this "HP vs Twilight" thingg?????]

Harrypotter148, lallawmkima and 5 others like this

EmilyWeasley God, I completly agree with you. It's annoying that people think we should take sides!! Some people think it's the same thing (which is not!!) and the others think it's totally different so we should just like one of them. How stupid is that?? I love Bella and Alice and I Love Hermione and Tonks, OK?!

burgundyeyes You're right that comparing those two books is useless. but, i assure you that this "war" will not end. perhaps the "old" fans will realise it and stop. but there will always be new fans for both series and they will continue on the "battle". you said that one of the not so good thing about hp is that J.K killed too many characters. well, it's reality. it's time of war. and war isn't a little game. people die, it was to be expected. in normal wars (non magical ones), humans die. yes, we are sad. but, that's the way it is. (i'm not saying that war is good, though)

mickis14 Yeah I´m tired I mean I don´t like HP but if the don´t bother us I respect them :D

Bookaholics Actually, I think it's fun to have friendly debates and little arguments. But I agree the "war" has gone to far.

Costume check

added by youknowit101

7

The Twilight Saga: The Plot Holes That Never Were

posted by cassie-1-2-3

I’ve read many lists pointing out Twilight “Plot Holes”, but more often than not, the lists aren’t very valid at all. Half of them are usually just complaints, pointing out something they don’t like about Twilight (Example:” Why would vampires go to high school?”, or “Why does Bella have so many friends?”). The rest are just factually incorrect, or can be logically theorized. These are usually followed by “Stephenie Meyer obviously ditched history class”, or “Hasn’t Stephenie ever heard of logic?”, or my personal favorite, “I would know, I had a lesson about it...

6

Why I Agree With Rosalie Cullen

posted by PotterLambert93

As you can tell, I do not like Twilight. However, there is one character in the "saga" that I definatley agree with. That person happens to be... Rosalie.

Sure Rosalie is a Bitch most of the time, but when you watch her in "Eclipse" [my sister made me watch all the movies] you actually discover why she acts like that, especially towards Bella, and to be honest, I can't really blame her. In fact, I actually felt bad for her, and heres why:

In "Eclipse" Rosalie explains to Bella about what it's like to be a vampire, and the consequences. Rosalie was once a human in the 1930's era who had so many...

2

Bella, and the Dangers she Shows to a Peaceful Pureblood Society

posted by Confuzzle

So we all know who Bella is, complete muggle and interfering with the magical world. The Department of International Magical Cooperation and the Department of Magic Reversal are overlooking claims, as shown on that post on My Life Is Twilight. I know this has been covered a lot, but I'm going to go in a bit further on what makes Muggles like her so much.

In several articles, Bella was described as an empty shell, meaning any girl can relate to her. This fits, because we know that she's only described as clumsy. Well, so are hundreds of millions of people in the world...so they could fit into...

Lily Potter 3

added by HoltNLucy4Ever

Alice 3

added by HoltNLucy4Ever

1

BURRNNN

added by courtney_horan1

Can You Abuse The Willing?

added by RonGetYourWand

Not mine! Belongs to MelinaPendulum.

video

twilight

fan video

debate

3

{ Unwritten ~ Alice Cullen Tribute }

added by KatiiCullen94

video

Breaking Dawn and Deathly Hallows

added by bddh

Source: tumblr

Breaking Dawn and Deathly Hallows

added by bddh

Source: tumblr

1

What Twilight Should Be Like, Part One

posted by siriuslyawesome

I like Twilight. I used to love Twilight. But then, I began to feel disappointed. I wanted Bella to have DONE something that actually could affect the entire WORLD. Suddenly, I created my own versions of Edward and Bella and the Volturi. I like Twilight as it is....but it would be much better like this.
-1-
Bella Swan tugged on her muddy brown ponytail to keep in in place as thundered roared and rain came down in buckets on the deserted island. The forest, slick with slime and muck, was dangerous enough without HIM lurking in the shadows. Her ears picked up a soft sound beneath the gale. He...