Some old posts I made regarding this topic;
No compitition what so ever. Bellatrix is the crucio master, she can deflect spells cast by Dumbledore. Shes an occlumer and has beat Harry before. Not to mention she'd take enjoyment in crucioing Jane to death.
Bellatrix's mind is already to scrwed up to do any more damage to it, and I think saying crucio is alot fasterf then crippling someone's mind.
The people Im complaining about are the ones who didnt respond on the other picks, just brows through them and you'll see what I mean. 1 or 2 might have commented but thats it.
She has done non verbal spells, she killed a fox with out casting a spell, and I dont quit rember if she used the wand or not.
Both. In physical terms she was starved and rotting in prison. Mental terms she was surronded by dementors which sucked out all her happy memories and any speck of happiness or hope she had. Not to mention just being in a dark cold prison for 15 years with no contact with any other human caused her a great deal of mental damage. Jane's spells wouldn't do much more damage.
The whole debate is here;
link