make a top for singing and dancing ? not based on fav

singing
1-Taeyeon
2-Tiffany
3-Seohyun

dancing
1-Hyoyeon/Sooyoung
2-Yuri
3-Yoona

the top three singer and dancers for me are the ones who have shown the most progress or improvement.

1.Taeyeon- she did an awesome job in Twinkle, although I have mixed feeling about her voice in regard to improvement, I still think she is a top singer

2.Seohyun- She showed she could sing and hold her own when it mattered, esp in Twinkle and Jack

3.Sunny- I have to put Sunny here because no one else blew my mind away with their voice then her in her musical. For someone who is known for singing very cute, we now can see her truley powerful voice and acting put to the test.

1.Hyoyeon- her doing dancing with the stars, really showed she can do a variety of dancing not just "poppin and locking", she is now the dancing Queen of SNSD. She can dance smooth, fast, hard, I don't think anyone can top her now.

2.Yoona- She is still consistent but she showed she can dance sexy during her "4 minutes" performance so I give her credit for that

3.Sooyoung- I don't know why I added her, not much improvement but like Yoona I can give her credit for being about to dance smooth and sexy in her solo performance


WHY NOT..
Jessica- well Jessica really hasn't shown me anything new about her, her tone and voice hasn't really changed even in Paparazzi, and her solo performance in "Almost" was beautiful but nothing "new"

Tiffany- again I found nothing new with her voice as of late, even in Twinkle she really didn't do anything difficult like Seohyun or Taeyeon did like holding high notes, so I can't give her that much credit. I liked her OST for Yoona's drama but it didnt blow me away as much as the others

Yuri- well Yuri hasn't impressed me with dances for a while now.

Hear me out on this Taeyeon, Jessica, Hyoyeon, and Yuri are the hardest people to impress me because they are best singers or dancer in SNSD. I get very bored of them because they tend to make the least improvement, I guess because their the best anyway.

Well ranks are changing look what happened to the underrated Seohyun and Sooyoung, they went up higher on dancing or singing, and I suspect new year will be a even bigger shocker

I chose this clip because this is what started me getting into Sunny when she dances, when she is "feeling" the song and stage she is actually good

singing
1.Taeyeon
2.Jessica(guys! Jessica can sing ok? she can hit any high notes that taeyeon can but not as loud as taeyeon remember she can sing that is why she is 2 main vocal)
3.Seohyun

Dancing
1.Yuri/hyoyeon
2.sooyoung
3.Yoona

in my opinion:
*singing
1.taeyeon
2.jessica
3.seohyun

*dancing
1.hyoyeon
2.sooyoung
3.yuri

*my opinion only, so peace *_*..

Top 3 in singing:

1) Taeyeon - i think everyone will have to agree with this. she is definitely one of the best singer. she can sings in any genre she likes and she puts lots of emotion in every songs
2) Jessica - well, i know most people dont like her nasal tone/voice but i love it :) i fell in love with her voice since i heard the song titled 'One Year Later' duet with Onew. she is just amazing.
3) Seohyun - her voice got a lot better after The Boys. she can compete with the main vocals. she is very good in harmonizing.
her voice when singing ballad song is smooth and soft. i very like it

Top 3 in Dancing ^_^
1) Yuri
2) Hyoyeon - she is the main dancer, but idk for some reasons, i dont like it so much. dont know why. it feels like lacking something.
3) Yoona - her dancing is sharp.

From my point of view towards the members on singing and dancing :

Singing -
Taeyeon (She sings so amazing in about every song Snsd sings^^)
Tiffany (Because its you and Rolling in the deep. For me,i love her tone of voice,i think its so pretty~)
Jessica (When you wish upon a star was one of my favorite songs of her singing solo.)

Dacning -
Hyoyeon (Her dancing skills are great)
Yuri (2nd on dancing the best right after Hyoyeon for me^^)
Yoona (4 Minutes and when she danced at SMtown live in NY was really good)

singing
tae she just amazing
fany
seo the reason that make her in top 3 her slow song in fashion king wow
dancing
yuri
hyo
soo

1. Taeyeon: Her voice is beautiful and also strong. Definitely the best singer.
2. Seohyun: She's improved so much and she has a nice range too.
3. Jessica: Nice voice but it sounds thin live.
4. Tiffany: She has a beautiful tone but isn't strong live.

1. Hyoyeon: She can do a variety of dances and she is confident and skilled. Her only problem is that she can be to agressive.
2. Yuri: She's still second IMO but at this rate she may be moved down.
3. Yoona: She rarely makes mistakes and is controlled and sharp.
4. Sooyoung: Graceful.

I think Seohyun's fifth in dancing, but she's not as good as the top four yet. Still, she's probably the most talented of them all.

Singing:
1. Taeyeon
2. Tiffany/Seohyun
3. Jessica

Dancing:
1. Hyoyeon
2. Yuri
3. Yoona/Sooyoung