Nope, Earthland Erza is stronger because she has the power of feelings. The power of feelings is the equivalent of having a Sharingan in Naruto. If you have it, you can overcome any opponent and winning is almost a given.
I think someone created a poll on this, Anyways Earthland Erza is just that bit stronger, if u talk about right now, Erza is wayyy stronger now, since she has improved and Knightwalker has lost her magic, but if u meant at the Edolas arc, then they seemed to be evenly matched, but this IMO opinion was because Titania Scarlett was fighting to match Knightwalker, she has more armour and could have made the fight go at her pace and not Knightwalker's . So based on that i think Titania Scarlett is stronger but not by too much. But worst case scenario, they are equal.
posted over a year ago
I did not know that someone created a poll on this..............and yes, i meant at the Edolas Arc.