Fairy Tail

answer this question

Fairy Tail Question

Gray or Natsu, who is STRONGER???

Okay so i decided to put these into some stats for you, to put my point forward:
Physical offence: Natsu= 6/10. Gray= 5/10
Magical offence: Natsu= 7/10. Gray= 6/10
Physical defence: Natsu= 6/10. Gray= 6/10
Magical defence: Natsu= 3/10. Gray= 6/10
Speed: Natsu= 6/10. Gray= 6/10
Intelligence: Natsu= 3/10. Gray= 4/10
Mastery of Magic: Natsu= 7/10. Gray= 8/10
Magical power: Natsu= 7/10. Gray= 7/10
Destructive capacity: Natsu= 7/10. Gray= 4/10
Natsu TOTAL= 52/90. Gray TOTAL= 52/90

That's right i think they are equal. Some people may not like that some of the stats are low but i did these with the idea that Zeref or Acnologia are 10 in any stat (Zeref+Acnologia are 90/90). So you could say i was being rather lenient in some of the stats and both Gray and Natsu got lucky. Honestly i like Gray better but know that i threw all favouritism to the side to do this. One more thing, Natsu's mastery of magic could have been higher but i say it can only reach 8 or 9 when he can eat other elements freely and it can only reach 10 when he can go in and out of Dragon Force at will like Sting and Rogue.
 reefa2931 posted over a year ago
next question »

Fairy Tail Answers

T_ballack said:
Nice, putting up stats, but i'd rather not do this, because if i did this with respect to acnologia being a perfect ten, then they rating would be so low that i might get killed on here. I feel both of them where at least equal pre-timeskip, and that gray would win in a fight because he is much more intelligent, that said natsu does have Battle intuition which helps him. I still think i need to see more comparable feats from both of them to know their levels post time-skip. But i'd still think they are about equal. Anyways why my rating would be much lower is because, for instance, your rating suggest, Gray+Natsu would be stronger than acnologia, or if erza is added to the mix the they beat acnologia. Oh and here is a thought, i think you should add Speed and speed of magic execution, like for example natsu needs prep for his roar, laxus doesn't something like that, gray's ice is instantaneous laki's wood isn't. Maybe Durability too. Anyways i'd say they are equal until proven otherwise via post time-skip performance, and lets hope i don't get killed
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Miva4ever said:
Well it depends
They use different types of magic, and the powers can be stronger sometimes and weaker sometimes.
And you all know that when something happen to the important person by the characters side, then the character grows in power...
That is my calculation anyway.
I do like the both and i think they a awesome in their own ways :) tho if they fight each other then, sadly i think that Natsu will be stronger... Fire wins over ice..
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
lol, tell that to fukuro and rufus.
T_ballack posted over a year ago
*
Well I did say that it was my opinion -.-
Miva4ever posted over a year ago
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
Fire can melt ice as well as ice can freeze one's flames. Which is why Gray should get more credit than what he gets.
2xWolf posted over a year ago
starprincess7 said:
We can't really say as to who is stronger because their magic is opposite : fire and ice. Both have similar attitudes against each other. But they both fight for their friends, and saying that most of FT member's powers come from friend/nakama power, we can safely say that they are both equally powerful. Natsu does have a higher temper though, which makes him show his power more and Gray isn't that high tempered so he doesn't show his power much. Maybe that's why it looks as if Natsu is more powerful than him while they both are equal. But, who knows ??? I hope you like my answer !!! :)
 select as best answer
We can't really say as to who is stronger because their magic is opposite : fire and ice. Both have similar attitudes against each other. But they both fight for their friends, and saying that most of FT member's powers come from friend/nakama power, we can safely say that they are both equally powerful. Natsu does have a higher temper though, which makes him show his power more and Gray isn't that high tempered so he doesn't show his power much. Maybe that's why it looks as if Natsu is more powerful than him while they both are equal. But, who knows ??? I hope you like my answer !!! :)
posted over a year ago 
fruitshake said:
Natsu's got more will than gray does. he and gray are equals when you put in that way but when it comes down to it, natsu's definitely stronger. I wanna see gray go all out like natsu has.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Lol, incase you hadn't payed attention......Gray has as much will as Natsu, just either seems like the type guy not to care, or doesn't know how to show it due to being cool headed.
2xWolf posted over a year ago
*
While on top of Natsu's will is being hot headed. Opposite of Gray. Who beat the Owl Merc? Not Natsu, Gray did. Gray had more will and heart in that fight. Who beat Leone with physical strength, and pure heart. Gray. Not Natsu. The show, and creators just doesn't give Gray the credit he deserves.
2xWolf posted over a year ago
*
That one knight that controls souls in toys, Wouldn't be able to beat Gray in fair fight. Cuz he had to run like coward to lead Gray into his buddy's trap in order to beat em. Like I said Show doesn't give Gray Credit He Deserves. Whether people like it or not Gray and Natsu are polar opposites. Therefor are equal. Gray can knock Natsu on his ass, as well as Natsu can knock Gray on his ass. Just because Natsu's power comes from a dragon, him being pure Dragon slayer magic doesn't make him stronger than gray.
2xWolf posted over a year ago
*
Lockus Proved That, As well as the Owl Merc. Nuff said.
2xWolf posted over a year ago
RHARGETT said:
I'd say Gray because he's more intelligent thanan Natsu and in another world it could be a tie because fire vs ice could be a devoluation.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
NatsuD said:
I'd say Gray because he is more intelligent than Natsu and in a different world it would be a tie because fire and ice are natural enemies
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
EthanDayton said:
Natsu because he beat up Deliora.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Bleeding_Rose said:
In a surface view I would say they are equal but if we delve deeper I could say Natsu is stronger or Gray, fist take into account their magic, Natsu possesses Dragon Slaying Magic wielding the element of fire and fire usually trumps ice which is the element Gray uses in his magic but then again Gray later in the series receives Demon Slayer Magic, and END a powerful demon and Zeref's attempt at resurrecting his little brother which just so happens to be Natsu meaning he's a demon. Now we have fire vs ice where fire is the obvious winner but then you have a demon with fire against someone who posses the power to slay them, so they're not as much equal as it would depend on the circumstances.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Avdesh said:
The grew stronger tick mark answer

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!