Disney Princess
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
Disney Princess Which Disney Princess did the Biggest Sarcrifice? Counted by comments, not percentages
41 fans picked: |
Mulan
|
|||
Ariel
|
|||
Belle
|
|||
Pocahontas
|
|||
Rapunzel
|
|||
Jasmine
|
|||
Tiana
|
|||
Snow White
|
|||
Cinderella
|
|||
Aurora
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
mulan went to war knowing she could die. that's basically giving her life to save someone else's.
Mulan and Ariel take risks, but they never take suicidal risks.
However, many of the things which Ariel "sacrifice" don't really count. Changing her species and losing her old life don't count, because she'd rather be a human living a human life--that's not a sacrifice, that's an upgrade. Giving up her home and family don't really count since moving out is a natural part of growing up. It's not a sacrifice to lose something you'd naturally lose anyway. Ariel doesn't really give up her friends. Certainly not Scuttle, and presumably not Flounder.
Really, that just leaves one main thing Ariel sacrifices--her voice. She also risks her soul, that's a risk that Ariel doesn't take seriously into consideration.
What Tiana sacrificed was her dream to buy the old sugar mill. That's the thing that was on a strict time limit, since the realtors had another buyer who they preferred and they said she'd have to offer more money to change their mind. (In the end, it looks like they were swayed by a scary alligator rather than more money.)
Now, it's not clear exactly whether or not Tiana was really giving up her dream. It's complicated. Tiana told Naveen she could reach her dream with a lot of money, but that's only because she thought he was a rich prince and that was a way to sway the realtors. On the other hand, Tiana probably knew that the realtors were prejudiced against her and they only gave money as a convenient excuse.
What I find interesting is the ambiguous relationship between Charlotte and Tiana. Clearly, Tiana either doesn't feel she can ask Charlotte directly for money, or doesn't want to. I think their relationship is complicated by their financial interaction.
I've been pondering writing a Charlotte-centric story about that. I speculate that Charlotte insisted on buying all those dresses mainly because that's how she got to spend time with her friend Tiana. I think Tiana's mother didn't mind taking advantage of that, to help support her family. If you think about it, that's got to complicate their friendship. Charlotte must wonder whether or not Tiana was ever truly her friend...
Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment