Aladdin: Old vs New

Favorite Aladdin: Original

Favorite Jasmine: Remake

Favorite Animal Sidekicks: Original

Favorite Genie: Original

Favorite Carpet: Original

Favorite Jafar: Original

Favorite Sultan: Original

Favorite Cave of Wonders: Original

Favorite Arabian Nights: Remake

Favorite One Jump Ahead: Remake

Favorite One Jump Ahead Reprise: Original

Favorite Friend Like Me: Original

Favorite Prince Ali: Remake

Favorite A Whole New World: Original

Favorite Jasmine's Reason to Go to the Marketplace: Original

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine meeting: Original

Favorite Cave of Wonders scene: Original

Favorite Genie Introduction: Original

Favorite I Wish to Be a Prince scene: Original

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine reunion: Original

Favorite Magic Carpet Ride: Original

Favorite Jafar's Hypnotism: Original

Favorite Jafar Taking Over Agrabah: Original

Favorite Banishment in Snow: Original

Favorite Battle With Jafar: Original

Favorite Jasmine Tricking Aladdin to reveal who he is: Original

Favorite Kiss: Original

Favorite almost drowning: Remake

Favorite Aladdin / Genie argument: Original (the remake seemed more like the Genie was just disappointed and not really in an argument, in my opinion)

Favorite version of lamp being stolen: Remake


Favorite Jasmine picking Aladdin: Original

Favorite Aladdin Remake

Favorite Jasmine Remake and original

Favorite Animal Sidekicks:

Rajah - Remake
Abu - Remake
Iago - Original

Favorite Genie Original and Remake

Favorite Carpet Remake

Favorite Jafar Original and Remake I like his back story in the remake and his costumes. Original Jafar was more menacing but I’m glad they took out the lust object scene between him and Jasmine. The remake is better in that regard. It might be because he’s too good looking compared to the original Jafar. It might also be an age thing. I don’t know.

Favorite Sultan Remake

Favorite Cave of Wonders Original

Favorite Arabian Nights Remake

Favorite One Jump Ahead Remake and Original

Favorite One Jump Ahead Reprise Original

Favorite Friend Like Me Remake

Favorite Prince Ali Remake

Favorite A Whole New World Original and Remake

Favorite Jasmine's Reason to Go to the Marketplace Remake

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine meeting Remake

Favorite Cave of Wonders scene Original and Remake

Favorite Genie Introduction Original and Remake

Favorite I Wish to Be a Prince scene Remake

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine reunion Remake

Favorite Magic Carpet Ride Remake

Favorite Jafar's Hyponotism Remake

Favorite Jafar Taking Over Agrabah Original

Favorite Banishment in Snow Remake

Favorite Battle With Jafar Remake and original (for giant bird vs carpet chase) I wanted to make that clear because Jafar as a Genie looks too realistic in remake and looks more menacing in a demon genie form in the original.

Favorite Jasmine tricking Aladdin into revealing who he is original and remake

Favorite kiss original

Favorite almost drowning remake

Favorite Aladdn/Genie argument original

Favorite version of the lamp being stolen original

Favorite Jasmine picking Aladdin Remake

Favorite Aladdin: Original
Favorite Jasmine: Remake
Favorite Animal Sidekicks (Rajah, Iago, Abu): Original
Favorite Genie: Original
Favorite Carpet: Original
Favorite Jafar: Original
Favorite Sultan: Original
Favorite Cave of Wonders: Original
Favorite Arabian Nights: Original
Favorite One Jump Ahead: Original
Favorite One Jump Ahead Reprise: Original
Favorite Friend Like Me: Original
Favorite Prince Ali: Original
Favorite A Whole New World: Original
Favorite Jasmine's Reason to Go to the Marketplace: Remake
Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine meeting: Remake (Slightly! Hard choice!)
Favorite Cave of Wonders scene: Original
Favorite Genie Introduction: Original
Favorite I Wish to Be a Prince scene: Original
Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine reunion: Remake
Favorite Magic Carpet Ride: Original
Favorite Jafar's Hypnotism: Original
Favorite Jafar Taking Over Agrabah: Original
Favorite Banishment in Snow: Original
Favorite Battle With Jafar: Original
Favorite Jasmine tricking Aladdin into revealing who he is: Remake
Favorite kiss: Original
Favorite almost drowning: Original
Favorite Aladdn/Genie argument: Original
Favorite version of the lamp being stolen: Original
Favorite Jasmine picking Aladdin: Remake

Favorite Aladdin : original

Favorite Jasmine : original

Favorite Animal Sidekicks (Rajah, Iago, Abu) : original

Favorite Genie : love the new one he was hilarious but original

Favorite Carpet : original

Favorite Jafar : original he was scary and charismatic on the contrary of the one in the remake

Favorite Sultan : remake

Favorite Cave of Wonders : original

Favorite Arabian Nights : original more powerful

Favorite One Jump Ahead : original

Favorite One Jump Ahead Reprise : original

Favorite Friend Like Me : i love the one in the remake but original

Favorite Prince Ali : original by far

Favorite A Whole New World : original

Favorite Jasmine's Reason to Go to the Marketplace : remake

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine meeting : original was more funny

Favorite Cave of Wonders scene : original

Favorite Genie Introduction : remake

Favorite I Wish to Be a Prince scene : remake

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine reunion : original

Favorite Magic Carpet Ride : original

Favorite Jafar's Hyponotism : original

Favorite Jafar Taking Over Agrabah : original

Favorite Banishment in Snow : original

Favorite Battle With Jafar : original by far

Favorite Jasmine tricking Aladdin into revealing who he is : original

Favorite kiss : original

Favorite almost drowning : remake

Favorite Aladdn/Genie argument : remake

Favorite version of the lamp being stolen : original

Favorite Jasmine picking Aladdin : original

Aladdin: Both
Jasmine: Remake
Sidekicks: Original, I think they have funnier moments although I do like Rajah and Abu in the remake.
Genie: Original
Carpet: Original, I feel like it had more character there, but I still liked it in the remake.
Jafar: Original, he was more menacing, although I liked hearing his backstory in the remake.
Sultan: Original
Cave of Wonders: Original
Arabian Nights: Remake, more powerful, in my opinion.
One Jump Ahead: Original, although it was a good in the remake and I liked how Jasmine was there.
One jump Ahead Reprise: Original because of the vocals.
Friend Like Me: Original
Prince Ali: Original
A Whole New World: Original
Jasmine’s Reason to Leave: Remake, less selfish.
Aladdin and Jasmine meeting: Original, it was more drawn out.
Cave of Wonders scene: Remake
Genie Introduction: Original
I Wish to Be a Prince scene: Remake
Reunion: Remake
Carpet Ride: Original
Hypnotism: Original, although I liked how he attempted to hypnotize Aladdin in the remake.
Jafar taking over Agrabah: Both
Banishment in the Snow: Remake
Battle with Jafar: Original, I liked how he turned into a giant snake.
Jasmine tricking Aladdin: Remake, she’s less aggressive.
Kiss: Original
Almost Drowning: Remake, I thought it was more intense with the music, and I liked how Jafar was more prominent before Aladdin was thrown into the water.
Argument: Original
Lamp Stolen: Original, made Iago more useful.
Jasmine picking Aladdin: Remake

Favorite Aladdin Original/The old one, where he is not portrayed as an inept social fool.

Favorite Jasmine DEFINITELY the original/ the old one, where Jasmine is not a power-hungry politician, and where she speaks her own mind about her love life.

Favorite Animal Sidekicks (Rajah, Iago, Abu) Original

Favorite Genie Robin Williams/ original

Favorite Carpet Original

Favorite Jafar DEFINITELY the original

Favorite Sultan The oiginal

Favorite Cave of Wonders The original. The CGI in the new one was cringe-worthy.

Favorite Arabian Nights The original. They changed the lyrics in the new one, and it didn't pack the same punch.

Favorite One Jump Ahead The original

Favorite One Jump Ahead Reprise The original

Favorite Friend Like Me The original

Favorite Prince Ali The original

Favorite A Whole New World The original ( parts of the remake sounded like High School Musical)

Favorite Jasmine's Reason to Go to the Marketplace The original

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine meeting The original

Favorite Cave of Wonders scene The original

Favorite Genie Introduction The original

Favorite I Wish to Be a Prince scene The original

Favorite Aladdin and Jasmine reunion The original

Favorite Magic Carpet Ride THE ORIGINAL

Favorite Jafar's Hyponotism The original

Favorite Jafar Taking Over Agrabah The original

Favorite Banishment in Snow The original

Favorite Battle With Jafar The ORIGINAL. The new remake ending was very underwhelming.

Banishment in the Snow: The original.
Battle with Jafar: The original. I missed the giant heroic snake fight scene.
Jasmine tricking Aladdin: The original. She's absolutely boring in the remake.
First Kiss: Original
Almost Drowning: The original. Jafar was far too talky in the remake. He really just sucked out the momentum in the scene...
Aladdin and Jasmine Arguing: Original
The lamp gets stolen again: Original. Iago was given much more screentime in the plot.
Jasmine picking Aladdin: The original. The remake version felt flat.