answer this question

Disney Princess Question

Beauty and the Beast: Old vs New

I'm writing an article comparing the original Disney Princess movies and their remakes and I would like to know everyone's thoughts about both movies and which they prefer; original or remake.

Just answer the following with "original" or "remake". You can either just say one of those two words or you can answer and give a reason.

Favorite Belle

Favorite Beast

Favorite Servants

Favorite Gaston

Favorite Le Fou

Favorite Maurice

Favorite Belle/Little Town

Favorite Belle Reprise

Favorite Gaston song

Favorite Be Our Guest

Favorite Something There

Favorite Beauty and the Beast

Favorite Mob song

Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle

Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father

Favorite Going to the West Wing

Favorite Wolf Attack

Favorite Library scene

Favorite Dance

Favorite Releasing Belle scene

Favorite Beast vs Gaston

Favorite Transformation

Deadline will be June 21st!

 BB2010 posted over a year ago
next question »

Disney Princess Answers

deedragongirl said:
Original: Mainly because I grew up with Paige's voice!

Remake: Robbie Benson is scary.

Original: They're more lively than their remake counterparts!

Original: Richard White's voice makes me tremble.

Remake: I love Josh Gad

Original: Comical and sympathetic at the same time.

Original: The scene has more charisma!

Original: The music and the scenery are breathless!

Remake: I support the LGBT community.

Original: Colourful

Original: The chemistry between the two characters instantly click.

Original: The whole scene says it all!

Remake: At least Lefou redeems himself!

Remake: The original doesn't make any sense at all.

Original: Belle clears a misunderstanding with her dad.

Original: At least the Beast is scary in this, the remake is very stiff.

Original: The scene works out!

Original: The scene and the music.

Original: The dance is more lively.

Original: I feel bad for the beast during this scene.

Remake: Despite that I'm anti-gun, this scene is more dramatic than the original.

Original: The transformation in the remake is rush and nothing special.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Why do you think Maurice finding the castle in the original doesn't make sense? And what do you mean about supporting the LGBT communtiy for the song Gaston?
BB2010 posted over a year ago
*
Because it lives a loophole later on, especially Philippe the horse. Well, in the song Gaston for the remake version, Lefou is gay.
deedragongirl posted over a year ago
*
ok jw
BB2010 posted over a year ago
sunnyfields said:

Favorite Belle: Remake (I like that she's an inventor)

Favorite Beast: Remake

Favorite Servants: Original

Favorite Gaston: Remake

Favorite Le Fou: Remake (I like his personality more. He is less stupid and more theatrical.)

Favorite Maurice: Remake

Favorite Belle/Little Town: Original

Favorite Belle Reprise: Original

Favorite Gaston song: Remake

Favorite Be Our Guest: Orginal

Favorite Something There: Remake

Favorite Beauty and the Beast: Original

Favorite Mob song: Remake

Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle: Remake

Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father: Original

Favorite Going to the West Wing: Remake

Favorite Wolf Attack: Remake

Favorite Library scene: Remake

Favorite Dance: Original

Favorite Releasing Belle scene: Remake

Favorite Beast vs Gaston: Remake

Favorite Transformation: Original
select as best answer

Favorite Belle: Remake (I like that she's an inventor)

Favorite Beast: Remake 

Favorite Servants: Original

Favorite Gaston: Remake

Favorite Le Fou: Remake (I like his personality more. He is less stupid and more theatrical.)

Favorite Maurice: Remake 

Favorite Belle/Little Town: Original

Favorite Belle Reprise: Original

Favorite Gaston song: Remake

Favorite Be Our Guest: Orginal

Favorite Something There: Remake

Favorite Beauty and the Beast: Original

Favorite Mob song: Remake

Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle: Remake

Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father: Original

Favorite Going to the West Wing: Remake

Favorite Wolf Attack: Remake

Favorite Library scene: Remake

Favorite Dance: Original

Favorite Releasing Belle scene: Remake

Favorite Beast vs Gaston: Remake

Favorite Transformation: Original
posted over a year ago 
HoltNLucy4Ever said:
Favorite Belle: Original
Favorite Beast: Original
Favorite Servants: Original
Favorite Gaston: Original
Favorite Le Fou: Original
Favorite Maurice: Original
Favorite Belle/Little Town: Original
Favorite Belle Reprise: Original
Favorite Gaston song: Original
Favorite Be Our Guest: Original
Favorite Something There: Original
Favorite Beauty and the Beast: Original
Favorite Mob song: Original
Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle: Original
Favorite Belle Staying For Her Father: Original
Favorite Going To The West Wing: Original
Favorite Wolf Attack: Original
Favorite Library song: Original
Favorite Dance: Original
Favorite Releasing Belle scene: Original
Favorite Beast vs Gaston: Original
Favorite Transformation: Original


select as best answer
Favorite Belle: Original
Favorite Beast: Original
Favorite Servants: Original
Favorite Gaston: Original
Favorite Le Fou: Original
Favorite Maurice: Original
Favorite Belle/Little Town: Original
Favorite Belle Reprise: Original
Favorite Gaston song: Original
Favorite Be Our Guest: Original
Favorite Something There: Original
Favorite Beauty and the Beast: Original
Favorite Mob song: Original
Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle: Original
Favorite Belle Staying For Her Father: Original
Favorite Going To The West Wing: Original
Favorite Wolf Attack: Original
Favorite Library song: Original
Favorite Dance: Original
Favorite Releasing Belle scene: Original
Favorite Beast vs Gaston: Original
Favorite Transformation: Original
posted over a year ago 
*
so far you are the only one who said they prefer original over remake all the way through :P
BB2010 posted over a year ago
*
^I feel this way also. Should I even bother posting, or save you space?
wavesurf posted over a year ago
*
^no no go ahead and post! Even if you're only preferring original or remake for every point I still want to hear everyone's opinions for the articles!
BB2010 posted over a year ago
*
^Ok. :)
wavesurf posted over a year ago
wavesurf said:
Favorite Belle Paige O'Hara (I don't think Emma Watson can actually "act." Every time she appears on screen, she is herself. She never "embodies" and "lives in the character" like Meryl Streep, Kate Winslet, Sean Bean, or Leonardo Dicaprio do).

Favorite Beast Robby Benson. Dan Stevens lacked oomph and was just okay.

Favorite Servants the original. OMG the CGI in the new remake was an eyesore!

Favorite Gaston Richard White. Luke Evan's was just really disgusting ( not to be blamed on him, totally) because Disney turned Gaston into a multiple times pre-meditated murderer.

Favorite Le Fou Original. Josh Gad was kind of forgettable.

Favorite Maurice Original. In the remake, he had a song, but it bored me a lot.

Favorite Belle/Little Town Original.

Favorite Belle Reprise Original

Favorite Gaston song DEFINITELY the original.

Favorite Be Our Guest DEFINITELY the original.

Favorite Something There DEFINITELY the original.

Favorite Beauty and the Beast DEFINITELY the original.

Favorite Mob song the original.

Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle the original score.

Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father the original score.

Favorite Going to the West Wing the original score.

Favorite Wolf Attack the original score.

Favorite Library scene the original.

Favorite Dance the original.

Favorite Releasing Belle scene the original.

Favorite Beast vs Gaston -- the ONLY one that even pulls on my nostalgia: the original.

Favorite Transformation DEFINITELY the original with the original score!!!!!

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
jsyk I don't mean the scores from Finding the Castle, Belle Staying for Her Father, Going to the West Wing, or Wolf Attack. I meant the scenes themselves
BB2010 posted over a year ago
*
that is unless you like both the scenes and the scores
BB2010 posted over a year ago
*
^Thanks! :)
wavesurf posted over a year ago
PrincessAyeka12 said:
Favorite Belle - Original

Favorite Beast - Original

Favorite Servants - Original

Favorite Gaston - Original

Favorite Le Fou - Original

Favorite Maurice - Original

Favorite Belle/Little Town - Original

Favorite Belle Reprise - Original

Favorite Gaston song - Original

Favorite Be Our Guest - Original

Favorite Something There - Original

Favorite Beauty and the Beast - Original

Favorite Mob song - Original

Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle - Remake

Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father - Original

Favorite Going to the West Wing - Original

Favorite Wolf Attack - Original

Favorite Library scene - Original

Favorite Dance - Original

Favorite Releasing Belle scene - Original

Favorite Beast vs Gaston - Original

Favorite Transformation - Original
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
KataraLover said:
I think both movies are equally good and even made my own article comparing the two in my own way.

Favorite Belle: Remake
Favorite Beast: Remake
Favorite Servants: Original
Favorite Gaston: Remake
Favorite Le Fou: Remake
Favorite Maurice: Original
Favorite Belle/Little Town: Remake
Favorite Belle Reprise: Original
Favorite Gaston song: Remake
Favorite Be Our Guest: Original
Favorite Something There: Original
Favorite Beauty and the Beast: Original
Favorite Mob song: Original
Favorite Maurice Finding the Castle: Remake
Favorite Belle Staying for Her Father: Original
Favorite Going to the West Wing: Original
Favorite Wolf Attack: Original
Favorite Library scene: Remake
Favorite Dance: Original
Favorite Releasing Belle scene: Remake
Favorite Beast vs Gaston: Remake
Favorite Transformation: Original
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »