I don't like Twilight but if I had to choose I'm Team Edward for two reasons-
A) Robert Pattinson
B) EDWARD HAD HER FIRST!!!! geez
Posted over a year ago
Why don't you make the motto "Twilight Hating, if you're a Twihard refute our arguments I dare you and we'll ignore everything you say because 90% of this club is made of haters", that would be more subtle and less confusing.
Posted over a year ago
Yes, people are not allowed to critique art/pop culture. You must blindly love everything or else you're a "hater." Wouldn't want to make you actually have to THINK about things.over a year ago
/as the time goes by, I appreciate the story of Twilight more and more and various levels. I'm not sure why this is, but it's lovely.
Posted over a year ago
I like the series, but when i say "i see the gaiety" i don't mean it as a compliment. I mean, it's a bit gay/dumb/retarded in some ways, but in other ways, it's a good book.over a year ago
Okay... Well gaiety means lighthearted and cheerful. It has nothing to do with homosexuality or mental disorders, but if you really are saying that you can see all the homosexuality and mental disorders in Twilight, then I'm gonig to go ahead and completely ignore you from now on.over a year ago
If people spent as much energy attacking mainstream shit written by men (and assumed appealing to “all audiences”) as they did attacking “misogynistic” books written by women for women I’d be impressed.
But i guess i just don't know how important it is to to ridicule women and girls for enjoying literature that doesn't measure up to exacting and wholesome standards of feminist perfection.
It's for their own good!
Posted over a year ago
Finally, I found a Twilight fan club where I don't have to see all the "Who's way hotter?" "Who's your favorite character?" and all the hype EVERY TIME! *sigh in relief* And...I don't have to really see JUST ABOUT EVERYONE GUSH ABOUT THE SERIES! I like the books, but that was it for me!
Posted over a year ago
Just talk about Twilight, pretty much. The difference between here and the Twilight spot is that you don't have to actually like Twilight to participate, and the boring questions like "Who's hotter, Edward or Jacob" aren't here. There are a few articles about "the rules" I'll link you.over a year ago
This spot needs some major tlc. Go back to the days when the original cats were here having civilized conversation about flaws and what we liked...
Posted over a year ago
one of the reasons i hate twilight so much is because of the lack of researh Even diehard twilight fans can't argue with this ----> How could Rosalie have been rich in the great depresion if her father was a banker?
Posted over a year ago
Too true. She also wrote "It was like the GD was like a rumor". Oh yeah because you totally drove past the starving homeless children begging for food, mothers selling their bodies to provide, and dads fleeing out of state to find jobs all while selling all their furniture, cars, jewelry, and facing foreclosure. Looks like someone didn't pay attention during 8th grade history.over a year ago
Of course people can argue with this. It doesn't matter how many times the answer is explained to people, they will willingly decide to completely forget everything you told them an hour later.over a year ago
To answer your question, thousands of banks survived the great depression by denying loans. They didn't lend all their money out, so they didn't lose it.over a year ago
@cassie-1-2-3: you're acting as if u don't h8 anything urself. I've seen the stuff u put up in the Harry potter vs twilight stuff. U h8 Harry potter and ur telling us we can't h8 twilight!!!! That's rubbish!!over a year ago
I don't hate Harry Potter. I just don't like it. It's okay to not like something. Not liknig Harry Potter is not at all a hobby of mine.over a year ago
i agrer with zar-far11 you're acting if u don't hate anything urself u hate hp and your saying others can't hate twightlight that is just messed up !over a year ago
I just remembered something.
When I was reading Twilight my mother found it on the kitchen table. She said she was worried about my father, because I wouldn't read - quote - such crap xD
Posted over a year ago
Call me crazy, but I think the sparkling actually makes sense, considering their density.
It makes a lot more sense to me than the more typical legend of burning or turning to dust in the sun. Is there really any semi-logical explanation behind it?
Posted over a year ago
No Offense to Twilight lovers, but I don't love Twilight nor accept the forms of Vampires sparkling in the daylight. I was born in the era of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, where the vampires actually turned to dust in the sunlight and had better defined characteristics. The original Dracula and the movie Underworld portray vampires beautifully.
Posted over a year ago
If you don't like Twilight why are u apart of this page! it's called the "Critical Analysis of Twilight" not Dracular, Buffy or The lost Boys!over a year ago
Well honestly sparkling didn't bother me that much. It's not like writers are not allowed to come up with their own interpretations of fictional creatures such as vampires. It was mostly the writing style and awfully cliched love triangle that annoyed me. Had Twilight been ONE book I think it would have been much more bearable.over a year ago
really?? i read teh Twilight books like way before they were famous, and thought they were not bad.. but as the books went by and then the movies started.. i begun to dislike the series.. i felt after awhile the story didn't appeal to me.. though i still would say i think the very first book is not so bad..over a year ago
i haven't read Midnight Sun, I've been curious about it. The books are decent. I just love the way the werewolves look in the movies. That's precisely what Iover a year ago
I've changed my mind. I've gone over to the other side. I think Twilight's problematic. I still think this club needs major clean-up to stop it from being an anti club. Civility and respect are more important, and the anti material that doesn't critically analyze some detail (like that pic of Dracula screaming because he read Twilight) just comes across as mean. Respectfully disagree, don't bully.
Posted over a year ago
I personally like Twilight (more so with the books), but I am annoyed with stuff in the books as well as stuff the added onto or left out of the movies. I don't like that Bella is careless of her parents' love for her in favor of being with a neverending *person*, Edward suggesting in the books that Bella do the nasty with Jacob to have that baby experience, Edward being too controlling, & the uselessness of the *triangle*, when Jacob <3 Nessie & Bella realizing she loves him as a friend. Oi. =/
Posted over a year ago
No offense to twilight lovers: I don't like twilight, don't call me stupid or anything for hating twilight, this is where you can talk badly or well about twilight, but if you don't agree, don't comment, just respect people's opinion. I believe that twilight is stephanie meyer's love dream, and that clumsiness is not an imperfection. But, i have yet to read twilight, so i'll see but so far, based on what people who like twilight have told me, it's just not my kind of book.
Posted over a year ago
Look, we should all RESPECT EACH OTHERS OPINIONS! If you dont' like Twilight, you don't have to bash it! If you love Twilight, you don't have to scream at people who don't!over a year ago
true but bella really annoys me. edward deserves better. she just makes people miserable and is the causs eof most problems. and i just dont like herover a year ago
there's this GUY in my class who reads twilight, and actually LIKES it... i was ranting at him about the awfulness of the series...
Posted over a year ago
Sorry...that would be me. See, this club usually never shows up on my mosaic, but I want it to, and the best way to do that is to add a link or a video, because then it'll show up at the top of your mosaic..... I do this with all the clubs I want displayed on my mosaic.....sorry if it bothers you, :)over a year ago
I'm reading the Twilight stoof.
Eh, it's not the most AWFUL book I've ever read
*coughexodusisathin-veiledgorebookcough*
I don't LOVE it...... right now it's mediocre at best to me, but it's not awful.
Posted over a year ago
and another thing i can't stand now.
harry potter taught me to value friendship, be brave, and not to ever give up
twilight taught me girls are nothing without a boyfriend!
thats what i hate most. bella needs edward or she crumples up in the forest like a little bitch. whe ron left hermione she still looked for horcruxes with out him. she did not get depressed and atempt sucside to hear hrons voice again!!!
Posted over a year ago
well, she did get pretty upset over ron leaving in the book, she used to cry herself to sleep, and Harry could hear her. I'm not trying to contradict you, I'm agreeing. I still kind of like twilight, but now I'm very aware of how Stephanie Meyer is turning women into objects that have to have a guy, or else they should "forfeit any desire to live"-New Moon. I like being a feminist...:Dover a year ago
i agree i forgot about that but even id hermione cried she still tryed to get through it as were bella got depressed for like, 4 months. and i respect that u like twilight :)over a year ago
Exactly. Hermione doesn't need a man to survive, while Bella is unnaturaly obssessed and depended on Edward. They can't even be compared as role models.over a year ago
i agree, the face that bella needs a man makes me think shes not even fit to be a role model. she hasn't really done anything while worthwhile. she always lets jacob or edward do the work.over a year ago
i used to love twilight but now after reading harry potter and other vampire books i can't even read it anymore. the author is not origial at all, except with the fact that edward sparkles like a fairy princess! she totally stole jacob black idea from sirus black! i mean turning into a wolf and riding a motercyle?! thats really origial...not! and the covers from another book! i love vampires but i really hate edward because i hate stalkers and hes a sparkling stalking fairy princess
Posted over a year ago
I used to love twilight but now i realise how rubbish it is... plus I've seen the fans. And, honestly, if I had a penny for every time Meyer said Edward was like granite *rolls eyes* i'd be richer than the author (I honestly don't even know how her trash took off)
Posted over a year ago
It's not a guessing game. It's just stating your opinion. Who you like better or who you think Bella should have chose, or who you would have chosen, if put in her position.over a year ago
Think I've taken an ironic 360. First I loved it, then I realised it was terrible, now I have so much fun paying it out I kind of like it again. In any case I can't WAIT for Breaking Dawn. It's terribleness will be my entertainment for the year.
Ironic 360.
Posted over a year ago
I used to think it'd be great for the lulz but after seeing the leaked pic of Edward holding just born Renesmee, with blood all round his mouth... I'm having second thoughts.over a year ago
This is random, but do the anti-twilighters like The Vampire Diaries? And for the ones who do like Twilgiht, which do you prefer? Because I'm an anti, and before I watched The Vampire Diaries I hated vampires, because of the whole twilight thing but The Vampire Diaries redeemed vampires for me. Two words Damon Salvatore! :D
Posted over a year ago
Hello, kitties! Momcat's back - and the CAT ain't what it used to be. =( Pleeeeeaaaaase come check out the new forum thread so we can all brainstorm on ways to turn our beloved spot back into the fun, friendly, intelligent place it was meant to be! We desperately need to get our claws trimmed! link
Posted over a year ago
Wait - I realized that the first time we see Cedric Diggory in hp he's jumping out of a tree! It's the vampire creeping into him!
Posted over a year ago
I really do wonder if any interesting thought provoking comments will be placed on this wall or will it only be subject to people making up teams that aren't even relevant and exclaiming that they love certain characters... Just me wondering if this spot has lost the analysis
Posted over a year ago
More it is not used for analysis. Eg. I could post i think Robert Pattinson acted better in this film than in the previous films. It is not all about the less than 3 signsover a year ago
Yes, but I don't think she'd mind since she drank straight blood in Breaking Dawn. What I want to know is what about when it's her time of month?over a year ago
I thought this was a good spot...until I realized this spot is mostly twilight haters. 1. I love twilight 2. The books were WELL WRITTEN 3. Edward/Rob is hot. xD
Posted over a year ago
o3o Twilight IS well written, and the potential for it was BRILLIANT... But... The way Twilight was drawn out just... failed. The only reason it got so popular was because A) There was a gap in the market and B) It has hot guys in the movie.over a year ago