I love Alyssa.

Shannen is such a dramma queen

Ditto to the above answer. She has had problems on every show shes been on...

Alyssa didn`t do anything wrong, she was just the young hot one getting the attention & old Shannen Doherty got jealous

i agree phoebe puts the charm in charmed

Actually, I think they should've just sorted it out, you know? I mean, it was a bit ridiculaous that she left. But hey, better her than Alyssa.

xxx

i dont think i wuda been able to hack charmed without another season of phoebe and cole!!

Shannen doherty is the best actress of all time i love her she is the best fantastic brilliant but there both brlliant so i couldent pick

i liked that prue left cuz then there wouldnt be paige and she is awesome oh and i love henry super cute together

I was very conflicted when I heard that Shannen Doherty was leaving the show. I was even more conflicted when I heard Rose McGowan was joining. I knew her as Marilyn Manson's ex-girlfriend and the freaky girl from "Jawbreaker." But, Paige quickly grew on me and know I don't even like to watch episodes from before Prue died because Prue annoys me.

I liked Prue, but i liked Phoebe better.

Although Shannen did leasve i can't imagine Alyssa (Pheobe) not being in the show

I personally wish that I could have all the sisters.But,really,if I had to lose one,it'd be Phoebe.She can be really irritating and immature.And the way she acted towards Cole when he was honestly trying to be good in season five permanently turned me off.

i didn't want any of them tomleave but if i had to choose it would be none but there isn't an option for that

I hate when an actor/actress leaves a job because they have personal problems with someone else... it's your job, deal with it outside of work!

i love phoebe..

"I personally wish that I could have all the sisters.But,really,if I had to lose one,it'd be Phoebe.She can be really irritating and immature.And the way she acted towards Cole when he was honestly trying to be good in season five permanently turned me off."

It's not like Alyssa Milano wrote the lines herself .. Julian McMahon chose to leave to be on Nip/ Tuck

i couldnt pick i love them both

they had conflict with each other?

well i think that no one should have left

Just to let everyone know; it was Shanon Dorety who started all of the problems
on the show not Alyssa! Shanon started to think that she was better than everyone
else and should get way more spotlight than
the rest of the actors/actresses! That is why the
producers fired Shanon and not Alyssa! Shanon is the one who started fights with everyone
back stage!

sorry didn;t know

prue should leave in stead of phoebe

Shannon is a BRILLIANT actress but I have read a BUNCH of times that she is just a bitch!

OK I PICKED PRUE.

actully in my openion
no one should have left the show its really redicueles that they fought over shomthing stupid..but actully alyssa brought more attention
she got the carisma although i like prue!!!
but it happend so what can we do??!!

Prueeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

i like them both so... but if i had to pick it would have been alyssa. i mean there wasn't much to do with her character after cole and the way she acted towards him in s.5 - was v. annoying. jus feel that charmed wouldn't have suffered in prductn standards is shannen was there and there was so much left to do with shannen's character. plus, i wud love to see prue and paige together, i think they would get on well

Alyssa is my idol so...

now one

I really, really don't like Shannen. I find it hard to like prue because of her. Plus... she can't really act.

Shannen is an okay actress but shes such a bitch...
Plus Alyssa is WAY more nicer, better, and hotter

Shannen is an okay actress but shes such a bitch...
Plus Alyssa is WAY more nicer, better, and hotter

@Casper15 and how do you KNOW THIS????? do you or ANYONE who claims this know for SURE?? sorry but Alyssa is a little brat!! Shannen should have STAYED and Alyssa should have got the boot!!! if you havent worked with Shannen and only going by what articles say etc then you have no say on how off set shit happens. a lot of people dont like Shannen cuz shes an out spoken chick who says how it is and not let people walk all over her!! this is the reason i adore Shannen, im not saying shes not a bitch she probably is but sorry shes a strong minded woman!

i don't know as i loved them both so much i hate that shannen left but at the same time i love paige and i would never want to have seen alyssa milano leave either,
i love charmed just the way it is :D xx

I didn't like shannen doherty in charmed and alyssa milano put charm in charmed and shannen doherty got fired off of the show because she has a diease where she can't eat anything but she won't die and plus alyssa milano is away better actor then shannen doherty was i'm just saying and if you don't agree i really don't care sodon't bother to disagree because it's my opinion

I'm team Shannen, and yeah I liked Phoebe but I LOVED Prue.

I can´t choose , I love both. No one should left

The only thing I know for sure is that Holly Marie Combs worked with Shannen for three seasons and Alyssa for eight and yet was best friends with Shannen. So I get the feeling that everything wasn't completely on Shannen. I'm biased since I like Prue a lot more than Phoebe, but it's still something to think about.