Well, I'm tight on time at the moment so no time to look for images (I'm sure we can find them for you) but we can always have stakes as the early prizes, maybe bunnies for middle prizes and the the top prize could be the scyth sort of thing.

amulets
cross
books
gachnar (hes a mini demon)
orb thingis (dont know how there spelt but what brings back a soul)
kittens
ill come back if i think of any more!

the orbs are the orbs of thessula (I believe that is spelled correctly)

also can add to the list

pig (for Mr. Gordo)
hearts
gravestones

okay well me and nosemuffin were messenging earlier and she sppears to have forgotten to post them so using what we already and have what me and nosemuffin came up with what about these 17 in general highest to lowest, now i don't mind i love all buffy but i am fairly freaky when it comes to organising and felt the need to make a list so please change/play around with/scrap but i have tried to put them in order of what i think is most significant

1. scythes (by the way papa it's a special looking one not like the grim reeper style, not sure how we could do a mini one)
2. Amulets
3. Orbs
4. Swords
5. Keys
6. Crossbows
7. Crosses
8. Stakes
9. Railroad spikes
10. Fangs
11. Demon horns
12. blood drops
13. Gravestones
14. Books
15. Glasses (the wearing kinds not the drinking kind)
16. Pigs
17. Unicorns

Also for substitution

- hearts (I don’t get this reference)
- kittens (miss kitty?)
-yellow crayons
-flowered onions
-griffins (angel’s tattoo)
-faiths tribal tatto (again can we make one?)
-giles’ tattoo (ditto)

okay who do i prop for the wiked new prizes, their awesome!

Great list Debs! You and Nose are amazing