Do you think Elliott Yamin should have won Season 5? Poll Results - American Idol

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

American Idol Do you think Elliott Yamin should have won Season 5?

106 fans picked:

Chris Daughtry should have won!

48%

(added by tuneyloon7)

YES he was robbed.

25%

None of them should of won

12%

No Taylor won fair and square

11%

Both are wrong McFee (yuck) should have won

not sure

(added by pikakel19)

CullenCult posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

CullenCult picked YES he was robbed.:

I thought this question wuld be fun to see what people really
think....... ELLIOTT YAMIN RULES!!!!

posted over a year ago.

None of them should of won

lutrina picked None of them should of won:

I think Chris was the best season 5 contestant, he should have won. Elliott is good too though.

posted over a year ago.

last edited over a year ago

moosie picked YES he was robbed.:

Well, let's see...Kat and Taylor were both dropped from their record labels, and Elliott is still going strong. That ought to tell everyone something right there.
Chris was good, too, but I think he got a little smug and it did him in with the viewing/voting public.

posted over a year ago.